Part XIII · Chapter 33
Relics and other Christian artifacts

Churches show a splinter they call the Cross and bones they call Peter's. Is any of it real, and why would anyone keep a dead man's bones in the first place?

10 scenes · about 25 min read

The short answer

Some of it is real, some is probably real, some is legend and some is fake. Much of the sorting was done by the Catholic Church's own scholars.

Christians keep because the body matters: it was a temple of the , and it will rise again. Relics are honoured for 's sake; only God is worshipped.

The strongest evidence is in the graves, not the golden cases.

By about AD 200 Roman Christians were pointing to 's grave on the Vatican Hill. The bones themselves are less certain: their path from a niche beside the grave to a storeroom box rests on one workman's memory.

Wood said to be the Cross was honoured in Jerusalem by 350, but the story of Helena finding it comes later.

Some relics were false: Joan of Arc's 'relics' came from a mummy. Because relics were faked, sold and stolen, the Catholic Church now forbids selling them and tells to withdraw doubtful ones. No Catholic has to believe any particular relic is genuine.

Follow the trail

Ten objects and documents, from cloths that touched Paul to bones a pope sent to Istanbul in 2019.

Mid-first centuryRevealed2 min read

Cloths that had touched Paul

Luke, in the Acts of the Apostles

In the mid-first century the preached in Ephesus, a port in today's Turkey. Luke's book, the Acts of the Apostles, says cloths that had touched Paul's skin were taken to the sick, and they got well.

IWhat was going on

Ephesus was a great port, famous for its temple of the goddess Artemis. It was also a city of magic: charms, spells and books of secret formulas.

Paul spent more than two years there. He preached first in the synagogue, the Jewish meeting place, and then in a lecture hall. Acts says the whole province heard the message.

IIWhat was at stake

In a city full of charms and amulets, people would naturally treat anything linked to a holy man as magic.

The question was whether God works through ordinary things at all, and how to tell that from superstition.

IIIWhat happened

Luke says God did extraordinary things through Paul. Face cloths and aprons that had touched his skin were taken to the sick, and their illnesses left them.

Soon after, many in Ephesus who had practised magic brought their spell books and burned them in public. Luke is careful: it was God who did the deeds, not the cloth.

IVWhat came of it

The idea had deep roots. The Jewish Scriptures tell of a dead man who came back to life when his body touched the bones of the prophet Elisha.

A century after Paul, the church at Smyrna, another city in today's Turkey, gathered the bones of its bishop, , who had been killed for his faith. They kept them as more precious than jewels, and met at his grave each year.

VRead the source
So extraordinary were the mighty deeds God accomplished at the hands of Paul that when face cloths or aprons that touched his skin were applied to the sick, their diseases left them and the evil spirits came out of them.
The New American Bible (vatican.va IntraText edition; 1986 revised New Testament) · Acts 19:11-12 (New American Bible, vatican.va IntraText edition, __PYD.HTM)

Why it matters

Catholics and Orthodox see here the reason for relics, the remains of saints and things they touched. God works through the body and the things it touched, because the body matters to him. It was made by God and will be raised.

Many Protestants read it as a one-off sign that marked out Paul as an apostle, not a pattern for keeping objects. Both agree the power was God's.

Before AD 216Historical2 min read

A bishop's gravestone that speaks in riddles

Abercius, bishop of Hieropolis in Phrygia

In the late 100s Abercius, a bishop in what is now central Turkey, wrote a poem for his own gravestone. In Christian code, it speaks of Rome, of believers everywhere, and of a Fish given as food with wine and bread.

A rough block of marble carved with lines of Greek capital letters, on a plinth.
Surviving fragment of the gravestone of Abercius, bishop of Hieropolis, late second or early third century. Vatican Museums.
IWhat was going on

Abercius was bishop of Hieropolis, a town in Phrygia, in the middle of today's Turkey, in the late second century. Christianity was still illegal, and a gravestone stood in public view.

Early Christians used the fish as a secret sign for Christ. The Greek word for fish, ichthys, spells the first letters of Jesus Christ, Son of God, Saviour.

IIWhat was at stake

How do you tell the world what you believe, on a stone anyone can read, without spelling it out for every hostile passer-by?

