If God is real, why doesn't he just show himself? Why doesn't he answer my prayers?
Christians believe God has shown himself, above all in Jesus, but in a way that invites rather than forces. Unanswered prayer is real, and Jesus knew it from the inside. God's silence isn't the same as his absence.
Part 1 · The question
This might be the most honest question there is. If a loving God wants to know everyone, why not make it obvious?
Why do some sincere people look for him and find nothing?
Then there's the version that hurts. You prayed for someone to get better, and they died.
In the US, an economist once looked at what people typed into Google about God.
The third most common question was why does God hate me?
Christians don't have a neat answer to this, and they shouldn't pretend to. But they do have something to say.
Part 2 · Love waits for an answer
The Catholic Church teaches that God really does make himself known. But he won't force anyone to believe.
Its , the summary of what it believes, says your answer to God must be free.
The Catechism also says Jesus invited people to faith and conversion, but never coerced them.
In plain words, he called people to trust him and turn their lives around, but he never forced anyone.
Why would God hold back like that? Think about how love works. Here's an analogy that might help.
Imagine the richest, most popular kid at school decides they want to be your best friend.
They could buy you the newest phone tomorrow, and get the whole class to tell you how amazing they are.
You might well hang around with them. But be honest: would it be friendship, or a deal you couldn't turn down?
Love that's forced isn't love. So someone who really wants you, not just your yes, does it differently.
They sit with you at lunch when you're on your own. They let you see who they really are, slowly.
And then they leave the choice to you, even if it takes years.
That's how Christians understand God's quietness. He could overwhelm anyone.
Instead he comes close enough for you to know him, and leaves you free to say no.
He wants you to choose him, not to be pushed.
Part 3 · He did show up
And here's the big claim. Christians believe God did show himself, in Jesus.
Jesus was a Jewish teacher who lived about 2,000 years ago.
Christians believe in one God who is three: the Father, the Son and the . They're not three gods, but one.
Jesus, they believe, is the Son, God himself become human.
So when one of his friends asked to see God, Jesus could answer:
Whoever has seen me has seen the Father.
But look at how he came. He was a craftsman from a small town, with no army, no palace and no fireworks.
Lots of people met him face to face and simply walked away.
Centuries earlier, , a prophet Israel believed spoke for God, had already said that God hides himself:
Truly with you God is hidden.
Blaise Pascal, a French mathematician, thought God hides on purpose.
There's enough light for those who only desire to see, he wrote, and enough darkness for those who don't.
Part 4 · The skeptic's best point
Now the honest part. One philosopher, J. L. Schellenberg from Canada, has turned this into one of the strongest arguments against God there is.
A loving God, he says, wouldn't leave open-hearted people unable to believe through no fault of their own. Yet those people seem to exist.
Others add that what people believe mostly depends on where they're born, which fits a world without God better.
Pascal's line doesn't fully answer the philosopher, because the philosopher's point is about people who do want to see, and still don't.
Christians reply that a search can take years, and that God works at a pace each person can bear.
To be fair, that can't be proved from the outside.
So, honestly, many philosophers think Schellenberg's argument still stands. Christians can't make it disappear.
What they do is keep looking where Jesus said God would be found, in prayer and in other people.
And they trust that a search that's still going hasn't failed.
But a sincere seeker who never finds isn't written off.
Some people, through no fault of their own, never come to know the , the good news about Jesus.
The Catholic Church teaches that if they seek God with a sincere heart and, with God's help, follow their conscience, they can still be saved.
That means they can still reach life with God for ever, and Catholics believe it's still Jesus who saves them.
Part 5 · When prayer seems unanswered
Jesus knew unanswered prayer from the inside.
The night before he died, he knelt in a garden and begged his Father to spare him what was coming. Then he added:
not as I will, but as you will.
The next day he was anyway: the Romans nailed him to a cross and left him to die.
On the cross he cried out the first line of 22, a Jewish prayer-song that was already centuries old:
My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?
So the Christian answer is never you didn't have enough faith.
Jesus trusted his Father completely, and still wasn't spared.
The Catechism doesn't pretend prayer always feels answered. It admits: Some even stop praying because they think their petition is not heard.
And it passes on the advice of an early monk:
Do not be troubled if you do not immediately receive from God what you ask him; for he desires to do something even greater for you, while you cling to him in prayer.
Part 6 · Silence isn't absence
The Catechism's deepest answer is the cross. It talks about our petitions, the things we ask God for:
All our petitions were gathered up, once for all, in his cry on the Cross and, in his Resurrection, heard by the Father.
Jesus's own prayer was answered, but not by being spared.
It was answered three days later, on the first Easter Sunday, when Christians believe he rose from the dead.
If the silence has become too heavy to carry, please talk to someone today.
If you might act on thoughts of suicide, call your local emergency number now.
You can find a free, confidential crisis line in your country at findahelpline.com.
In Catholic belief, God's silence is never his absence.
The one who seems hidden is the one who came close enough to share our worst night.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 11
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2734–2741 · Why do we complain of not being heard? Trust tested in prayer, and Jesus's prayer for us.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 160 · Faith must be free; Christ never coerced anyone.
- John 14:8–9 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Whoever has seen me has seen the Father.
- Matthew 26:39 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus's prayer in Gethsemane.
- Matthew 27:46 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus's cry from the cross.
- Isaiah 45:15 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Truly with you God is hidden.
- Blaise Pascal, Pensées, 430 (Project Gutenberg) · Enough light for those who desire to see.
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Hiddenness of God · Schellenberg's 1993 argument from nonbelief, stated and discussed.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 846–847 · Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel but seek God sincerely may be saved.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 253 · The Trinity: not three gods but one God in three persons, each wholly God.
- TheHumanist.com, When in Doubt, Google 'Who Created God?' (19 October 2015) · Reports Stephens-Davidowitz's Google data: 'why does God hate me?' was the third most-asked God question in the US.