From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/infant-baptism
← Protestant or evangelicalWhy do Catholics baptise babies? Does baptism save?
Read it as an illustrated story · 9 minBecause Catholics believe is God's gift, and a baby can receive a gift. And yes, the Catholic Church teaches that baptism saves: it washes away and joins you to . The and many Protestants baptise babies too. Baptists wait for a person's own faith, and that's a serious, Bible-based view.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Council of Trent
- Session 7, canons on baptism, canon 2
Open the and look at the order. People hear about Jesus. They believe. Then they're baptised.
That's why Baptists, many Pentecostals and many independent churches see baptism as something you do after you believe.11 The Southern Baptist Convention, America's biggest Baptist church family, says baptism is an act of obedience that pictures a believer's faith.1
Baptists call it an ordinance, one of two things Christ told his church to keep doing.1 Catholics call it a : a sign Christ gave that doesn't only picture God's , but really gives it.13
So the objection makes sense. A baby can't believe or say sorry. Baptising one can look like a ritual standing in for real faith.
And lots of people baptised as babies grow up with no faith at all. That last point is fair, and Catholics feel it too.
But this isn't Catholics against everyone else. The Orthodox Church baptises babies.12 So do Lutherans, Anglicans, Methodists and Presbyterians.2,3,4,5
It's an argument inside Protestantism as much as between churches.
The gift comes first
The Catholic Church teaches that babies, like all of us, are born with a fallen human nature. The Church calls this . It isn't a baby's personal fault: it's something they're born into, not something they did. So they need a new start in Christ too.6
The puts it like this: The sheer gratuitousness of the grace of is particularly manifest in infant Baptism.6
That's a mouthful. It means God's help, which Christians call grace, is completely free. A baby has done nothing to earn it, and that's the point.
Holding back, the Catechism says, would keep a child from the priceless grace of becoming a child of God.6
Think of it like this
Think of a baby girl born in a hospital. Within days she has a name, a birth certificate and a family who take her home. Before long she might even have a passport, with a photo of her asleep.
Nobody waits till she's 21 to ask if she'd like to join the family or become a citizen. She belongs from the start, long before she understands any of it.
As she grows, she learns her family's ways, and the songs and stories of her country at school. One day she'll have to decide for herself what it all means to her. She might love it. She might walk away. But nobody thinks the gift was wasted because it came first.
That's how Catholics see a baby's baptism. The gift comes first; the response grows with her.
To be fair, a Baptist would say that's the very point in dispute. In the , they'd say, you join God's family by believing, not by being born.
So the analogy doesn't settle the argument. It only shows why Catholics don't think a gift has to wait until it's understood.
What the first Christians did
To be honest, the New Testament never shows a baby being baptised. It never forbids it either. It does tell of whole households baptised at once, but nobody can prove there were children in them.
calls baptism a new kind of circumcision (Colossians 2:11–12), the sign that marked a Jewish boy as one of God's people.9 And by God's own command, circumcision was given to baby boys, eight days old.9
In the 200s, a famous Bible teacher named Origen said the Church received the habit of baptising babies from the themselves.9
By AD 253 some wanted to wait until a baby was eight days old, as with circumcision. Bishops meeting at Carthage, in North Africa, said there was no need to wait.9
So at Carthage, the argument was about when to baptise babies, not whether.
Some did disagree. Around AD 200, a writer called Tertullian said to wait until children could know Christ.10 So baptising babies was already common enough to argue about. The Catechism calls it an immemorial tradition of the Church, with clear evidence from the second century on.6
Does baptism save?
Jesus said no one enters God's kingdom without being born of water and Spirit (John 3:5). For Catholics, baptism is where you're born again: the Catechism says that through it we are freed from sin and reborn as sons of God.14
It calls baptism necessary for salvation for those who have heard the gospel and could ask for it.7 It forgives sin and makes you an adopted child of God.8
Many Protestants are closer to this than they think. Lutherans call baptism necessary to salvation.2 Presbyterians say God really gives his grace in baptism, though not always at the moment of the baptism itself, but in his own time.5
Baptists read Jesus's words differently, and there are two readings you'll often hear.
Many Baptist preachers say born of water means ordinary birth. They point to the very next verse: What is born of flesh is flesh and what is born of spirit is spirit (John 3:6).
So, they say, Jesus means you need two births: the natural one, and a second one from the Spirit. A pastor of First Baptist Church in Dallas said in 1986 that he'd heard Baptist preachers explain it that way all his life.15
He preferred another reading himself: the water is God's word, the message of the gospel, which cleans a person when they hear it and believe.15
Either way, for Baptists the water of baptism shows on the outside what faith has already done inside.1
Catholics take the water as real water. Later in the same chapter, John's shows Jesus and his baptising in Judea (John 3:22). The notes in the New American Bible, a Catholic translation, suggest the story may have been placed there to explain the water of verse 5.16
In the 1500s the insisted on it: baptism needs real water, and Jesus's words aren't some sort of metaphor.17
That's a real disagreement, between people who love the same Lord.
Baptised, but never believed?
So what about someone baptised as a baby who grows up never believing? Are they saved?
Catholics would say baptism was a real beginning, but it isn't a free pass. It marks you as Christ's for good, yet sin can stop it from bearing the fruits of salvation.8
Parents and godparents promise to raise the child in the faith, and the Catechism says For all the baptized, children or adults, faith must grow after Baptism.6
In other words, a baptised person still has to give their own yes to Jesus. Catholics just believe God's yes came first.
And Catholics don't say every unbaptised person is lost:
God has bound salvation to the sacrament of Baptism, but he himself is not bound by his sacraments.
