Do I have to believe in Fatima, Lourdes, or any approved apparition?
No. Even when the Catholic Church approves an apparition like Lourdes, Fatima or Guadalupe, you never have to believe it. Approval means the message has nothing against the faith, and you're free to draw help from it.
Part 1 · The worry
Some Catholics feel like lesser Catholics because Fatima leaves them cold. Others love Lourdes or Guadalupe deeply.
To them, optional sounds like a put-down of something that changed their family's life.
So first, what are we talking about? An apparition is a reported appearance of Mary, Jesus or a saint.
At Fatima in Portugal in 1917, three shepherd children, Lúcia, Francisco and Jacinta, reported visions of Mary.
Long before that, at Lourdes in France in 1858, a girl named Bernadette reported 18 appearances of Mary.
Local later approved both Lourdes and Fatima.
In 1531, on a hill on the edge of what is now Mexico City, an Indigenous man named Juan Diego said Mary appeared to him.
Her image was found on his cloak, and it's still kept in her basilica there, a great church. Popes have backed Guadalupe for centuries.
To be fair, some historians, Catholics among them, have questioned parts of the early record.
In the story, Mary sends Juan Diego to the local bishop. That bishop left many writings, and none that survive mention it.
A former head of the basilica even doubted that Juan Diego had lived.
So the Vatican asked for more evidence before making him a saint.
Part 2 · God has already said everything
Start here. Catholics believe that in Jesus, God has said everything.
No new public revelation, meaning something new for everyone to believe, is to be expected before Jesus comes back.
Public revelation is what God showed everyone in Jesus, handed on by the . It's complete.
Anything after that, however beautiful, is in a different category. Catholics call it .
Private doesn't mean secret. It means it isn't part of the faith everyone is asked to believe.
The says private revelations aren't there to improve or complete Christ's definitive Revelation.
They're there to help people live it more fully in their own time.
At most, a private revelation reminds people of something already there, at a moment when they need reminding.
Part 3 · What approval actually means
So what does approval mean? In 2000 Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, later Benedict XVI, spelled it out.
It means the message has nothing against faith or morals, and you may accept it with care. In his words:
It is a help which is offered, but which one is not obliged to use.
And his test was simple. Does it point to Jesus?
A message that pulls people away from Jesus, or tries to replace the , fails.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of an app in your phone's app store.
Before it appeared there, someone checked it: no viruses, nothing that steals your photos, nothing against the store's rules.
The check is why you can download it without worrying. But notice what it doesn't say.
It doesn't say it's the best app. It doesn't say you have to install it.
Your friend might use it every day and tell everyone about it. You might never open it once. Both of you are fine.
Church approval works like that. It says the message has been checked, so it's safe to draw help from. It doesn't say you must.
Part 4 · Why so careful?
Why is the Church so careful? Because people can be wrong, and some lie.
The Vatican's 2024 rules openly mention people who use these events for profit, power, fame, social recognition, or other personal interest.
A Church that declared every reported vision real would be very easy to fool.
So the local bishop investigates first, then the Vatican reviews it. The same rules cover statues said to weep and other strange signs.
Under those rules, the Vatican's usual yes is simpler: nihil obstat, Latin for nothing stands in the way of the devotion.
It normally no longer declares new cases supernatural, meaning from beyond nature. That isn't a verdict that Lourdes or Fatima were fake.
Medjugorje, a village in Bosnia and Herzegovina where people report visions of Mary, got that kind of yes. People may pray there.
But the Vatican calls the messages alleged messages. And even a yes never obliges anyone to believe it as part of their faith.
Part 5 · And the image at Guadalupe?
Guadalupe has something Lourdes and Fatima don't: an image you can still go and see, on Juan Diego's cloak.
Painters, photographers and scientists with infrared cameras have studied it for centuries.
What they found, and who found it, is told in full in the site's short story on Guadalupe, Lourdes and Fatima.
But do you have to believe the image is a miracle? The same rule applies as for the visions.
The Church welcomes devotion to it. But it has never asked Catholics to accept any scientific verdict about it.
A study can't add to what you must believe, and it can't take anything away either.
Some Catholics find the studies a real help to their faith. Others never read them.
