← Protestant or evangelical
Salvation and grace

Why purgatory? Isn't Christ's blood enough?

Read it as an illustrated story · 9 min

Yes, 's blood is enough, and Catholics believe that too. Purgatory isn't a second payment or a second chance. The Catholic Church teaches it's a final cleansing for people who are already saved: Christ finishing his work in them before they see God.

Check it in the Church’s own documents

Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.

The objection is strong, and it comes straight from the . On the cross Jesus said It is finished.

If his death did everything, then any cleansing after death sounds like making up for part of it yourself.

Many Protestants see no need for it at all. The classic Presbyterian statement of faith says believers are made perfect in holiness the moment they die. Besides and , it says, the Bible knows no other place.10

What purgatory is not

So start with what the Catholic Church actually teaches. The says the people in are indeed assured of their eternal .1

It isn't a second chance, a third destination, or a place where anyone earns heaven.

It's for people who die as God's friends but aren't finished yet. In the Catechism's words, they go through a final cleansing so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven.1

We die unfinished

Be honest about how most of us die. Still carrying grudges. Still with bad habits. Still loving God and other people only halfway.

Even Lutherans and Catholics, writing together in 1999, agreed that when we stand before God, everything in our life that is wrong will be uncovered and will not enter eternal life.3

So something happens between the person who dies and the person who sees God.

Many Protestants say it happens in an instant. Catholics call it purgatory, and don't claim to know how long it takes.7

Catholic teaching does use the word punishment for it. But it doesn't mean God getting even. The Catechism says it's not a kind of vengeance inflicted by God from without.2

It means the damage that comes from the very nature of : the habits, wounds and wrong attachments that are still there after we're forgiven, and still need healing.2

Think of it like this

Imagine a dad who loves his son, and has always been good to him. But the son wants to live his own way. One day he walks out, and cuts his dad off completely. His dad did nothing to deserve it. It breaks his heart, and for years he lives with that hurt.

His dad keeps calling, but the son never picks up. Instead he's busy partying, drinking night after night with his friends, and slowly it wrecks his liver. One day he ends up in hospital, and the doctors say he's dying.

His dad hears, and comes straight away. The son can barely look at him, but he whispers I'm sorry. And right there at the bed, after all that hurt, his dad forgives him completely. But forgiving him doesn't fix his liver. The son is still dying.

So the dad does the one thing that can save him. He gives his son part of his own liver. Nobody forced him to. Forgiving him was free. Saving him cost the dad a big operation and weeks of pain.

Even then, the son doesn't walk out of hospital that afternoon. His body has to take the new liver, and getting well takes weeks. Some days it hurts. But those weeks don't add anything to what his dad gave. They're his dad's gift, taking hold in him.

God did something like the dad, and more. Christians believe the one God is Father, Son and . God the Son became one of us. That's Jesus. To heal what's killing us, he gave his whole life on a cross, and rose again.

So here's the Catholic picture of purgatory. God forgives us for free, and nothing is missing from what Jesus gave. Purgatory is the last part of the healing: his gift finishing its work in us, the way the son's body takes the new liver.

Where the idea comes from

describes believers whose life's work is tested by fire on the last day. If it burns up, they'll still be saved, but only as through fire.4

Notice that it's the work that burns, but the person still passes through the fire. Catholics read that as a cleansing, though Paul doesn't spell it out.

Jews before Jesus prayed for their dead.7 The book that shows it, 2 Maccabees, is in Catholic and Bibles but not ones, so for many readers it settles nothing.

But look at what the first Christians did. A 's gravestone from around AD 200 asks every fellow believer who reads it to pray for him: let him pray for Abercius.5 Abercius was the bishop's own name.

A writer in North Africa at the same time says Christians make offerings for the dead on the anniversaries of their deaths.6

Christians were praying for their dead long before anyone argued about it. The Orthodox Church still does, though it doesn't describe a cleansing punishment the way Catholics do.7

The fire is Christ himself

The Catholic Church set out this teaching at meetings of its bishops, the last of them the in the 1500s.1

Trent's decree on purgatory was careful. It said only that purgatory exists and that the dead are helped by our prayers and by the , which is the Catholic Sunday service. The decree said nothing about a place, a length of time or a fire.9

It even told preachers to keep the more difficult and subtle questions out of sermons for ordinary people.9

There's one more ruling from Trent that many Protestants quote, and it's only fair to face it. It's called 30. It says that when God forgives us, the guilt is wiped away, and so is the eternal punishment, being lost for ever.12

But it condemns anyone who says there's no debt of temporal punishment left, either in this life or in the next in Purgatory.12 Temporal means for a time. And punishment means what it meant earlier: not God getting even, but the damage sin leaves, still being healed.