Abercius wrote in riddles that fellow Christians would understand and others would pass over.

IIIWhat happened

In the poem Abercius says he travelled to Rome and saw a people bearing a shining mark. Everywhere he went, faith gave him a Fish drawn from a spring by a holy virgin, to eat with wine mixed and bread.

He asks everyone who understands to pray for him. The meal reads as the Eucharist, the bread and wine Christians share as Christ's body and blood. Many read the holy virgin as Mary, Jesus's mother.

IVWhat came of it

The stone was lost for centuries. In 1883 the archaeologist William Ramsay found two pieces of it built into the wall of a public bath at Hieropolis. A copy on another grave, dated 216, shows the poem is older than that.

Some scholars once argued Abercius was a pagan priest of the goddess Cybele. The Christian reading has held. The pieces are now in the Vatican Museums.

VRead the source
And to Rome he sent me to contemplate majesty, and to see a queen golden-robed and golden-sandalled; there also I saw a people bearing a shining mark. ... Faith everywhere led me forward, and everywhere provided as my food a fish of exceeding great size, and perfect, which a holy virgin drew with her hands from a fountain and this it [faith] ever gives to its friends to eat, it having wine of great virtue, and giving it mingled with bread.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Inscription of Abercius' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Inscription of Abercius', by Henri Leclercq, text of the epitaph as restored

Why it matters

The gravestone is evidence carved in stone by a bishop of the 100s, not a story written down later. It speaks of Rome, the Eucharist and prayer for the dead in one short poem.

It shows what the early Church believed, in the way it buried its dead.

c. AD 200Historical2 min read

A Roman points to the apostles' graves

Gaius of Rome, quoted by Eusebius

Around AD 200 a Roman Christian named Gaius answered a rival group with directions. Come to Rome, he said, and see the monuments of Peter on the Vatican Hill, and of Paul on the road to Ostia, Rome's port.

A marble chamber beneath St Peter's Basilica, lit by hanging lamps, with a mosaic of Christ in a niche at its far end.
The shrine over Peter's grave beneath the high altar of St Peter's, Rome. Gaius pointed to this place around AD 200.
IWhat was going on

In the late 100s a movement called Montanism spread from Phrygia, in today's Turkey. Its followers trusted new prophets who claimed the Holy Spirit spoke through them.

One of their leaders, Proclus, pointed to the graves of the apostle Philip's prophesying daughters at Hierapolis. To him they proved his side had the apostles' heritage.

IIWhat was at stake

Whose church truly came from the apostles, the men Jesus sent out to spread his message? In an age of rival teachers, roots that went back to the apostles were a kind of proof.

Gaius, a Christian in Rome in the time of Bishop Zephyrinus (199–217), needed to answer Proclus.

IIIWhat happened

He offered the strongest evidence a Roman could: I can show the trophies of the apostles. A trophy was a victory monument. Go to the Vatican, or to the road to Ostia, and you will find the monuments of those who founded this church.

The church historian Eusebius, quoting him a century later, says the words refer to the places where the apostles' bodies lay.

IVWhat came of it

In the 320s the emperor Constantine built St Peter's Basilica on the Vatican Hill. His builders dug into a hillside cemetery to set its altar over that spot.

Excavations under St Peter's from 1939 to 1949 found a small shrine from about 160 above a simple grave. It is very likely the trophy Gaius meant.

VRead the source
But I can show the trophies of the apostles. For if you will go to the Vatican or to the Ostian way, you will find the trophies of those who laid the foundations of this church.
Church History (Historia Ecclesiastica) · Church History 2.25.6-7 (trans. A. C. McGiffert, NPNF Second Series vol. 1; New Advent 250102.htm)

Why it matters

By about 200 Rome's Christians were pointing to Peter's grave, and a shrine had stood over it for a generation.

That doesn't prove whose bones lay below. But it shows the memory of Peter's burial there is very old, and the grave is far firmer ground than any bones.

c. AD 200-217Historical1 min read

Cemeteries that were called dormitories

The church of Rome, under Zephyrinus and the deacon Callixtus

Around AD 200 the church of Rome began its underground cemeteries, the catacombs. Ordinary believers lay in rows of niches cut into the rock, the plainest and most equal kind of grave.

