Full text
No religion, or not sure · About 8 min ·  · Suffering, hell and hope

How can a good God allow so much suffering?

The short answer

Nobody has a neat answer, and the Catholic Church says so. Christianity points to free will, to a world that isn't finished yet, and above all to a God who went through suffering himself, on a cross.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · The question

This may be the hardest question you can ask a Christian.

There's usually a name behind it: a parent with cancer, a friend who took their own life, a child who never got to grow up.

Part 2 · If you're hurting right now

If you're asking because of something that happened to you, nothing on this page is meant to answer that.

A Christian who hands you an argument instead of sitting with you has misunderstood their own faith.

And if things feel too heavy to carry, please talk to someone today.

If you might act on thoughts of suicide, call your local emergency number now.

You can find a free, confidential crisis line in your country at findahelpline.com.

Part 3 · The argument

When you're ready to think it through, here's the argument at its strongest.

If God is good, he'd want to stop suffering. If he's all-powerful, he could.

Suffering exists. So either he isn't good, or he isn't powerful, or he isn't there.

It's not just that suffering exists. It's how much there is, and how often it hits people who did nothing to deserve it.

Serious people find that decisive.

The Catholic Church, the biggest of the three main branches of Christianity, doesn't pretend there's an easy answer.

Its , its official summary of beliefs, calls the question as pressing as it is unavoidable and as painful as it is mysterious.

It says no quick answer will suffice. Instead, its answer is the whole Christian story.

That means a good world, real freedom, God's patient love, Jesus's death and rising, and the hope of life with God for ever.

In its own words:

There is not a single aspect of the Christian message that is not in part an answer to the question of evil.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 309

Part 4 · Free will explains some of it

Christians usually start with free will. If people are free to love, they're free to hurt each other too.

Most of the suffering on the news was chosen by someone.

The Catechism says God is in no way, directly or indirectly, the cause of moral evil, the harm people choose to do.

He allows it because he won't take back the freedom that makes love possible. Love that's forced isn't love.

Think about it. A world where God stopped every bad choice would be a world where nobody really chooses anything.

And the Catechism adds something about that harm. God, it says, mysteriously, knows how to derive good from it.

It points to Joseph, in the , the collection of holy books Christians read. His own brothers sold him as a slave.

Years later, high up in Egypt, he kept many people alive in a famine, his brothers among them. He told them:

You meant evil against me; but God meant it for good
Genesis, quoted in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, 312

That doesn't make the evil good. The Catechism is clear: evil never becomes a good.

But free will doesn't explain a tsunami, or a baby born with a disease that slowly kills her.

For those, the Catechism offers another idea. God made a world in a state of journeying.

It's not finished yet. It's still on its way to what it's meant to be.

In a world like that, things grow and things break down, side by side. Nature has forces that build and forces that destroy.

Often they're the same forces. The fire that warms a home can burn it down.

The cells that let a body grow can grow out of control.

A world with steady laws, where things act the same way every time, is a world we can learn, plan and choose in.

But it's also a world where those same laws can crush the people in their way.

Christians also believe something went wrong at the very start. The first humans stopped trusting God and went their own way.

From that first break, the Church teaches, we all inherited the results, above all death.

But that can't explain all of it. Animals were suffering and dying for millions of years before any human existed.

No human choice caused that. To be honest, the Catholic Church has no full answer to it either.

What the Bible does say is that the hope reaches them too.

, one of the first Christian leaders, wrote that all creation is groaning in labor pains, waiting to be set free.

These are real ideas. But they won't comfort the parent of a dying child, and the Catechism doesn't pretend they will.

Any honest answer has a gap.

Part 5 · Job's friends got it wrong

The Bible doesn't avoid this either. The Book of Job is an ancient book of the Jewish people, mostly poetry, about a good man.

He loses his children, his money and his health. And his friends insist he must have deserved it.

God doesn't explain himself. But he does come, and speaks to Job himself. He asks Job about the whole world he made:

Where were you when I founded the earth?
Job 38:4

Job still isn't given a reason. But in the end he says:

I had heard of you by word of mouth, but now my eye has seen you.
Job 42:5

That's what Job gets: not an answer, but God himself.

Then God turns to Job's friends and tells them they were wrong.

Job, who shouted his complaints at God, was the one who spoke rightly. Suffering isn't proof you're being punished.

