Full text
About this site · About 5 min ·

Are you trying to convert me?

The short answer

Not by pushing you. The Trail is written by a Catholic who argues the Catholic case openly, so it isn't neutral, and it does hope you'll find it worth a closer look. But it won't pressure you: it lays out the evidence, weak points included, and what you make of it is yours.

Scroll to begin, or

Part 1 · A fair question

It's a fair question. A site about Catholic beliefs, built by a Catholic, can feel like a sales pitch with footnotes.

So here's the straight answer. The Trail is built by one person, a Catholic who goes by his initials, ACG.

He says it upfront: I'm Catholic and I argue for it openly.

Pretending to be neutral would be its own kind of spin.

So the site does make a case. But it doesn't push.

Part 2 · A case, not pressure

Making a case isn't the same as pushing you.

ACG promises that the weak points get as much room as the strong ones.

And he says: this isn't here to win an argument. What you make of it is yours.

Think of it like this

Here's an analogy that might help. Think of a friend who swears by one food truck.

The best tacos in the city, he says, and he won't stop talking about them.

So one Saturday he takes you there. He waits in line with you for 20 minutes and tells you what to order.

He's honest, too: some days the tortillas are soggy, and the line can be painfully slow.

But he can't eat them for you. If you try them and prefer the burger truck next to it, he might be a little disappointed.

He's still your friend, and he'll still hang out with you next week.

That's the spirit here: an honest recommendation, flaws and all, and the choice is yours.

Pushing would mean hiding the soggy days, or dropping you if you said no.

Can evidence be pushy too? It can.

Facts can be lined up to corner someone, with the awkward ones quietly left out.

And to be honest, a site built this carefully is persuasion. That's what making a case means. What matters is whether it's fair.

The guard against that is simple: you can check.

Every claim keeps its quote and a link to its source. Most also say how others read the same evidence.

And there's nothing to sign. No account, no mailing list, no prayer to tick at the end. You can read it all and walk away.

You're not asked to accept the case. You're invited to test it.

Part 3 · No one may be forced

You might expect a church to want converts at any cost. The Catholic Church's own rule says the opposite.

In 1965 the world's Catholic , meeting at the , wrote:

no one therefore is to be forced to embrace the Christian faith against his own will
Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (1965), 10

They went further than banning force. Sharing the faith must avoid even a hint of coercion, meaning pressure of any kind.

And it must avoid any persuasion that's dishonorable or unworthy, especially with poor or uneducated people.

Why so strict? Because Christians follow Jesus, and this is how he did it.

In the Catholic Church's words, he invited people to faith and conversion, but never coerced them. He asked. He never forced.

But that rule was written by a Church that had broken it.

The same document admits Catholics at times acted in a way hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it.

The is the good news Jesus brought. In other words, Catholics had acted against Jesus's own message.

The document doesn't say what they did. History gives examples.

One is Goa, Portugal's colony in India. From 1560 a church court there, the Goa Inquisition, worked to force Catholicism on the people.

Hindus were made to gather in churches, again and again, to hear Christian teaching or attacks on their own religion.

By the Church's own rule, that was wrong. Other answers here tell the full history of the Inquisition and the colonial missions.

So why quote the Church's own rules at all? Not as proof. A company quoting its own ad proves nothing.

They're here so you know the standard The Trail has signed up to, and can hold it to that.

The Second Vatican Council gave its reason in one line:

The truth cannot impose itself except by virtue of its own truth
Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (1965), 1

In other words, if something is true, it doesn't need to be forced.

Part 4 · Sharing, not pushing

Catholics aren't told to keep quiet, though.

Ordinary Catholics, not only priests, have the right and duty to work so that Jesus's message may be known and accepted by all.

So Catholics do hope people will accept it. What matters is how they share it.

Francis, the Catholic Church's leader then, put it simply, quoting Benedict XVI, the pope before him.

The Church doesn't grow by pressuring people to join. It grows by attraction.

In other words, it grows when people see something worth a closer look, not when they're worn down.

Part 5 · So what's the aim?

For Christians, the aim ACG names most is unity.

He means Catholics, and Protestants, the three main branches of Christianity, seeing one family history in the same 2,000 years.

He says he isn't hoping everyone reading becomes Catholic tomorrow. He hopes Christians start from what they already share: a love for Christ.

He pictures the day they all sit at one table.

And if you're not a Christian at all? ACG says the site is open to anyone, anywhere.

He hopes the site helps you think it through, whoever you are and wherever you're at.

So no, nobody's trying to corner you. The Trail argues its case, and leaves you completely free to say no.

But wait…

Here are some questions people often ask next.

Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.

The end of this answer

You can stop here.

When you’re ready, the next question is just below.
Sources 7
  1. ACG, About The Trail: "Why I built The Trail" and "What I am trying to do" · The site's author on making the Catholic case openly, showing the weak points, unity at one table, and not hoping everyone becomes Catholic.
  2. The Trail, How we know (the method page), chapter I: How every claim is checked · Each claim keeps its quote, its source, what it can't show and how others read the evidence.
  3. Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (7 December 1965), 1, 4, 10, 12 · No one may be forced to believe; no coercion or dishonourable persuasion; past failures admitted; truth imposes itself only by its own truth.
  4. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 160 · Faith is a free act; Christ invited people to faith and conversion but never coerced them.
  5. Wikipedia, Goa Inquisition · Hindus in Portuguese Goa forced to assemble periodically in churches to hear Christian doctrine or criticism of their religion; the Inquisition there from 1560, and measures meant to force Catholicism on the people.
  6. Catechism of the Catholic Church, 900 · Lay Catholics have the right and duty to work so that the message of salvation is known and accepted.
  7. Pope Francis, Evangelii Gaudium (24 November 2013), 14 · The Church grows not by proselytising but by attraction, quoting Benedict XVI at Aparecida (13 May 2007).