A narrow underground passage cut into soft rock, its walls lined with rows of empty rectangular burial niches.
Burial niches (loculi) in the Catacombs of Domitilla, Rome: the plain, equal graves of ordinary Christians.
IWhat was going on

Roman law didn't allow burials inside the city walls, so cemeteries lined the roads outside. Many Romans were cremated.

Christians wanted to bury their dead, because they believed the body would rise again. They also wanted to lie together, as one family.

IIWhat was at stake

Land outside Rome was expensive, and many Christians were poor. How could a growing church give everyone, slave or free, a decent grave?

The answer was to dig down into the soft volcanic rock, gallery under gallery.

IIIWhat happened

Bishop Zephyrinus put Callixtus, a or church assistant, in charge of the cemetery on the Appian Way, a main road out of Rome. Callixtus later became bishop of Rome himself, and several third-century bishops of Rome were buried there.

The walls were painted with Jonah, Lazarus, the Good Shepherd and the fish: stories of rescue from death. Christians called these places dormitories, sleeping-places.

IVWhat came of it

Pilgrims later came to pray at the graves of the martyrs, those killed for their faith, and popes restored them. In the early Middle Ages, as Rome emptied and raiders came, the martyrs' remains were moved into churches inside the city.

The catacombs were mostly forgotten until they were rediscovered in the sixteenth century.

VRead the source
The ancient term to designate these monuments is coemeterium, which derives from the Greek and means “dormitory”, thereby stressing the fact that for Christians, burial is just a temporary moment while they wait for the final resurrection.
Christian Catacombs · Pontifical Commission for Sacred Archaeology, 'Christian Catacombs', section 'Origin of the catacombs'

Why it matters

The catacombs were burial grounds the Roman authorities knew about, not secret hideouts. The legend of Christians living in them is wrong.

What they do show is a church that buried its poor beside its bishops and honoured its martyrs. It prayed for its dead and expected them to rise.

c. AD 350Historical2 min read

The wood is already everywhere

Cyril of Jerusalem, teaching candidates for baptism

Around AD 350 Cyril taught new Christians at Golgotha in Jerusalem, where Jesus died, some twenty years after the ground there was dug out. Wood believed to be the Cross was kept there, and he said pieces had already gone across the world.

IWhat was going on

In 135 the emperor Hadrian rebuilt Jerusalem as a Roman city. A pagan temple was built over the place Christians remembered as Golgotha, where Jesus was and buried.

Around 326 ordered the temple torn down. The diggers found a rock-cut tomb, and Christians hailed it as Christ's. The Church of the Holy Sepulchre, the church of the tomb, was dedicated there in 335.

IIWhat was at stake

Somewhere in that work, wood believed to be the Cross was found and kept. Pilgrims flooded in, and everyone wanted a piece to take home.

Was that devotion, or a market waiting to happen?

IIIWhat happened

Around 350 Cyril, who later became bishop of Jerusalem, gave talks in the church built at Golgotha. They were for adults preparing for , the washing with water by which someone becomes a Christian.

He told them the holy wood of the Cross was seen among them that very day. From Jerusalem it was already filling the whole world, as believers took pieces of it away.

IVWhat came of it

An inscription of 359 from Tixter, in today's Algeria, lists a piece of the Cross among a church's relics.

Around 380 the pilgrim Egeria watched church assistants, the deacons, guard the wood on Good Friday, the day Christians remember Jesus's death. Someone, she was told, had once bitten off a piece and run.

VRead the source
The holy wood of the Cross bears witness, seen among us to this day, and from this place now almost filling the whole world, by means of those who in faith take portions from it.
Catechetical Lecture 10 ('On the clause, And in One Lord Jesus Christ') · Catechetical Lecture 10.19 (trans. E. H. Gifford, NPNF Second Series vol. 7)

Why it matters

The devotion to the Cross is real and early: within a generation of the dig, pieces were across the Roman world.

Whether the wood was truly Christ's cross can't be proved. The Catholic Church doesn't ask anyone to believe that it was.