Both stand on the same faith, which rests on Jesus himself.
So, like the Shroud, the cloak is still argued over, and no study has settled it.
And nothing in the faith hangs on it. You can pray before her image whatever the scientists decide.
Part 6 · But popes go to Fatima
Here's the strongest objection. In 2017 Pope Francis made two of the Fatima children saints, at Fatima itself.
In 2002 made Juan Diego a saint, in Guadalupe's own basilica. Surely that's a stamp of approval on the visions?
It's a judgement about their lives, not their visions.
The 2024 rules say making someone a saint doesn't confirm any supernatural events in their life.
That isn't a quiet doubt about Guadalupe or Fatima. The Church honours these saints for how they lived.
And it leaves the visions where they've always been: a gift offered to you, not a test.
To be fair, approval often feels like endorsement, and many Catholics take it that way.
The Catholic Church welcomes the devotion, but it doesn't bind you to it.
So you're free not to believe it. But mocking it, or the people it has helped, isn't the Catholic way either.
Optional doesn't mean less. You can tell a friend you don't have to believe it.
And you can still pray before the image of Our Lady of Guadalupe with your grandmother. Both are true.
You can be a faithful Catholic and never visit Fatima.
And you can love Guadalupe or Lourdes with your whole heart, without making it a test for anyone else.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
One new thing like this, every Thursday.
One email a week from ACG, about 3 minutes to read. Stop any time.
Sources 14
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 65–67 · Revelation is complete in Christ; private revelations do not belong to the deposit of faith.
- Sanctuaire Notre-Dame de Lourdes, The decree (1862) · The 18 apparitions of 1858 and the bishop's recognition on 18 January 1862.
- Santuário de Fátima, Chronology of the three seers · The 1917 visions and the Bishop of Leiria's 1930 declaration.
- Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, The Message of Fatima (26 June 2000), theological commentary · Ratzinger on what approval means and how to test a private revelation.
- Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Norms for Proceeding in the Discernment of Alleged Supernatural Phenomena (17 May 2024) · The six verdicts; no obligation to believe; canonisation is not a verdict on visions.
- Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, The Queen of Peace: note on Medjugorje (19 September 2024) · A nihil obstat for the devotion, without declaring the messages supernatural.
- Pope Francis, Homily at the canonisation of Francisco and Jacinta Marto, Fatima (13 May 2017) · Two of the Fatima children declared saints at the shrine.
- Juan Diego Cuauhtlatoatzin: biography, Vatican (2002) · The 1531 apparitions at Tepeyac, the image on Juan Diego's cloak, kept in the Basilica of Our Lady of Guadalupe.
- George Lee, "Shrine of Guadalupe", Catholic Encyclopedia (1910) · Popes' support for the shrine; Benedict XIV made Our Lady of Guadalupe the national patron, with a feast on 12 December.
- John Paul II, Homily at the canonisation of Juan Diego, Mexico City (31 July 2002) · Juan Diego declared a saint in the Basilica of Our Lady of Guadalupe, "the Marian heart of Mexico and of America".
- Joaquín García Icazbalceta, Carta acerca del origen de la imagen de Nuestra Señora de Guadalupe de México (1883, printed 1896) · A Mexican Catholic historian, writing at his archbishop's request, notes that Bishop Zumárraga's surviving writings never mention the apparition.
- Alejandro Bermúdez, "Mexico Faithful Aren't Buying the Latest Dig at Juan Diego", National Catholic Register (19 December 1999) · Former basilica abbot Guillermo Schulenburg's doubts about Juan Diego's existence (from 1990); the Vatican asked for further proofs in 1997 before the canonisation went ahead.
- Digital Sindonological Lexicon, "The Tilma of Guadalupe" · A Polish encyclopedia of Shroud research that defends a miraculous origin: the 1979 infrared study, later additions (gold rays, the crescent), colours not yet explained.
- Joe Nickell, "'Miraculous' Image of Guadalupe", Skeptical Briefs 12.2 (June 2002) · A skeptic's case: the 1981 infrared report's claims, sketch lines and retouching in the photographs, the 1982 Sol Rosales examination reported by Proceso.