Full text
Catholic · About 6 min ·  · Mass and the sacraments

Can I go to a Protestant church service, or take communion there?

The short answer

You can go to the service, pray and sing along, and the Catholic Church encourages praying with other Christians. But Catholics don't take communion there: when it's offered, stay in your seat and pray. And a Protestant service doesn't replace Sunday Mass. Holding back is about being honest about a real split, not looking down on anyone.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The worry

It comes up all the time: a friend's youth group at an evangelical church, a cousin's wedding in a Pentecostal church, a Christian camp.

Evangelicals and Pentecostals are Protestants.

So can a Catholic go? And can they take there, the bread and wine shared in memory of Jesus?

Some Catholics were told it's wrong even to step inside. Others think a service is a service, so why not take the bread too?

The Catholic answer sits in between. And it's the same answer for every church, from Lutheran and Anglican to Baptist and Pentecostal.

It holds even for a small independent evangelical church with no at all.

Part 2 · Yes, go and pray

You're welcome to go. The Catholic Church encourages praying with other Christians.

You can join the hymns and prayers, and even read or preach if your hosts ask you.

In the 1960s the world's Catholic bishops met at the .

They said Christians in other churches who've been , meaning washed with water as they became Christians, are rightly accepted as brothers and sisters.

Going to their church is visiting family, not crossing a border.

The bishops said more. The uses those churches to bring people to God.

And people born into them can't be blamed for the split that happened long ago.

The honours what Protestants do too.

When they share the Lord's Supper, their communion, it says they proclaim Jesus's death and rising, and wait for him to come back.

Part 3 · So why not take communion?

So why not take communion there? It isn't a judgement on your friends' faith.

Catholics believe Communion goes with full unity between churches. Sharing it before that unity exists says something that isn't true yet.

The bishops at that were honest that two good things pull in different directions.

Sharing communion is meant to show unity, so most of the time it has to wait until the unity is real.

But sharing it also brings , God's help, so sometimes it's right. The exceptions come near the end.

In Catholic belief, Communion isn't only a sign of unity. It's also one of the things that builds it, so it's handled with great care.

There's also a real difference in belief about communion itself. Catholic priests are by bishops.

Those bishops were ordained by bishops before them.

Catholics believe that chain goes back to the .

Some churches do claim that chain. Anglicans, and Lutherans such as the Church of Sweden, say their line of bishops was never broken.

The Catholic Church doesn't accept it. In 1896 Leo XIII ruled Anglican ordinations invalid.

The new rite of the 1550s, he said, had removed the priest's role of offering the sacrifice of the .

So the Catholic Church holds that Protestant churches don't have that chain, and believes their communion isn't the full .

Many Protestants agree it's different. Baptists, a big family of Protestant churches, call their Lord's Supper a symbolic act of obedience.

Lutherans and many Anglicans, though, believe Jesus is truly present in it.

With them, the main Catholic concern is that chain of bishops, not how sincerely they believe.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of two branches of a family that fell out generations ago over the old family shop.

Nobody alive remembers the fight clearly.

Today they visit each other on holidays, eat together, and pray together at funerals. The cousins are in each other's group chats.

They really are family, and everyone knows it.

But there's one thing they hold back on. At the big reunion, nobody stands up and announces that the old split is fully healed.

Nobody says the shop is one business again. It isn't, not yet. There are still real things to settle.

Sharing communion is that announcement. Saying it early wouldn't heal anything.

It would only hide the crack, and make it harder to fix for real.

Part 4 · Sunday, weddings and other questions

What about Sunday? Church law says Catholics are obliged to participate in the Mass on Sundays, and a Protestant service doesn't replace it.

The easy fix is a Saturday evening Mass, which counts for Sunday.

Weddings and youth groups? Go, and go gladly. Catholics may even be witnesses at weddings in other churches.

When communion is offered, stay in your seat and pray. If the bread and cup are passed along the rows, just pass them on.

If anyone asks, say you're Catholic and you'll pray from where you are.

Some evangelical churches baptise only people old enough to say for themselves that they believe.

Baptists, for example, describe baptism as the immersion of a believer in water: going right under, as a believer's own act of faith.