25 February 395Historical2 min read

The story of Helena arrives

Ambrose of Milan, at the memorial of the emperor Theodosius

In 395 Ambrose, bishop of Milan, told how Helena, mother of the emperor Constantine, searched Golgotha and found the Cross. That was nearly seventy years after the dig. In the texts that survive, the story comes long after the relic.

A wide Renaissance fresco: on the left workmen dig up crosses outside a hill town; on the right kneeling women watch a cross held over a man rising from a bier.
Piero della Francesca, Finding and Recognition of the True Cross, San Francesco, Arezzo, between 1452 and 1466. It paints the later legend, in which a miracle picks out the true cross.
IWhat was going on

The emperor Theodosius I died at Milan in January 395, leaving the empire to two young sons. Forty days later Ambrose, bishop of Milan, preached at his memorial.

He held up Helena, Constantine's mother, as a model of a Christian ruler. She had visited the Holy Land in the 320s and built churches there.

IIWhat was at stake

The wood was honoured, but how had it been found, and how did anyone know it was Christ's?

The earliest account of Helena's journey was written by the church historian Eusebius around 339. It describes her churches and gifts to the poor, and never mentions a cross.

IIIWhat happened

Ambrose tells the story. Helena searched Golgotha and found three crosses. She knew Christ's by the title, the sign had fixed above it.

Then he adds the line that matters most: she worshipped the King, not the wood, because worshipping wood is the error of pagans.

IVWhat came of it

A few years later the historian Rufinus told it differently: a sick woman was healed by touching the true cross. The story grew with each telling.

It shaped Christian art for a thousand years. The feast of the Holy Cross on 14 September still remembers the dedication of the church at Golgotha.

VRead the source
Helen, then, came and commenced to look about the sacred places. The Spirit inspired her to search for the wood of the Cross ... She discovered, then, the title; she adored the King; not the wood indeed, because this is an error of the Gentiles and a vanity of the wicked; but she adored Him who hung on the wood, who was inscribed in the title
On the Death of Theodosius (De obitu Theodosii) · De obitu Theodosii 43 and 46 (trans. M. D. Mannix, 1925, pp. 78-79)

Why it matters

Helena's finding is tradition, not documented history. The relic came first and the story came later.

But Ambrose's line is still Catholic teaching: the honour goes through the object to Christ. Worship belongs to God alone.

590sHistorical2 min read

Rome refuses to cut up an apostle

Pope Gregory the Great, to the Empress Constantina

In the 590s the Empress Constantina, in Constantinople, asked for the head of Paul, or some other part of his body. Gregory refused. In Rome, he wrote, nobody touched the bodies of the saints.

IWhat was going on

In the 590s Rome was a battered city, threatened by the Lombards, a Germanic people who had invaded Italy. It depended on the emperor in Constantinople for troops and money.

In the East, saints' bodies were often moved and divided. Constantinople had brought in relics of the apostles Andrew, Luke and Timothy two centuries before. Empress Constantina wanted Paul for a church in her palace.

IIWhat was at stake

Saying no to the empress was risky. Saying yes meant breaking open the apostle's tomb, something Romans held sacred and dangerous.

Gregory had to protect Rome's custom without insulting the emperor's wife.

IIIWhat happened

Gregory wrote back that it was not the Roman custom even to touch the saints' bodies. Instead, a cloth was placed in a box near the tomb, and sent. It was believed to carry the saint's blessing.

He offered her filings from the chains of Saint Peter instead. He had heard that Greeks dug up saints' bones, and wrote that he could scarcely believe it.

IVWhat came of it

The Roman caution didn't last. In the 700s and 800s, as the catacombs became unsafe, popes moved martyrs' bodies into churches inside the city. Bones were divided and sent across Europe.

Later Catholic Church rules tried to stop relics being broken into ever smaller pieces.

VRead the source
Moreover, let my most tranquil lady know that it is not the custom of the Romans, when they give relics of saints, to presume to touch any part of the body; but only a cloth (brandeum) is put into a box (pyxide), and placed near the most sacred bodies of the saints
Register of Letters, Book IV, Letter 30, to Constantina Augusta · Register of Letters, Book IV, Letter 30, to Constantina Augusta (trans. James Barmby, NPNF Second Series vol. 12)

Why it matters

East and West both honoured relics, but not always in the same way. Rome began more cautious than Constantinople.

