I'm Orthodox. Can I receive Communion at a Catholic Mass?
On the Catholic side, yes: if you ask for it yourself and are properly prepared, a Catholic priest may give you Communion. But your own Church most likely asks you not to, and the Catholic Church asks you to respect that.
Part 1 · The worry
Picture it. You're with your Catholic husband or wife at a wedding, a funeral, or Sunday .
The line for starts moving. Do you go up?
Communion is the bread and wine Christians share, as Jesus asked his friends to do at his last supper.
Catholics believe it truly becomes his body and blood. So do the .
The Catholic Church is led by the , the of Rome.
The Orthodox in the East and the Catholics in the West were one Church for about a thousand years.
Then they grew apart, above all over the pope's authority.
1054 is the usual date for the split.
Catholics say the East broke from the pope; the Orthodox say Rome broke away by claiming more than the first popes had.
So should you go up? It's a fair question.
And the honest answer depends on two Churches, not one.
Part 2 · What Catholic law says
The Catholic Church's own rulebook, its Code of Canon Law, is clear. A Catholic priest may give Orthodox Christians three .
The three are confession, Communion and the anointing of the sick.
The anointing is a prayer with holy oil for someone who is seriously ill.
There are two conditions.
You must ask for it yourself, and you must be properly prepared.
The Catholic Church's openness here might surprise you, because it's much stricter with most other Christians.
Here's why. Catholics believe your Church has real priests, in an unbroken line from the .
The apostles laid hands on the next leaders to pass on the authority Jesus gave them, and those leaders did the same.
Every Catholic bishop today stands in that line, and so does every Orthodox bishop.
So Catholics believe your Communion is real too.
At your Divine Liturgy, the bread and wine truly become 's body and blood.
The , the Catholic of the 1960s, went further.
It said some sharing in worship with the Orthodox is not only possible but to be encouraged, in the right circumstances and with church approval.
With churches the Catholic answer is stricter, because it doesn't see their ministers in that line from the apostles.
It isn't a judgement on anyone's love for Jesus.
How far Communion can be shared depends on how much is already shared.
Part 3 · Why your Church says no
Now the other side, and it's a strong one.
For the Orthodox, Communion is the sign that unity in faith already exists, not a tool for building it.
You don't just walk up to receive.
You get ready first: you pray, you fast, going without food for a time, and usually you go to confession.
One Orthodox priest in America explains why he wouldn't receive Communion in another Church.
In his words, it would go against my own tradition, to which I have committed myself before God.
The Russian Orthodox Church says the same thing.
Unity in the sacraments comes from one shared faith, not the other way round.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a friend's family inviting you over for Sunday lunch.
They mean it: you're welcome here. They've set an extra plate, cooked your favourite dish, and they wave you to the table.
But your own family has a rule. Sunday lunch is eaten at home, together, with Grandma at the head of the table.
It's not that your friend's food is bad. The meal at home is how your family says we belong to each other.
A good host knows this. They won't phone your parents to argue, and they won't pull you into a chair.
They'll set a place, and leave the choice with your family.
The Catholic Church is like that host. Its invitation is real. So is your Church's rule, and the Catholic Church won't push you past it.
Part 4 · Listen to your own Church
So the Catholic answer doesn't stop at yes. In 1993, the Catholic Church wrote an official guide to dealing with other Christians.
It says Catholics must give due consideration to the rules that Eastern Churches, like yours, set for their own people.
It adds that Eastern Churches may have more restrictive disciplines in this matter, which others should respect.
Disciplines here means rules. It also warns against anything that looks like trying to win members away from another Church.
The respect runs both ways.
If an Orthodox church keeps Communion for its own members, a Catholic who could otherwise receive there must hold back.
And no Catholic bishop may make general rules about this without first talking to the local Orthodox Church.
Part 5 · What about the blessed bread?
At the end of your Liturgy, you go up for the antidoron, the blessed bread.
Its name means in place of the gifts. It isn't Communion.
The West once had the same custom, but there it has become rare.
A few places, mostly in France, still kept it in the 1900s.
If you're ever offered blessed bread at a Catholic Mass, it's ordinary bread with a blessing. It isn't Communion either.
Whether to take it is a good question for your own priest.
Part 6 · One agreed exception
There's one case where the Catholic Church and an Orthodox Church have both said yes.
In 1984, and the head of the Syriac Orthodox Church made a joint statement.
Their people may receive confession, Communion and anointing from each other's priests, when getting to their own is materially or morally impossible.
In plain words, that's when you really can't reach a priest of your own.
The Syriac Orthodox belong to the , a separate family of ancient Churches. If you're Greek, Russian or Serbian Orthodox, this agreement isn't yours.
If you're Syriac Orthodox, it's your own Church's permission too. Otherwise, ask your own priest or bishop what your Church allows.
So what do you do when the Communion line starts moving? You can stay in your seat and pray, and nobody will think twice.
In many parishes you can also go up with your arms crossed over your chest, and the priest will bless you instead.
So the Catholic answer is a door left open, not a door pushed.
If your Church says wait, the Catholic Church would rather you wait with your Church than come alone.
Think back to the Sunday lunch. Why doesn't the good host pull you into a chair?
Pick an answer below.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 10
- Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 844 · When Catholic ministers may give the sacraments to Eastern Christians, and the duty to consult.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1398–1400 · Why sharing is possible with the Orthodox but not with Reformation communities.
- Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 15 · Some sharing in worship with the Eastern Churches is possible and encouraged.
- Fr John Breck, Why Not Open Communion? (Orthodox Church in America) · An Orthodox priest explains why the Orthodox receive only in their own Church.
- Russian Orthodox Church, Basic Principles of Attitude to the Non-Orthodox (2000), 2.12 · True communion in the sacraments has nothing to do with "inter-communion"; unity comes from one faith.
- Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (1993), 122–125 · Respect the Eastern Churches' discipline; Catholics must too.
- Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. II: Benediction and Dismissal · The antidoron, 'in place of the gifts', once given only to those who did not receive Communion.
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Bread, Liturgical Use of · Eulogia and antidoron; the Western blessed bread (pain bénit), still kept especially in France.
- Josef A. Jungmann, The Mass of the Roman Rite, vol. 2 (1951; tr. Francis A. Brunner) · Blessed bread survives in the Eastern liturgies and in rural France and Switzerland.
- John Paul II and Patriarch Ignatius Zakka I Iwas, Common Declaration (23 June 1984), 9 · Catholic and Syriac Orthodox faithful may receive from each other's priests in need.