From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/is-the-mass-a-re-sacrifice-of-christ
← Protestant or evangelicalIs the Mass a re-sacrifice of Christ?
Read it as an illustrated story · 8 minNo. Catholics believe Jesus died once, for all, rose again, and can never die again. The doesn't repeat the cross. Catholics believe it makes that one sacrifice present, so people in every century can stand at the foot of the cross and receive what it won.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Council of Trent
- Session 22: doctrine, canons and decree on the Mass
If you've read the , you can see where this worry comes from. The letter to the Hebrews says Jesus doesn't need to offer sacrifice day after day, like the priests in the old Temple. He did it once for all when he offered himself.3
Then you hear Catholics talk about the sacrifice of the Mass. It sounds like Jesus is being killed again, every Sunday, all over the world.
Early Protestants were blunt. The Church of England's statement of beliefs, in 1571, called these Masses blasphemous fables, and dangerous deceits.9
Yet on the main point, the Catholic Church agrees. The cross can't be repeated. Jesus died once, and it never needs to happen again.
One sacrifice, not two
Then what do Catholics mean? In one line: the one cross isn't repeated, it's made present. The says the cross and the Mass are one single sacrifice.1
Same Jesus giving himself, same Jesus given. Only the manner of offering is different.1 On the cross he gave himself with his blood. At Mass that same gift is made present, without blood.1,2
The Catholic word is re-present: not do again, but make present again. The Catechism says the Mass applies its fruit.1 What Jesus won once is handed out, Sunday by Sunday, to real people.
So does Jesus suffer again at every Mass? No. Catholics believe he's truly there, in what looks like bread and wine, but with no new suffering and no new death.1 Why they believe he's really there has its own answer.
Think of it like this
Go outside on a clear night and look up at a bright star. That point of light seems to be shining right now, just for you.
But the light reaching your eye left that star years ago, sometimes hundreds of years before you were born. The star sent it out once. It isn't sending it again because you looked up.
And you aren't looking at a photo or a recording of the star. It's the real light, from that one moment, landing in your eye tonight.
That's how Catholics see the Mass. The cross happened once, in one place, on one afternoon. The Mass doesn't stage it again. It makes that one real sacrifice present to you, here and now.
And Catholics believe it isn't only what the cross won that reaches you. Jesus himself is there, alive, the same one who gave himself.
What remembering meant to Jesus
At his last meal before he died, at time, Jesus took bread and said do this in memory of me.
Passover is the Jewish feast that remembers God freeing Israel from slavery in Egypt. At Passover, each generation says it's remembering what the LORD did for me.6 Not for my great-great-grandparents. For me.
So Catholics call the Mass a memorial too. But in the Bible, remembering wasn't just thinking back. As the Catechism puts it, the old events become in a certain way present and real to the people keeping them.1
Early Christians called it a sacrifice
compares , the table of the Lord, with the altars in Corinth's temples to Greek gods, where people ate meat offered to them.7
It's an odd comparison if nothing like a sacrifice were going on.
And a handbook for churches written within about a century of Jesus, called the Didache, calls the Sunday Communion meal your sacrifice.8
The , the ancient churches of Eastern Europe and the Middle East, still call it a sacrifice. A catechism by Philaret, a Russian Orthodox , calls it the bloodless sacrifice of the Body and Blood of .12
The other side's best point
Hebrews says Christ offered one sacrifice for , and there is no longer offering for sin.5 To many Protestants, a priest at an altar every day looks like exactly what Hebrews says is over.
saw Communion as a gift God gives us, not something we give to God. Offering it back, he thought, turned God's gift into our own good deed.11
Many Protestants see the Lord's Supper as a memorial and a thank you for the sacrifice, not a sacrifice itself. Southern Baptists, for example, call it a symbolic act of obedience in which believers memorialize the death of the Redeemer.10
Catholics agree with Hebrews here: there is no longer offering for sin.5 If the Mass were a second offering, Hebrews would rule it out.
So the real question is simple. Is the Mass a second offering, or the one offering made present?