Gregory's letter is a reminder that reverence for the saints once meant leaving their bodies alone. The later trade in body parts was a change, not the start.

1238-1239Historical2 min read

A king pays the debt on the Crown of Thorns

Louis IX of France and Baldwin II, Latin emperor of Constantinople

In 1239 King Louis IX of France brought the Crown of Thorns, said to be Christ's, to Paris after paying off a loan on it. He built the Sainte-Chapelle to hold it. In 2019 it was carried out of burning Notre-Dame.

A tall gilded silver reliquary shaped like a crown on a pedestal, with seated royal figures at its base and red velvet visible inside.
Reliquary made for the Crown of Thorns in Paris in 1862 by Placide Poussielgue-Rusand after Viollet-le-Duc, shown empty at the Louvre in January 2024.
IWhat was going on

In 1204 Western crusaders sacked Constantinople, a Christian city, and stole countless relics from its churches. They set up a Latin empire there, run by Western Christians.

Thirty years later that empire was broke. Its ruler, Baldwin II, had pawned the Crown of Thorns to lenders in Venice as security for a loan.

IIWhat was at stake

Baldwin needed money and allies. Louis IX, a deeply devout king, wanted the relic for France.

The question was whether a holy object could be bought and sold. Church law had banned the sale of relics in 1215. Louis paid off the loan, rather than buying the relic outright.

IIIWhat happened

Louis paid off the Venetians. On 19 August 1239 he carried the Crown into Paris barefoot, wearing a simple tunic.

He built the Sainte-Chapelle, a chapel of stained glass, to hold it. It was finished in 1248. The Crown is a ring of rushes, a reed-like plant. Its thorns seem to have been given away over the centuries as separate relics.

IVWhat came of it

During the French Revolution the Crown was moved out of the chapel. In 1806 it was given back to the Church and kept at Notre-Dame Cathedral.

On 15 April 2019, as Notre-Dame burned, firefighters and a chaplain carried it out. It returned to the restored cathedral on 13 December 2024.

VRead the source
In 1238 Baldwin II, the Latin Emperor of Constantinople, anxious to obtain support for his tottering empire, offered the Crown of Thorns to St. Louis, King of France. It was then actually in the hands of the Venetians as security for a heavy loan, but it was redeemed and conveyed to Paris where St. Louis built the Sainte-Chapelle (completed 1248) for its reception.
Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crown of Thorns' · Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crown of Thorns', by Herbert Thurston, third paragraph

Why it matters

From 1238 the Crown's story is documented. Before that the record is thin, and its link to Christ's suffering and death rests on tradition.

Its route to Paris also runs through the sack of 1204. In 2001 Pope John Paul II said that Latin Christians' sack of the city fills Catholics with deep regret.

3 December 1563Inference2 min read

A council keeps relics but bans the profit

The Council of Trent, Session XXV

In 1563 the Council of Trent, the Catholic bishops' answer to the Reformation, passed a decree on relics. Honour the bodies of the saints, it said, and strip out the superstition and the money.

IWhat was going on

The Protestant Reformers had written hard against relics. In England nearly every shrine was torn down in 1538. 's Treatise on Relics of 1543 mocked the fakes in Europe's churches, and called the whole practice a road to idolatry.

Some of the mockery was deserved. Medieval church treasuries were full of relics no one could trust.

IIWhat was at stake

Could the Catholic Church defend honouring relics while admitting the abuses?

It had to say clearly what it believed, and why. Then it had to fix the practice so the Reformers' charges would no longer be true.

IIIWhat happened

On 3 December 1563 the council passed its decree. The bodies of the martyrs, it says, were living members of Christ and temples of the Holy Spirit, and God will raise them to glory. So they are to be honoured.

The same decree ordered every superstition removed and all filthy lucre, greedy profit, abolished. No new relic was to be recognised without the bishop's approval.

IVWhat came of it

Catholic scholars over the following centuries sorted fakes from likely relics. Some relics once honoured were withdrawn.

Today the Catholic Church's law says it is absolutely forbidden to sell sacred relics. A 2017 Vatican instruction requires a certificate before any relic is shown.

