Isn't religion the cause of most wars?
No. By most counts, religion was the main cause of only a small share of history's wars, and land, power, money and fear drove most of them. But Christians have fought and killed in God's name, and the Catholic Church has publicly asked forgiveness for it.
Part 1 · The worry
It's a reasonable worry. Popes, the heads of the Catholic Church, called for the Crusades, the medieval wars to win back Jerusalem.
People were burned for what they believed.
And Catholics and Protestants, two of the main branches of Christianity, killed each other across Europe for over a hundred years.
So maybe that's the danger. Believe God is on your side, and you'll kill for him.
But most wars is a claim about numbers. So let's count.
Part 2 · Let's count
One big encyclopedia of wars lists 1,763 of them.
It files 121 of them, about 7%, as religious wars.
That count is rough. Before the 1600s, almost every war was explained in religious words.
One historian thinks the real figure might be double. Even then, religion would be the main cause of about one war in seven.
And even the famous religious wars were mixed. The Thirty Years' War began in 1618 between Catholic and states in Germany.
But later, Catholic France joined Protestant Sweden against a Catholic emperor. By then it was about power.
What about modern wars? Another scholar sorted every war from 1648, when the Thirty Years' War ended, to 1989, by what caused it.
One cause he counted was going to war to protect people of your own faith in another country.
That was a main cause of 14% of wars from 1648 to 1714.
From 1918 to 1941, and from 1945 to 1989, it was a main cause of none.
Religion didn't vanish, though. He kept a separate cause: a people fighting to unite their own ethnic or religious group.
That drove 17% of wars from 1918 to 1941, and 12% after 1945.
But that cause lumps nation and faith together, so it can't tell you how much of it was religion.
And the two world wars, the deadliest in history, weren't fought over religion.
Since the Cold War ended in 1989, though, religion has mattered more.
A 2006 Harvard study found religious civil wars were a growing share of all civil wars.
Many recent ones involve groups claiming to fight for Islam, like Islamic State, which most Muslims reject.
Christians aren't clean either. In Bosnia in the 1990s, Serbs, Catholic Croats and Muslims fought a war that ran along religious lines.
That doesn't mean unbelief causes war instead.
Neither belief nor unbelief excuses violence.
Part 3 · When Christians kill
But counting can't answer everything. Violence that claims God's approval may be worse than the rest.
It tells a soldier that killing is holy.
And saying religion was just the flag they fought under can't excuse everything.
If the Catholic Church takes credit for its hospitals, it has to own its burnings too.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of football.
Fans have fought and even killed over matches: brawls outside stadiums, riots after a big match against local rivals, bottles thrown on the train home.
But nobody says football causes most of the world's violence.
Look closer and it's anger, gangs and drink doing the damage. The club colours just become a flag to fight under.
Still, the club can't just shrug and blame the gangs.
If its own songs are what the fans shout while they hurt people, it has to own that.
It has to ban the violent songs, say sorry to the people hurt, and tell everyone clearly: that's not who we are.
Religion and war work a lot like that.
Most wars aren't about religion. But when people kill under a church's flag, the church has to own it.
Here the founder's own words matter.
Christians follow Jesus, a Jewish teacher who lived about two thousand years ago, and who they believe is God's Son.
The night Jesus was arrested, one of his friends pulled a sword to defend him. Jesus stopped him. He said:
Put your sword back into its sheath, for all who take the sword will perish by the sword.
He'd already told his followers to love your enemies.
So a Christian who kills to spread the faith isn't following Jesus more closely. He's going against him.
Part 4 · What the Catholic Church says now
The Catholic Church teaches that war is an evil to avoid, never a way to spread the faith.
The , its summary of beliefs, says all citizens and all governments are obliged to work for the avoidance of war.
A country may defend itself only under strict conditions. The harm from the attacker must be lasting, grave, and certain.
Every peaceful way out must have failed. There must be a serious chance of success. And the fighting mustn't cause worse evils than it stops.
Killing civilians and prisoners is a crime.
And anyone ordered to take part in genocide, wiping out a whole people, is bound to refuse.
Faith itself can never be forced.
In 1965 the , a meeting of the world's Catholic , taught that no one may be pushed into believing.
And the Council admitted that Christians haven't always lived up to that, or to the , Jesus's own message.
At times, it said, there had been a way of acting hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it.
Catholics believe the Church is holy because Jesus is holy, while its members are sinners who need forgiving.
The Catechism calls it at once holy and always in need of purification.
So it can admit what its members did, without pretending they were someone else.
In 2000, at a service called the Day of Pardon, did just that.
He asked forgiveness for the violence some have used in the service of the truth.
For the year 2000, theology advisers at the Vatican, the Church's headquarters, wrote a study on how to judge the past.
Its rule: don't excuse everything, and don't blame people for things they didn't do.
So the Catholic answer has two parts. Religion isn't the cause of most wars.
But where Christians did kill in God's name, the Catholic Church calls it a , and has said so in public.
Think back to the football fans. If they fight outside the stadium after a match, is football to blame?
Pick an answer below.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
One new thing like this, every Thursday.
One email a week from ACG, about 3 minutes to read. Stop any time.
Sources 11
- Matthew 26:52 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus tells Peter to put his sword away on the night of his arrest.
- Matthew 5:43–48 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus teaches love of enemies in the Sermon on the Mount.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2307–2317 (avoiding war) · War must be avoided; strict conditions for self-defence; genocide must be refused.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 827 · The Church is holy, yet its members are sinners always in need of purification.
- Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (7 December 1965), 12 · No one may be coerced into faith; Christians have sometimes acted against the Gospel.
- John Paul II, Homily for the Day of Pardon (12 March 2000) · The pope asks pardon for violence used in the service of the truth.
- Andrew Holt, "The Myth of Religion as the Cause of Most Wars", in Seven Myths of Military History (Hackett, 2022), republished by the author · A crusades historian counts the Encyclopedia of Wars index: 121 entries (6.9%) under religious wars; his own rough count might double it.
- Wikipedia, Religious war (summarising Phillips and Axelrod's introduction, and Holsti, Peace and War, 1991, p. 308) · Before the 1600s wars were justified in religious terms; Holsti's table of the causes of wars, 1648–1989.
- Wikipedia, Thirty Years' War · Catholic France entered the war in alliance with Protestant Sweden against the Habsburgs.
- International Theological Commission, Memory and Reconciliation: The Church and the Faults of the Past (December 1999) · How the Church judges its past: neither excusing everything nor blaming wrongly.
- Belfer Center (Harvard Kennedy School), Religion, Civil War, and International Order (2006) · religious civil wars as a growing proportion of all civil wars