For babies who die without baptism, the Catholic Church says it can only entrust them to the mercy of God. Jesus's tenderness towards children, it says, lets us hope.7
What already unites us
If you were baptised with water in the name of the Father, the Son and the , in a Baptist, Methodist or any other church, the Catholic Church recognises it.
Those justified by faith in Baptism, the Catechism says, have a right to be called Christians.8 You're already family.
That covers most Pentecostal churches too. The condition is the one Jesus gave: water, with the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit named.18
There's one exception: Oneness Pentecostal churches. Most Christians believe in the .
Oneness churches don't. For them, Father, Son and Spirit are ways the one God has shown himself. And that changes how they baptise.19
They baptise in the name of Jesus Christ, because of a verse in Acts. In it tells a crowd to be baptised in the name of Jesus Christ (Acts 2:38).19
Catholics usually read Peter's words as setting Christian baptism apart from 's, not as new words to say at baptism. John was the prophet who baptised people in the river Jordan before Jesus began to teach.9
But the Catholic Church holds that naming the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit is part of the essential rite of Baptism.20 So it doesn't count a baptism in Jesus's name alone.
And baptism in the Holy Spirit?
Many Pentecostals speak of the baptism in the Holy Spirit. The Assemblies of God, the largest Pentecostal fellowship, teach that every believer should seek it.21
It's a second experience after faith, often shown by speaking in tongues, praying aloud in a language you never learned.21
Catholics link it to a sacrament, Confirmation, when a person is anointed with oil and prayed over to receive the Spirit.
The Catechism says its effect is the full outpouring of the Holy Spirit as once granted to the apostles on the day of .22
And many Catholics use the Pentecostal phrase too. The Catholic Charismatic Renewal began in 1967, and has grown to millions of members.23
They don't mean a second baptism. Raniero Cantalamessa, who preached to the for 44 years, explains it as the grace of baptism coming alive.23,25
And in 2019 Pope Francis asked the Renewal to share baptism in the Holy Spirit with everyone in the Church.24
So the experience Pentecostals prize is one many Catholics know. They see it as God's gifts in baptism and Confirmation coming fully alive.
There's more on this under "Do Catholics believe in speaking in tongues and healing?"
Catholics baptise babies for the same reason they believe in grace at all: God moves first, and we spend our lives answering.
Sources25
- 1Southern Baptist Convention, The Baptist Faith and Message (2000), articles VI and VIIThe Baptist view: baptism is the immersion of a believer, an act of obedience symbolising faith.
- 2The Augsburg Confession (1530), article IXLutherans: baptism is necessary to salvation, and children are to be baptised.
- 3The Thirty-Nine Articles of the Church of England, article XXVIIAnglicans: the baptism of young children is to be retained.
- 4The United Methodist Church, Articles of Religion, article XVIIMethodists: the baptism of young children is to be retained.
- 5The Westminster Confession of Faith, chapter 28 (Orthodox Presbyterian Church text)Presbyterians: infants of believers are to be baptised; grace conferred in God's time.
- 6Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1250–1254Why the Catholic Church baptises infants; faith must grow after baptism.
- 7Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1257–1261Baptism and salvation; hope for infants who die without baptism.
- 8Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1262–1274What baptism does: forgiveness of sins, new birth as a child of God; the foundation of communion among all Christians.
- 9Catholic Encyclopedia, Baptism (1907), section on the baptism of infantsOrigen on the apostolic tradition; the Council of Carthage of 253.
- 10Tertullian, On Baptism, 18 (around 200)An early voice for delaying the baptism of little children.
- 11Wikipedia, Assemblies of God USA (beliefs section)The Assemblies of God, a major Pentecostal church, practises believer's baptism by immersion.
- 12Orthodox Church in America, ChrismationBaptism and chrismation are completed by Holy Communion, for infants as well as adults.
- 13Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1131
- 14Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1213
- 15W. A. Criswell, "Born of Water and of Spirit", sermon at First Baptist Church, Dallas (1986)A Baptist pastor sets out the readings of John 3:5: natural birth (the one he heard from Baptist preachers all his life), John's baptism, and his own preference, the cleansing word of God.
- 16John 3, with notes on verses 5 and 22–26 (New American Bible)Right after the talk with Nicodemus, Jesus is shown baptising; the note suggests the passage was placed there to give meaning to "water".
- 17Council of Trent, Session 7 (3 March 1547), canons on baptism, canon 2Real water is necessary for baptism; John 3:5 is not to be turned into a metaphor.
- 18Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (1993), 92–95Baptism is conferred with water and a formula naming the Father, Son and Holy Spirit; baptism by immersion or pouring with that formula is valid.
- 19United Pentecostal Church International, Our BeliefsA Oneness Pentecostal church: one God revealed as Father, through the Son and as the Holy Spirit; water baptism in the name of Jesus Christ.
- 20Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1278The essential rite of Baptism: water, with the invocation of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.
- 21Assemblies of God, Statement of Fundamental Truths, 7–8Baptism in the Holy Spirit is distinct from and subsequent to the new birth; its initial physical sign is speaking in tongues.
- 22Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1302–1303The effect of Confirmation is the full outpouring of the Holy Spirit as at Pentecost; it deepens the grace of baptism.
- 23Wikipedia, Catholic Charismatic RenewalBegan in 1967; baptism in the Holy Spirit as a personal experience of God's power; McDonnell and Montague; Cantalamessa on a "valid but tied" sacrament.
- 24Pope Francis, address to the Catholic Charismatic Renewal International Service, CHARIS (8 June 2019)Francis asks the Renewal to share baptism in the Holy Spirit with everyone in the Church.
- 25Wikipedia, Raniero CantalamessaPreacher to the Papal Household from 1980 until 2024.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.