VRead the source
the holy bodies of holy martyrs, and of others now living with Christ,-which bodies were the living members of Christ, and the temple of the Holy Ghost, and which are by Him to be raised unto eternal life, and to be glorified,--are to be venerated by the faithful ... Moreover, in the invocation of saints, the veneration of relics, and the sacred use of images, every superstition shall be removed, all filthy lucre be abolished
Canons and Decrees of the Council of Trent · Session XXV, decree on the invocation, veneration and relics of saints (Waterworth 1848, pp. 234-236)

Why it matters

The Catholic reason for relics is the body: it was a temple of the Spirit, and it will rise. Honouring a saint's remains points to that hope.

The rules exist because the abuses were real. No Catholic depends on any single relic, and no Catholic must believe a particular one is genuine.

June 2019Historical2 min read

Peter's bones go to his brother's city

Pope Francis, to Patriarch Bartholomew of Constantinople

On 29 June 2019, the feast of Peter and Paul, Pope Francis gave an Orthodox delegation nine fragments of bone found under St Peter's in Rome. They were to be kept beside the relics of Andrew, Peter's brother, in Istanbul.

IWhat was going on

Excavations under St Peter's between 1939 and 1949 found the old shrine over Peter's grave. In 1950 Pope Pius XII said the tomb had been found, but bones found there could not be proved to be Peter's.

Later the archaeologist Margherita Guarducci traced other bones from a niche beside the grave. In 1968 Pope Paul VI called that identification convincing. Other experts disagreed, among them Antonio Ferrua, one of the Jesuits who had dug the tomb.

IIWhat was at stake

Catholics and Orthodox have been divided for nearly a thousand years; 1054 is the date usually given. Peter is the apostle of Rome. His brother Andrew is honoured as the founder of the church of Constantinople.

How could a pope show, in a way people could see and touch, that the two churches are brothers too?

IIIWhat happened

On 29 June 2019, after Mass on the feast of Saints Peter and Paul, Francis met a delegation from the Ecumenical Patriarchate. That is the office of the Orthodox bishop who holds first place of honour among them, in Istanbul.

He handed them a bronze case with nine fragments of the bones, kept until then in the papal apartments.

In a letter that August he explained his choice. The bones, he wrote, can quite reasonably be considered Peter's, and he wanted them beside Andrew's relics in Constantinople.

IVWhat came of it

The relics are now kept by the Ecumenical Patriarchate in Istanbul.

In 2004 Pope John Paul II had already returned relics of two patriarchs of Constantinople, taken to Rome long before. In November 2025, Pope Leo XIV and Patriarch Bartholomew prayed the Nicene Creed together at İznik, ancient Nicaea.

VRead the source
This contained bones that can quite reasonably be considered those of the Apostle Peter. ... I sensed that it would be highly significant were some fragments of the relics of the Apostle Peter to be placed beside the relics of the Apostle Andrew, who is venerated as the heavenly patron of the Church of Constantinople.
Letter of the Holy Father Francis to His Holiness Bartholomew I, Archbishop of Constantinople, accompanying the gift of some relics of Saint Peter (30 August 2019) · Letter of Pope Francis to Bartholomew I accompanying the gift of some relics of Saint Peter (30 August 2019), paragraphs 3 and 5

Why it matters

Francis's careful wording shows the Catholic Church's honesty: quite reasonably, not proven. No pope has formally declared the bones authentic.

It also shows what relics can still do. Two brothers' remains, side by side, are a sign of the both churches say they are seeking and have not yet reached.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

The Catholic Church honours relics because of what it believes about the body. The calls the bodies of the living members of Christ and temples of the Holy Spirit, which God will raise.

The already shows God healing through cloths that had touched Paul.

The honour goes to the saint for Christ's sake; worship goes to God alone. Ambrose, bishop of Milan, said it in 395: Helena adored the King, not the wood.

The hold the same, and every Orthodox service of the is celebrated over relics.

The rules follow from the belief, and the Catholic Church writes them down.

Its law book, law, states that it is 'absolutely forbidden to sell sacred relics'. A 2017 instruction bans any trade in them, and any display without a certificate that the relic is genuine.

