Did Constantine invent Christianity, or choose which books went in the Bible?
No to both. Constantine, a Roman emperor, made persecuting Christians illegal in 313 and called a big meeting of bishops at Nicaea in 325. But Nicaea argued about who Jesus is, not which books belong in the Bible. The four Gospels were already a settled set more than a century before him.
Part 1 · The story you've heard
You've probably heard the story, partly thanks to a bestselling novel, The Da Vinci Code.
A Roman emperor took over a small movement, made Jesus into a god by a vote, and picked the books he liked for the .
If that were true, the Bible would be a government product. So let's check what actually happened.
Part 2 · What Constantine actually did
was a Roman emperor in the early 300s.
Before him, Christians in the empire were often persecuted for their faith.
In 313 he made it illegal to persecute Christians. He paid for churches, ordered copies of the Bible, and called meetings of .
Bishops are the leaders of the Church in each region.
But he didn't make Christianity the official religion. That was a later emperor, Theodosius, in 380.
Here's an analogy that might help. Think of the head of a school who wants to fill the new library.
She orders 50 fresh copies of the book every class has been using for years.
She pays the bill, chases the delivery, and makes sure the boxes arrive before the school year starts.
The teachers are thrilled. Her name might even go on a sign by the library door.
But nobody would say she wrote the book, or chose what's inside it. The teachers had been teaching from it long before she arrived.
She made sure there were enough copies. That's all.
Paying for something isn't the same as making it. That's the difference the myth misses about Constantine.
And that's just what Constantine did. He wrote to a bishop asking for fifty copies of the sacred Scriptures.
He wanted them made by professional copyists, on good parchment, and finished fast.
He ordered the Bibles. He didn't decide what was in them.
Part 3 · Nicaea wasn't about the books
So what was the famous meeting at Nicaea about? It was about one question: who is Jesus?
Christians believe in one God, who is Father, Son and . They call Jesus the Son.
In the early 300s, a priest called taught that Jesus wasn't fully God.
He quoted Scripture too, and a lot of people followed him.
In 325, bishops met at Nicaea, a town in what's now Turkey, to settle it.
Is the Son fully God, in the same way the Father is? Or was he made, something less?
Constantine called the meeting, because the fight was splitting his empire, and he pushed hard for agreement.
But it was the bishops who argued it out. Almost all of them signed, and he exiled Arius and the two bishops who wouldn't.
Their creed, a short statement of belief, says he is fully God.
But nobody made Jesus divine by a vote. More than 200 years earlier, Pliny, a Roman governor, wrote about Christians he had put on trial.
He reported them singing a hymn to Christ as to a god. Christ there means Jesus.
Nicaea argued over what that meant, not whether it was true.
Nicaea's 20 rules still survive, and you can read them today.
They cover things like who's allowed to live in a priest's house, and not kneeling to pray on Sundays.
The contents of the Bible are not among them.
Part 4 · So who settled the list?
No emperor. The is the second part of the Christian Bible: 27 books about Jesus and his first followers.
It grew out of what churches were already reading in their services.
Around AD 180, more than a century before Constantine, a bishop in what's now France wrote about the , the accounts of Jesus's life.
His name was . He said there can't be more or fewer than four.
An early list, usually dated around AD 170 to 200, counts Luke as the third Gospel and John as the fourth.
It's as if everyone already knew there were four. Some scholars date the list later, to the 300s.
The edges were argued over for longer. A historian writing in Constantine's own day says some people still doubted books like Hebrews, James and Revelation.
All three are now in the New Testament. Constantine hadn't settled it.
Other books called gospels did exist, like the Gospel of Thomas. Breakaway groups passed them around under the names of the , Jesus's first messengers.
The same historian lists them, and says no earlier church writer had thought them worth mentioning.
Thomas isn't a story of Jesus's life. It's a list of 114 sayings, and almost two-thirds are like sayings in the four Gospels.
Most scholars date it to the 100s, after the four, though some argue parts of it are older.
And the Gospel of Judas? Judas was the follower who betrayed Jesus.
Irenaeus already knew this book around AD 180, and called it a fictitious history.
It came from a group that taught Judas alone understood the truth, and handed Jesus over on purpose.
The one copy that survives, in an Egyptian language, was made around AD 220 to 340. Nobody can be sure it's the book Irenaeus meant.
Nobody picked four out of a pile of equals.
Most of the others were written later, by smaller groups, and it was the churches, not an emperor, that left them out.
The first surviving list that matches today's 27 New Testament books comes from a bishop in Egypt, in 367.
So there was an argument. But it happened among churches, over generations, and not at Nicaea.
The Catholic Church says it didn't invent the Bible's list. It recognised it, from how the books had been received and used since the apostles.
