From The Trail, a site by ACG · www.christiantrail.site/faq/text/divorced-remarried-communion
← CatholicI'm divorced and remarried. Can I still receive Communion?
Read it as an illustrated story · 7 minIf your first marriage was valid, the Catholic Church as a rule asks you not to receive while the new relationship goes on. But you're not thrown out, you belong at , and there are real ways forward. If you're divorced and haven't remarried, you can receive like any other Catholic.
Where this answer says what the Catholic Church teaches, here’s what it rests on. Each link opens the document itself.
- Catechism
- 1625–16291649–16512382–2386 and 2390
- Council of Trent
- Session 24, canons on the sacrament of matrimony
If you're asking this, you've probably been through a lot. A marriage ended, maybe not by your choice. Now you stay in your seat while others go up for Communion.
Divorce alone doesn't stop you
Start with the good news. Divorce on its own doesn't stop you receiving.
A spouse who was abandoned, or who divorced to protect the children, hasn't sinned.3 Only if you broke up a marriage through your own serious fault would you bring that to confession first.3,6
The real question is about a new marriage while the first one still stands.
Why remarriage is different
The Catholic Church holds that a valid marriage between two people, once they've sealed it by having sex as husband and wife, can't be dissolved by any human power, only by death.3
Catholics believe this comes from Jesus himself. Asked about divorce, he said what God has joined together, no human being must separate. Whoever divorces and marries someone else, he said, commits adultery.4
Christians read one line differently. Matthew's adds an exception. A Catholic translates it unless the marriage is unlawful, and some Christians read it as allowing divorce.5 The churches of the East generally allow divorce after adultery, and a second wedding with a quieter service of repentance.9
Many churches allow divorce too.11 That Catholic Bible's notes read the exception another way: as unions that were never real marriages in the first place.5
To be fair, the Orthodox reading isn't a loophole. It's their long tradition, and the chose its words carefully in 1563.12
It condemned anyone who says the Catholic Church has erred in teaching that adultery doesn't end a marriage. It didn't condemn the Eastern practice itself.12
The draws the conclusion. A new civil marriage, it says, puts a couple in a situation that objectively contravenes God's law, meaning it goes against that law. So they cannot receive communion as long as this situation persists.2
The objection is easy to feel. Someone who steals can go to confession and receive next Sunday. So why are you asked to wait for years?
It isn't that remarriage is a worse than theft.
Confession forgives what you're turning away from, and a second marriage isn't a past act.
If the first marriage was valid, the new one is still going on.2
No second wedding?
What if there was never a second wedding? In some places divorce isn't possible, so people separate and simply move in with a new partner. Elsewhere, couples just choose not to marry again.
The answer is the same, for the same reason. If the first marriage was valid, it still stands. And the Catechism says of couples who live together without marrying that sex outside marriage excludes one from communion.3
When Francis wrote about this in 2016, he spoke of divorced people who have entered a new union. So the path set out below, talking it through honestly with a priest, applies here too.7
The Catholic Church also knows why people end up there. wrote that some feel almost forced into living together by money, culture or religion. He asked priests and parishes to get to know each couple's situation, case by case, to treat them with tact and respect, and to patiently help them toward a proper marriage.6
What Communion says
Pope John Paul II gave two reasons in 1981. Communion is the sign of 's faithful love for his Church, and a second union while the first bond still stands contradicts that sign.6
And admitting people anyway would confuse others about whether marriage really is for life.6
Think of it like this
Think of signing a form at the bank. Above the line are boxes: your name, your address, your income. Your signature at the bottom says: everything written above is true of me.
You wouldn't sign if one box wasn't true yet, even if every other box was. Not because you're a bad person, but because your signature would be saying something that isn't so.
At Communion the priest holds up the bread and says The Body of Christ, and you answer Amen. That Amen is a kind of signature. Catholics believe it says yes to Jesus and his faithful love, the love marriage is meant to mirror.
The Catholic Church isn't saying you're a worse person. It's saying one part of your life doesn't yet match what you'd be signing.
