The Orthodox also have apostolic succession. Why not them?
They do, and the Catholic Church says so openly. It holds that Orthodox bishops, priests and the Eucharist are real. What's missing is full communion, being one Church: the two can't yet share one altar, mainly because they disagree about the pope's role.
Part 1 · A fair question
When Catholics explain why they believe theirs is the one Church Jesus founded, they often point to .
It means in an unbroken line all the way back to the .
The apostles laid hands on the next men to carry on their work, and those men did the same.
But the have exactly that.
Their line goes back just as far. So if that's the test, why aren't Catholics and Orthodox one Church?
If you're Orthodox, you may have heard that Catholics think only they have the real thing.
That isn't what the Catholic Church teaches.
Part 2 · A true Church, in Catholic eyes
In the 1960s the , a Catholic , said the Orthodox Churches possess true sacraments.
Above all, the Orthodox have real priests and a real .
The Eucharist is the bread and wine that Catholics and Orthodox both believe become .
So when an Orthodox priest celebrates the Divine Liturgy, Catholics believe Christ is truly there on that altar.
The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, says the Orthodox celebrate the Eucharist with great love.
In 1993, meeting at Balamand in Lebanon, the official Catholic–Orthodox dialogue commission went a step further.
It asked that future priests on both sides be taught the apostolic succession of the other Church and the authenticity of its sacramental life.
In other words, Catholic priests in training are meant to be taught that Orthodox are real.
Part 3 · One word, two meanings
One word causes confusion: communion. is the bread and wine received at or at the Divine Liturgy.
But means something bigger: Churches that are one Church, sharing one faith and one altar.
Catholics and Orthodox share a great deal, but not full communion.
The Catechism says they're so close that it lacks little for them to celebrate one Eucharist together.
Many Orthodox would say more than a little is missing: the words the West added to the Creed, and the 1870 teaching on the .
Part 4 · So what is missing?
For Catholics, the unbroken line of bishops makes a true Church.
But they believe Christ also gave the apostles a head, and that head was .
To him Christ gave the keys of the kingdom, which are a sign of authority.
So full unity among bishops also means being joined to Peter's successor, the bishop of Rome, the pope.
That bond is what the Catholic Church says is missing.
In Catholic eyes, the Orthodox have everything a Church needs to be a Church. What's broken is the bond between the Churches.
The Orthodox see it the other way round, and their view deserves its full weight.
For them, Rome is the one that moved. It added words to the Creed.
The Creed says the comes from the Father. The West added and the Son.
And, they say, Rome claimed more for the pope than the early Church knew.
Many Orthodox also read Jesus's words to Peter as meant for every bishop who keeps Peter's faith, not only the bishop of Rome.
In 1894 Pope Leo XIII invited the Orthodox to unite with Rome.
The next year the Ecumenical Patriarch answered with his fellow bishops.
The road to unity, they said, is for the Western Church to go back to its old teaching and its old way of running things.
And the Russian Orthodox Church rejects the idea that the Orthodox differ from other Christians only in secondary matters.
Each side believes it kept the faith and the other drifted.
Here's an analogy that might help. Picture two choirs from the same town. A long time ago they were one.
They still sing from the same old scores, copied page by page from their first choirmaster. Every new singer is trained by the ones before.
Go to either concert and you hear the real thing.
Nobody in town doubts that the other choir really sings: same harmonies, same music, same history.
But they split over one question: who conducts when everyone sings together?
Until that's settled, they don't stand on one stage. Singing as one choir would pretend the question had been answered.
That's how Catholics see the Orthodox. The music is real on both sides. What's missing is one stage.
And the question of the conductor is the one that still keeps them apart.
Part 5 · It doesn't run both ways
Catholic rules allow some sharing in worship with the Orthodox, even Communion, given suitable circumstances and the approval of church authorities.
A Catholic priest may give Communion to an Orthodox Christian who freely asks for it and is properly prepared.
