Full text
Catholic · About 6 min ·  · What you have to believe

What if I disagree with the Church about something? Can I criticise the pope?

The short answer

It depends on what you disagree with. The core beliefs the Catholic Church has declared as revealed by God ask for faith. Most other teaching asks for an honest effort to accept it. You must follow a conscience you've really worked to form. And you can tell priests and bishops, even the pope, where you think they're wrong, as long as you do it with respect.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

Plenty of Catholics quietly disagree with something, like a teaching on sex, or who can receive .

Or it might be something the said in an interview. They wonder if that makes them fake Catholics.

Other Catholics think any disagreement at all is betrayal.

Both skip two questions. What kind of teaching is it? And what are you doing with your disagreement?

Part 2 · Not all teaching weighs the same

The Catholic Church sorts its teaching into three levels, and asks for a different response to each.

First, what God revealed, like Jesus rising from the dead. This asks for faith.

Even here, struggling isn't refusing. Catholic teaching sets difficulty in overcoming objections apart from deliberately refusing to believe.

Knowingly and stubbornly denying what God revealed is different. The Church calls that heresy, a break with the faith itself.

Second, teachings closely tied to it, like declaring someone a saint.

These are to be firmly accepted and held.

The Vatican puts the teaching that only men can be priests in this group. said it must be definitively held.

His reason was that Jesus chose only men as his twelve , so the Church believes it has no authority to do otherwise.

Third, ordinary teaching: most other teaching from the pope and the .

It's the everyday kind, not settled for good. It asks for a sincere, respectful yes: you trust it and really try to accept it.

The says that yes isn't the same as the yes of faith, though it grows out of it.

And not every word from a pope weighs the same. The said so.

You can tell by what kind of document it is, how often he repeats the point, and how he says it.

A letter to the whole Church isn't the same as a remark to reporters on a plane.

Why take ordinary teaching seriously? Catholics believe Jesus promised his help to the apostles and to the bishops after them.

Bishops teaching with the pope, the Council said, speak in the name of Christ on faith and morals.

Trusting that is part of what it means to be Catholic.

But the Catholic Church is also honest that some of its teaching on practical questions has had faults.

A 1990 letter from the Vatican on handling disagreement admits some documents might not be free from all deficiencies.

Sometimes only time showed which parts were right. So your honest difficulty can be part of how the Church comes to see more clearly.

Part 3 · Yes, you can speak up

Church law says ordinary Catholics have the right and even at times the duty to speak up about the good of the Church.

They can tell their priests and bishops what they think, with respect for the faith and for those who lead them.

That includes the pope. You can criticise his decisions, his remarks, or how he handled a crisis.

was the leader of Jesus's apostles, and the first pope in Catholic belief.

Once, he stopped eating with Christians who weren't Jewish, because he was afraid of what others would say.

told Peter to his face he clearly was wrong.

It was about what Peter did, not a teaching he'd defined.

And if you disagree with your own parish priest, talk to him calmly, in private.

Or ask another priest, or someone you trust who knows the faith.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a close family.

Some things aren't up for a vote: who your parents are, and that everyone turns up when someone's in hospital.

But lots of things get talked over, like curfews, chores, or how strict Dad is. Sometimes you think your parents have got something wrong.

So you pick your moment, maybe when it's quiet after dinner, and tell your mum, respectfully, how you see it. She listens.

Sometimes your parents change their minds. Sometimes you do, years later, when you finally see what they meant.

Either way, you're still family.

What hurts the relationship isn't asking hard questions. It's deciding you're right before you've really listened.

And that's the line between honest disagreement and walking out.

Part 4 · Following your conscience

Your conscience is your inner sense of right and wrong. You must follow it. And you must form it.

The Catholic Church teaches both, and holds that they don't cancel each other out.

The Catechism says a person must always obey the certain judgment of his conscience.

But it also warns that conscience can be wrong without knowing it.

And the Catechism lists rejection of the Church's authority and her teaching among the things that lead conscience astray.

So forming it takes a whole life. In practice, that means reading Scripture, praying, and learning the Church's teaching.

It also means asking advice from people you trust who know the faith, like a parent, a priest or a teacher.

The most famous defence of conscience came in 1875, from John Henry Newman.

He was an English thinker who became Catholic as an adult, and later a cardinal, one of the Church's most senior leaders.

He said that in extreme cases, conscience must be followed even against a pope.

He joked that if he ever had to bring religion into toasts after dinner, he'd drink to the Pope, if you please.

Still, he'd drink to Conscience first, and to the Pope afterwards.

But read the small print. Newman meant a conscience that has honestly looked for the truth, not a feeling.

Its judgement must come after serious thought and prayer. And he said it can't clash head-on with a teaching the Church has solemnly declared.

And sometimes a conscience that pushed back was later proved right.

In the 1950s the American Jesuit priest John Courtney Murray was told to stop writing on religious freedom.

In 1965 the Second Vatican Council taught much of what he had argued, in its declaration on religious liberty.

So what if a difficulty won't go away? The 1990 Vatican letter treats struggling with a teaching very differently from campaigning against it.

It's much gentler with the struggle. And its advice fits anyone.

Study the teaching patiently, and be ready to change your mind.

If the problem stays, raise it with the people responsible.

If it still stays, the letter calls it a call to suffer for the truth, in silence and prayer.

Honestly, that's a lot to ask. But it goes on: with the certainty, that if the truth really is at stake, it will ultimately prevail.

What the Catholic Church warns against is dissent. That isn't simply disagreeing. It means organised public opposition.

It also means thinking you only have to accept infallible teaching, meaning the teaching the Church holds can never be wrong.

The letter rejects that idea.

Struggling with a teaching isn't disloyalty. Refusing to listen is the real problem.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
The Trail’s weekly letter

One new thing like this, every Thursday.

One email a week from ACG, about 3 minutes to read. Stop any time.

See past letters first
Sources 12
  1. Code of Canon Law, canon 212 · The faithful's duty of obedience and their right, at times duty, to speak to their pastors.
  2. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 892 and 907 · Religious assent to ordinary teaching; lay people's right to make their views known.
  3. Galatians 2 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Paul opposes Peter at Antioch.
  4. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1783–1785 · Conscience must be informed; its education is lifelong.
  5. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1790–1794 · Always obey a certain conscience; conscience can err; what leads it astray.
  6. John Henry Newman, Letter to the Duke of Norfolk (1875), section 5 · Newman on conscience and papal authority.
  7. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Donum Veritatis (24 May 1990), 23–36 · How to handle serious difficulty with a teaching, and what dissent is.
  8. Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio fidei (1998) · The three levels of teaching and the response each asks.
  9. Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (1964), 25 · Religious submission to the pope's ordinary teaching, weighed by how it is given.
  10. "England (since the Reformation)", Catholic Encyclopedia (1909) · Cardinal Newman's Letter to the Duke of Norfolk (1875), a reply to Gladstone.
  11. John Paul II, Ordinatio Sacerdotalis (22 May 1994), 1 and 4 · Christ chose only men as apostles; the Church has no authority to ordain women; the judgement is to be definitively held.
  12. Wikipedia, "John Courtney Murray" · Told by the Vatican in 1954 to stop writing on religious freedom; drafted the text that became Dignitatis Humanae (1965).