Notice the word objectively. It's about the situation, not your heart. The Catechism also says blame can be diminished or even nullified by fear, pressure, habit and other things.7
Pope Francis quotes that and draws the point: judging a situation isn't the same as judging how guilty you are.7
What Pope Francis changed
In 2016 Pope Francis wrote a letter called The Joy of Love.7 He kept the teaching, and said he wasn't offering a new set of general rules.7
But remarried Catholics are not excommunicated, he wrote. They aren't cut off, and they may still be living in God's .7
Then a footnote set off years of debate. Of the Church's help, it says: In certain cases, this can include the help of the sacraments.7
The around Buenos Aires, in Argentina, read this as opening a path, in some complex cases, to confession and Communion after working it through carefully with a priest. They warned it isn't open access to the sacraments.8
Francis wrote back that their reading explained his meaning fully, and that there was no other.8 In 2023 the Vatican's teaching office confirmed it as official papal teaching.10
So in some cases, after that careful process, a remarried Catholic may receive. It's never automatic.8
To be honest, not every Catholic reads it that way. In 2016 four cardinals, senior Church leaders, asked Francis to clarify it, and he never answered them directly.10
So for you, the practical step is simple: ask your priest whether your case is one of these. The answer follows your bishop's guidelines.7
What you can do now
Start with a priest you trust, and tell him your whole story. What's offered can differ from place to place, since it follows the local bishop's guidelines.7
Was your first marriage valid? If something essential was missing on the wedding day, a Church court can rule there was never a marriage.1 Then you'd be free to marry in the Church.
Can you live as brother and sister? That means living together without sex. Some couples who can't separate, often because of the children, do this. They go to confession first, and can then receive again.6
It's a heavy ask. Pope Francis notes many couples say it can put their faithfulness and their children's good at risk.7
Whatever the answer, keep coming. Priests and people must help remarried Catholics not to consider themselves separated from the Church, in whose life they can and must participate as baptized persons.2
That means Mass, prayer, Scripture, works of charity, and raising children in the faith.2
The teaching tries to keep two of Jesus's commitments at once: that marriage is for life, and that nobody is left outside. The door to Communion may be closed for now. The door to the Church never is.
Sources12
- 1Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1625–1629Consent makes a marriage; a Church tribunal can declare that a marriage never existed.
- 2Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1649–1651Separation, remarriage and Communion; remarried Catholics still belong to the Church's life.
- 3Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2382–2386 and 2390Marriage can't be dissolved; civil divorce can be tolerated; the abandoned spouse hasn't sinned; living together without marriage excludes from Communion.
- 4Mark 10:2–12 (New American Bible, on vatican.va)Jesus on divorce: what God has joined, no human being must separate.
- 5Matthew 5:31–32, with the New American Bible's note on the exceptive clauseThe phrase "unless the marriage is unlawful" (also Matthew 19:9) and how it's read.
- 6John Paul II, Familiaris Consortio (22 November 1981), 81, 83–84Free unions and how pastors should approach them; divorced but not remarried may receive; remarried may not, and why; living as brother and sister.
- 7Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia (19 March 2016), 243, 298–305 and notes 329 and 351Not excommunicated; no new general rules; discernment with a priest; "in certain cases" the sacraments.
- 8Pope Francis, letter to the bishops of the Buenos Aires pastoral region, with their guidelines (5 September 2016, Spanish)The Pope endorses guidelines that allow, in some cases, access to confession and Communion.
- 9Pew Research Center, Orthodox Christians support key church policies (8 November 2017)Orthodox churches generally allow divorce for infidelity, with penitential services for second marriages.
- 10EWTN News (Jonathan Liedl), Vatican responds to Cardinal Duka's dubia on divorced and remarried Catholics (2 October 2023)The doctrine office calls the Buenos Aires guidelines authentic magisterium; four cardinals' 2016 questions went unanswered.
- 11Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), 24.5–6 (Orthodox Presbyterian Church text)The Reformed confession allows divorce and remarriage after adultery or desertion that can't be remedied.
- 12Council of Trent, Session 24 (11 November 1563), canons on the sacrament of matrimonyCanon 7 condemns anyone who says the Church has erred in teaching that the bond of marriage can't be dissolved for adultery.
A question this page doesn’t cover?
Ask it in the question box at the bottom right of the page. It searches the whole site and answers from it. Or start with how this site checks what it says, and the full list of sources, each linked to the original.