, the leader of the Catholic Church at the time, took Job's side in a 1984 letter on suffering.

Some suffering does follow from a person's own wrongs, he wrote. But not all suffering is a punishment:

While it is true that suffering has a meaning as punishment, when it is connected with a fault, it is not true that all suffering is a consequence of a fault and has the nature of a punishment.
John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris (1984), 11

Part 6 · God went into it

The centre of Christianity isn't an explanation of pain. It's a man being executed.

Christians believe the one God is Father, Son and , and that God the Son became one of us. That's Jesus.

He died slowly on a cross. Near the end, he cried out to his Father:

My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?
Mark 15:34

Forsaken means abandoned. It's the first line of 22, an old song of prayer.

He was in agony. But even at his worst, he's still saying my God.

God didn't explain suffering from a safe distance. He went into it.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Picture a children's cancer ward at night. A four-year-old girl is in the middle of chemotherapy.

Her hair is falling out. The medicine makes her throw up. Strangers come in and put needles in her arm.

She can't understand why the person who loves her most is letting this happen.

Why does her mum let them hurt her, and make her sicker than before? She couldn't follow an explanation if she got one.

But there's something she can understand. Her mum hasn't left the room.

She's there when the needle goes in. She's there at 3am, holding the bucket, holding her hand.

The girl doesn't get an explanation. She gets a mother who stays.

The Christian claim is that God hasn't left the room either. On the cross he came all the way into the ward.

That isn't a proof, and it doesn't make the pain smaller. And it doesn't mean every pain is secretly good for you.

Christians believe God could stop suffering, and that's why the question still hurts. But the cross means God didn't spare himself.

And the cross wasn't the end. The say that on the third day, Jesus's tomb was empty.

In the Christian story, death comes from walking away from God. Jesus never did, not once, so death couldn't hold on to him.

He came back to life, and he'll never die again.

And Christians believe he brings everyone who comes home to him through death the same way, into life with him.

John Paul II went further. On the cross, he wrote, human suffering itself has been redeemed: rescued, and given a meaning.

Anyone who suffers, he said, can join their pain to Jesus's, and share in his work of rescuing the world.

Does that mean the cross left something unfinished? John Paul II asked that himself, and answered: No.

In plain words: pain joined to his isn't wasted. It can help others too.

But that's an offer, not a demand. Nobody owes it to anyone to find a meaning in their grief.

And no one should ever tell a grieving person that their loss was useful.

Part 7 · Showing up

The early Christians didn't only talk about suffering. They walked towards it.

When plague hit Alexandria, in Egypt, in the 260s, its , Dionysius, wrote that his people visited the sick fearlessly, and many died doing it.

Many of their neighbours, he says, ran from the sick, even from their closest friends, and left the dead unburied.

He was praising his own people, so allow for that. But it shows what they thought their faith asked of them.

John Paul II pointed to the Good Samaritan, from a story Jesus told.

A foreigner stops for a man beaten and left on the road, after two religious officials walk past.

He wrote:

Everyone who stops beside the suffering of another person, whatever form it may take, is a Good Samaritan.
John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris (1984), 28

In the end, the Catholic Church points to a promise, not an explanation. It's in Revelation, the last book of the Bible:

He will wipe every tear from their eyes, and there shall be no more death or mourning, wailing or pain.
Revelation 21:4

Its answer to suffering isn't a theory. It's a God who suffered with us.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 9
  1. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 309–314 · Why evil exists: no quick answer, God never its cause, free will, a world still journeying.
  2. Job 38:1–4 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · God answers Job out of the storm with questions.
  3. Job 42:1–9 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Job sees God; God says the friends did not speak rightly, Job did.
  4. Mark 15:33–37 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · Jesus's cry from the cross: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"
  5. John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris (11 February 1984) · Apostolic letter on suffering: Job, the cross, the Good Samaritan.
  6. Dionysius of Alexandria, quoted in Eusebius, Church History VII.22 · Christians nursing the sick in the plague of the 260s, in a bishop's own (partial) account.
  7. Revelation 21:1–4 (New American Bible, on vatican.va) · The promise that God will wipe every tear away.
  8. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 397–406 · The first sin as a loss of trust in God; its consequences for all humanity, above all death.
  9. Romans 8:19-23 (New American Bible, Revised Edition, USCCB) · All creation is groaning in labor pains, awaiting freedom.