But Orthodox Churches usually give Communion only to Orthodox Christians, and ask their own people not to receive it anywhere else.
That isn't a snub. For the Orthodox, sharing Communion is the sign that unity has been reached, not a way to get there.
And Rome tells Catholics to respect that rule.
Orthodox Churches also differ on how they see Catholic sacraments. Many receive a Catholic who joins them with an anointing, accepting the .
Some baptise them again.
Behind that is a strict Orthodox view: outside the Orthodox Church, sacraments are null and void, though the Church can accept them case by case.
Part 6 · Wounds older than the arguments
The distance between the two isn't only about beliefs. Much of it is painful memory.
In 1054, the pope's envoys and the Patriarch of Constantinople, today's Istanbul, excommunicated each other: each formally cut the other off.
In 1204, Western soldiers on a crusade, an armed expedition sent east by Western Christians, looted Constantinople.
It was Christians robbing Christians.
Both wounds have been faced. In 1965, Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras withdrew the old excommunications together.
In 2001, went to Athens and expressed his deep regret for 1204.
Part 7 · Not a return, a reunion
The Catholic Church has also given up an old way of thinking about unity.
At Balamand, Catholics and Orthodox together called outdated the idea that unity means the Orthodox coming back to the Catholic Church.
And neither side is to lure the other's people away.
In 2016 the pope and the Russian Patriarch wrote that their shared mission excludes any form of proselytism: using unfair means to pull believers across.
The goal is what Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras named in 1965: full communion of faith, fraternal accord and sacramental life.
In other words, one faith, brotherly agreement and one altar, the way the Churches lived in the first thousand years.
Rome has never written the Orthodox off. It calls them a true Church with true sacraments.
What's left is to share one altar again.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 14
- Second Vatican Council, Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), 15 · The Orthodox possess true sacraments, above all the priesthood and the Eucharist.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 838 · Communion with the Orthodox lacks little to reach a shared Eucharist.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1399 · The Eastern churches celebrate the Eucharist with great love and have true sacraments.
- Catholic–Orthodox Joint International Commission, Balamand Document (1993), 14, 30 · Sister Churches; the old ecclesiology of return set aside; teach the other Church's succession.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dominus Iesus (2000), 17 · The Orthodox Churches are true particular Churches lacking full communion over the primacy.
- Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Ecumenical Directory (1993), 99, 122–125 · Eastern baptism is valid; sacramental sharing, and respect for stricter Orthodox discipline.
- Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras, Joint Catholic-Orthodox Declaration (7 December 1965) · The excommunications of 1054 removed from memory; the aim of full communion.
- John Paul II, Address to Archbishop Christodoulos, Athens (4 May 2001) · The Pope's words of regret for the sack of Constantinople in 1204.
- Ecumenical Patriarch Anthimos VII and his Synod, Patriarchal Encyclical (1895), 6 · The Orthodox view that unity means the West returning to the faith and order of the first centuries.
- Fr John Breck, Why Not “Open Communion”? (Orthodox Church in America, 2007) · Orthodox Churches give communion only to Orthodox Christians; communion is not a means to unity.
- Russian Orthodox Church, Basic Principles of Attitude to the Non-Orthodox (2000), 2.8 · Differences with other Christians are not only in secondary matters.
- Joint Declaration of Pope Francis and Patriarch Kirill of Moscow and All Russia (Havana, 12 February 2016), 24 · Catholics and Orthodox reject proselytism: no disloyal means to draw believers from one Church to the other.
- Orthodox Church in America, The Orthodox Faith, vol. 3: Relations between the Churches East and West (nineteenth century) · The Russian Church received Western converts by chrismation, while the Greek Church required baptism.
- North American Orthodox–Catholic Theological Consultation, The Principle of Economy (1976) · The strict Orthodox view that non-Orthodox sacraments are null and void, and economy treating them as valid.