The , the Catholic Church's summary of its beliefs, puts it in one line. By apostolic Tradition it means what the apostles handed on:
It was by the apostolic Tradition that the Church discerned which writings are to be included in the list of the sacred books.
Part 5 · The harder question
Now the honest part. The real problem with Constantine is harder for Christians than the myth.
In one generation, a persecuted movement gained money, grand buildings and the backing of the state.
Within decades, emperors were turning beliefs into law.
Theodosius went on to crush the old Roman religion, and a rival Christian group that said Jesus wasn't fully God.
That's a serious charge, with real evidence behind it. The claim that he invented Christianity has no evidence like that.
The Catholic Church has owned that darker side. In 1965 it said so at the , a meeting of the world's bishops.
It admitted that at times, in the Church's own life, there had been this:
a way of acting that was hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel or even opposed to it
In other words, some of what was done went against the message of Jesus itself.
Then it added a line that's hard to square with that history, since force was used anyway:
Nevertheless, the doctrine of the Church that no one is to be coerced into faith has always stood firm.
Part 6 · 1,700 years later
Nicaea still matters, for a different reason. Its creed, filled out at a second meeting in 381, is still said every Sunday at .
Mass is the Catholic Sunday service.
Christians, whose Churches go back to the first centuries in the East, say it too.
So do many churches, the third main branch of Christianity.
There's one difference. In most Catholic churches in the West, the creed says the Holy Spirit comes from the Father and the Son.
The Western Church added those last words later. The Orthodox never did.
On 28 November 2025, Leo XIV, the leader of the Catholic Church, went to Iznik, the Turkish town that was once Nicaea.
The Patriarch of Constantinople, today's Istanbul, who is first in honour among Orthodox bishops, welcomed him there with leaders of other churches.
They stood above the ruins of an ancient church, half sunk in the lake. Catholic and Orthodox hymns were sung in turn.
When they prayed the creed, the pope left out the West's added words, and the Son.
And together, 1,700 years later, they said the same creed.
So the myth gets the story backwards. Constantine didn't give the Church its books.
He found a Church that already had them, already had bishops, and had just survived an attempt to wipe it out.
Here are some questions people often ask next.
Swipe through the questions people often ask next, and open any of them.The questions people often ask next. Open any of them.
You can stop here.
Sources 18
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 120 · The canon discerned by apostolic Tradition, and the full list of books.
- First Council of Nicaea (325): Creed and Canons (NPNF, New Advent) · The creed and all twenty canons; none concerns the Bible's contents.
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.11 (c. AD 180, New Advent) · The four Gospels, "neither more nor less".
- Athanasius, Festal Letter 39 (AD 367, New Advent) · The first surviving list matching today's 27 New Testament books.
- Eusebius, Life of Constantine 4.36 (NPNF, New Advent) · Constantine orders fifty copies of the Scriptures.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Constantine I" · The Edict of Milan (313), his support for the Church, baptism in 337.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Theodosius I" · The edict of 28 February 380 making one creed binding on all subjects.
- Catholic News Service via USCCB, "Though Nicaea in ruin, its creed stands and unites Christians, pope says" (28 November 2025) · Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew pray at Iznik, above a ruined basilica in the lake, for the creed's 1,700th anniversary.
- Second Vatican Council, Dignitatis Humanae (7 December 1965), 12 · The Church admits conduct "hardly in accord with the spirit of the Gospel".
- Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96 (c. AD 112, Early Christian Writings) · A Roman governor reports Christians singing a hymn "to Christ as to a god".
- Eusebius, Church History, book 3, chapters 3 and 25 (NPNF, New Advent) · Which books were accepted and which still disputed in the early 300s; the Gospels of Peter, Thomas and Matthias listed among books used by heretics under the apostles' names.
- General Instruction of the Roman Missal (2002), 67-68 · The Creed is said or sung at Mass on Sundays and solemnities.
- Wikipedia, The Da Vinci Code (Dan Brown, 2003) · Sales of 80 million copies; the novel's claim that Constantine destroyed the other gospels and promoted the four.
- The Muratorian Fragment (bible-researcher.com) · An early list counting Luke as the third Gospel and John as the fourth.
- Peter Kirby, "Muratorian Canon", Early Christian Writings · Usually dated 170-200; some have redated it to the fourth century.
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.31 (c. AD 180, New Advent) · A group that held Judas alone knew the truth and "accomplished the mystery of the betrayal"; "a fictitious history of this kind, which they style the Gospel of Judas".
- Wikipedia, Gospel of Judas · The only known copy, in the Codex Tchacos, carbon-dated to 220-340; uncertain whether it is the work Irenaeus meant.
- Wikipedia, Gospel of Thomas · A collection of 114 sayings, not a narrative; almost two-thirds resemble sayings in the four Gospels; most scholars date it to the second century, some earlier.