An older , at Florence in Italy in 1439, was blunter. It spoke of people who die truly sorry before they have made satisfaction.13

Their souls, it said, are cleansed after death by cleansing pains. Satisfaction means making amends.13

pointed to Trent's canon 30 in 1999, when he explained purgatory. He said those being cleansed are already in the love of Christ who removes from them the remnants of imperfection.11

To many Protestants, making amends for sin sounds like paying off a debt Jesus already paid. It's a fair worry about the words.

Catholics read it with the Catechism: forgiveness does not remedy all the disorders sin has caused.14 Making amends is part of getting well.

In 2007 Benedict XVI offered a picture some Protestants find moving:

Some recent theologians are of the opinion that the fire which both burns and saves is Christ himself, the Judge and Saviour. The encounter with him is the decisive act of judgement. Before his gaze all falsehood melts away.
Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi (2007), 47

In that picture, purgatory is meeting Jesus face to face, and being healed by it.

And the stain our sins leave? Benedict XVI said it has already been burned away through Christ's Passion.7 Meeting him is when that reaches all the way into us. In 's words, we experience and we absorb the overwhelming power of his love.7

Does it hurt? Where is it? How long?

These are usually the first things people want to know. The Catholic Church says less about them than most people expect.

Is it a place? Pope John Paul II said no. The word purgatory does not indicate a place, but a condition of existence.11

Those being made ready, he said, aren't cut off from God. They're immersed in the love of Christ, and still joined to the saints in heaven and to us.11

Does it hurt? Benedict XVI answered honestly: yes. Meeting Christ's gaze heals us through an undeniably painful transformation.7

But he called it a blessed pain: the pain of finally seeing your life as it really is, which is exactly where the healing starts.7

How long does it take? Nobody can say in days or years. Benedict wrote that it can't be measured by the clocks and calendars of this world. He called it the heart's time.7

What went wrong, and the fix

Now the honest part. The Catholic Church has to own a real abuse.

In the late Middle Ages, money got tangled up with prayers for the dead. Travelling fundraisers, who collected money with promises of , became known for wicked abuses.8,9

The bishops at Trent admitted that earlier attempts to stop them had become in later times useless.8

So in 1562 they abolished those fundraisers. The next year they told bishops to forbid anything around purgatory that smelled of greed, or in their old phrase, filthy lucre.8,9

The reform was real, and it came too late for the frightened people who had already paid.

Purgatory isn't Christ's blood falling short. It's Christ's blood finishing the job.

Sources14
  1. 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1030–1032Purgatory: the final purification of those already assured of salvation; prayer for the dead.
  2. 2Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1471–1473Temporal punishment is not vengeance from outside; it follows from the nature of sin.
  3. 3Annex to the Official Common Statement on the Joint Declaration (1999), 2ELutherans and Catholics: what is wrong in our life will not enter eternal life.
  4. 41 Corinthians 3:10–15 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Work tested by fire; the person saved, but only as through fire.
  5. 5Catholic Encyclopedia, Inscription of Abercius (1907)A bishop's epitaph from the late second or early third century asking readers to pray for him.
  6. 6Tertullian, De Corona, 3 (early 200s)Christians make offerings for the dead on their anniversaries.
  7. 7Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi (30 November 2007), 45–48The purifying fire as Christ himself; its "duration" can't be measured; prayer for the dead in Judaism, East and West.
  8. 8Council of Trent, Session 21 (16 July 1562), chapter 9The office of the questors of alms abolished everywhere.
  9. 9Council of Trent, Session 25 (3–4 December 1563), Decree concerning PurgatoryThe doctrine taught soberly; superstition and money-making forbidden.
  10. 10The Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter 32.1 (Orthodox Presbyterian Church text)The Presbyterian view: believers' souls are made perfect in holiness at death; Scripture knows no third place.
  11. 11John Paul II, General Audience on purgatory (4 August 1999)Purgatory is not a place but a condition of existence; those being purified are immersed in the love of Christ.
  12. 12Council of Trent, Session 6 (13 January 1547), canon 30Guilt and eternal punishment forgiven; a debt of temporal punishment may remain, in this world or in purgatory.
  13. 13Council of Florence, Laetentur caeli (6 July 1439), Papal Encyclicals OnlineThe truly penitent who die before making satisfaction are cleansed after death by cleansing pains.
  14. 14Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1459Absolution takes away sin, but does not remedy all the disorders sin has caused.
Quotes checked
Not answered here

A question this page doesn’t cover?

Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.