So someone baptised Catholic as a baby is sometimes baptised again when they join. To them, that's the first real one.

Catholics believe the first baptism already did what it promised. It marks you as belonging to for good, and no can erase that.

The Catechism says:

Given once for all, Baptism cannot be repeated.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1272

So in Catholic eyes, the first baptism still counts. The second adds nothing to it and takes nothing away.

And every properly baptised Christian is family. The Catechism says they with good reason are accepted as brothers.

One more case. Some churches that look Protestant teach that Jesus isn't God.

One example, from the Philippines: the Iglesia ni Cristo, or Church of Christ. Its official magazine says:

the Lord Jesus Christ is Man and not God
Pasugo: God's Message (Iglesia ni Cristo)

Protestants, like Catholics and the , believe Jesus is God the Son.

Catholic prayer with other Christians rests on that shared faith, and on baptism in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

So with a church like that, what's said so far doesn't simply carry over.

If you're invited, talk it through with your local priest first. Either way, you can respect your friend's faith and be honest about your own.

Catholics receive the from Catholic ministers. The sacraments are the signs through which they believe God gives his help, like baptism and Communion.

There are a few exceptions, spelled out exactly.

The first is the Orthodox Church, the ancient churches of Greece, Russia and the Middle East. Catholics believe their Communion is real.

So a Catholic who truly can't reach a Catholic priest may receive from an Orthodox one, for real need or real spiritual good.

There must be no risk of error, or of treating all churches as the same.

But Orthodox Churches usually give Communion only to Orthodox Christians, which Catholics should respect.

That isn't a snub. For the Orthodox, sharing Communion is the sign that unity has been reached, not a way to get there.

The Catholic rule works the other way round too. Orthodox Christians who ask for Communion at a Catholic Mass may receive it.

For Protestants, it's only in danger of death, or another serious need the bishop recognises.

Then a Catholic priest may give Communion to a Protestant who can't reach their own minister.

They must ask for it themselves, share the Catholic faith about what Communion is, and be properly prepared.

The Catholic Church admits this hurts. The Catechism says the more painful the division, the more urgent the prayer for full unity.

Holding back from communion is meant to keep that hunger for unity alive, not to push anyone away.

Until then, Catholics can do almost everything else together with other Christians: pray, sing, read the , and serve.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 12
  1. Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (1993), 93, 108–136, 206 · Baptism in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit as the basis of communion; shared prayer, taking part in other churches' services, the Sunday obligation, and why the Eucharist needs full communion.
  2. Code of Canon Law, canon 844 · When Catholics may receive sacraments from other ministers, and give them to other Christians.
  3. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1398–1401 · The Eucharist and the unity of Christians; Orthodox and Reformation churches.
  4. Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (21 November 1964), 3, 8 · Other Christians as brothers; the two principles for common worship.
  5. Code of Canon Law, canons 1247–1248 · Saturday evening Mass fulfils the Sunday obligation.
  6. Southern Baptist Convention, The Baptist Faith and Message (2000), II and VII · Christ as fully God, fully man (II); what the Lord's Supper and baptism are (VII).
  7. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1271–1272 · Baptism unites all Christians; it marks a person as Christ's for good and cannot be repeated.
  8. "Iglesia ni Cristo", Wikipedia · Registered in the Philippines in 1914 by Felix Manalo, formerly a Methodist and Adventist lay preacher; nontrinitarian.
  9. Samuel T. Solano, "Biblical proofs that Christ is not God", Pasugo: God's Message (Iglesia ni Cristo) · The INC's official magazine on its teaching that Christ is man and not God.
  10. Fr John Breck, Why Not “Open Communion”? (Orthodox Church in America, 2007) · Orthodox Churches give communion only to Orthodox Christians; communion is not a means to unity.
  11. Leo XIII, Apostolicae Curae (13 September 1896) · Rules Anglican ordinations made with the Edwardine rite of the 1550s null and void, because the rite removed the priest's power of offering the sacrifice.
  12. The Porvoo Common Statement (1992) · Anglican and Nordic and Baltic Lutheran churches, the Church of Sweden among them, on the historic succession of bishops each has kept.