So who is offering at Mass? The Catechism says it is Christ himself, acting through the ministry of the priests.13 The priest brings no gift of his own. The only offering is the one Jesus made of himself, once.
Hebrews calls him our high priest and says he must have something to offer.4 That something is himself, given on the cross.
Nor does he offer himself again in . Hebrews says he doesn't offer himself repeatedly: he did it once for all.14
What he does now, it says, is appear before God on our behalf.14 He lives forever to make intercession for us.3
Catholics believe the Mass is drawn into that: the one offering, made once, still before God for us, and made present on the altar. It isn't a new one added, and it isn't the cross done again.
Where the forgiveness comes from
The went further in the 1500s, and this is the part Protestants find hardest. It called the Mass a true sacrifice for sin, not only a thank you or a memorial.2
Through it, Trent says, God gives the and gift of penitence, meaning true sorrow and turning back, and forgives even grave sins.2 For serious sins, that turning back still includes confession to a priest.
So does the Mass win a forgiveness the cross didn't? Trent's own answer is no. The one offered is the same; only the way of offering differs. The cross's fruits, it says, are received most plentifully through this unbloody one.2
The forgiveness was won once, on the cross. The Mass is one way it reaches someone kneeling in church today. Nothing new is won.
Where the critics were right
To be honest, the Reformers had a point. By the late Middle Ages, many people treated each Mass as one more sacrifice stacked on top of Christ's. More Masses meant more grace, they thought.11 In Luther's own town, one church had thousands of Masses said every year.11
And money came into it. In 1562 Trent had to ban bargaining over payment for Masses, which tells you the bargaining was real.2
Closer than you'd think
Today Lutherans and Catholics say together that many Catholics back then lost sight of the one sacrifice. And they quote what their joint talks had agreed: Christ's sacrifice can be neither continued, nor repeated, nor replaced, nor complemented.11
But, they went on, it can and should become ever effective anew in the midst of the congregation.11 They still differ on how that happens at Communion.
So on the main worry, Catholics and Protestants agree more than they know. The Catholic Church teaches that Jesus doesn't die again at Mass. Catholics believe that each Sunday they stand at the foot of the one cross.
Sources14
- 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1362–1367The Eucharist as memorial; the Mass and the cross are "one single sacrifice".
- 2Council of Trent, Session 22 (17 September 1562): doctrine, canons and decree on the MassChapters 1–2 on the one sacrifice represented; canon 3; the decree banning bargains over Masses.
- 3Hebrews 7 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Christ offered himself once for all; he lives forever to make intercession.
- 4Hebrews 8 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)The high priest must have something to offer.
- 5Hebrews 10 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Consecrated through the offering of Christ's body once for all.
- 6Exodus 13 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Each generation says the Lord brought me out of Egypt.
- 71 Corinthians 10:16–21 (New American Bible)The cup and bread as participation; the table of the Lord against the table of demons.
- 8The Didache (c. AD 50–120), 14The Sunday Eucharist called a sacrifice, with Malachi 1:11.
- 9The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion (1571), Article XXXIThe Anglican Reformers' objection to the sacrifices of Masses.
- 10Southern Baptist Convention, The Baptist Faith and Message (2000), VII: Baptism and the Lord's SupperThe Lord's Supper as a symbolic act of obedience in which believers memorialize the death of the Redeemer.
- 11Lutheran–Roman Catholic Commission on Unity, From Conflict to Communion (2013), 146–148, 157–159Late-medieval confusion about the Mass; Luther's objection; the shared Lutheran–Catholic statement on the one sacrifice.
- 12Philaret of Moscow, The Longer Catechism of the Orthodox, Catholic, Eastern Church, Q 376A Russian Orthodox catechism: prayer in union with the bloodless sacrifice of the Body and Blood of Christ.
- 13Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1410It is Christ himself, the eternal high priest, who, acting through the ministry of the priests, offers the Eucharistic sacrifice.
- 14Hebrews 9 (New American Bible, Revised Edition)Christ entered heaven to appear before God on our behalf, not to offer himself repeatedly; once for all (9:24–26).
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.