A Vatican guide, the Directory on Popular Piety, tells bishops to withdraw doubtful relics quietly. It also tells them to stop relics being broken into ever smaller pieces. No Catholic is obliged to believe that any particular relic is genuine.

The Catholic case does not rest on the famous relics. It rests on humbler things that can be dated. By about 200 Roman Christians were pointing to Peter's grave, and a second-century monument stands on the spot.

Abercius's gravestone, from the same generation, speaks of Rome, of a people bearing a shining mark, and of a Fish given with bread and wine.

The catacombs, Rome's underground cemeteries, show a church that buried its poor and its bishops in the same places, and called them dormitories.

On the famous relics the Catholic answer is honesty, and much of it came from Catholics. The Jesuit historian Herbert Thurston wrote in the Catholic Encyclopedia in 1911 that medieval treasuries were crowded with 'unquestionably spurious relics'.

Another Catholic scholar, Johann Peter Kirsch, accepted that the Philomena tiles came from another grave. The Jesuit Antonio Ferrua disputed the bones under St Peter's.

The Catholic Church accepts that some relics it once honoured were false, and it has withdrawn some.

The abuses were real, and the Catholic Church does not defend them. , a North African bishop, complained of fake relics at the end of the fourth century.

A at the Lateran in Rome banned their sale in 1215, and Trent ordered profit and superstition removed in 1563.

Western crusaders stole relics from Constantinople in 1204. In 2001 said that the sack of the city by Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret. In 2004 and 2019 popes sent relics east as signs of reconciliation.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Eastern Orthodox

The Orthodox honour relics at least as fully as Catholics. The Orthodox Church in America's manual for adults says that meeting a relic means meeting the saint himself. By God's , it says, the saint is not separated from his relics.

Every Divine Liturgy, the Orthodox service of the Eucharist, is served over relics. A fragment is sewn into the antimension, the cloth on the altar that also carries the bishop's signature.

The Second Council of Nicaea in 787 ordered that no church be consecrated without relics. The same manual notes that Rome was at first reluctant to divide a saint's bones.

Lutheran

's Smalcald Articles of 1537, a statement of his teaching, list relics among the abuses that grew up around the . They are full of 'falsehoods and tomfooleries concerning the bones of dogs and horses', he wrote.

Even if there were some good in them, he said, they should long ago have been condemned, because God neither commands nor counsels them.

His deepest objection was about how people are saved. Relics had been treated as a way to win , a release from the punishment still due for forgiven , and forgiveness of sins: a good work and service of God, like the Mass.

Reformed

John Calvin's Treatise on Relics of 1543 goes further than exposing fakes. Relics, he argues, cannot be handled and looked at without being honoured. People will soon give them the honour due to Christ.

The desire for relics, he writes, is never without superstition, and is usually the parent of idolatry. He points out that God hid the body of so that Israel would not worship it.

On this reading the danger lies in the practice itself, so even a genuine relic is a risk.

Anglican

The Thirty-Nine Articles are the Church of England's sixteenth-century statement of belief. They group the 'Worshipping and Adoration, as well of Images as of Reliques' with , pardons and the invocation of saints.

Article XXII calls the Roman teaching on them 'a fond thing vainly invented', fond meaning foolish. It says it has no warrant in Scripture.

That is the formal position of 1562 and 1571; it does not settle what every Anglican holds today.

A skeptical historian: Antonio Lombatti

In 2013 the church historian Antonio Lombatti was asked about the bones Francis had displayed. He said he found it very difficult to believe they are authentic.

Christianity was illegal in Peter's time, he argued, and things were hidden and moved in haste. So bones of the right age and type still cannot be tied to one man.

From a factual point of view, he said, there is no way to know whether something that old is real.

The archaeologist Lorenzo Bianchi answered that the bones were buried there by about 120, and that Constantine believed them genuine.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself7
The documents, laid out in order12 steps

The same ground with the papers on the table, including the ones that tell against the relics. Where a step concerns one object, its grade is given: solid, plausible, tradition only, or false.

  1. The state knew where the cemeteries were

    Reign of Valerian and Gallienus

    At Alexandria the Roman governor, Aemilianus, sent Bishop Dionysius into exile. On the emperors' orders he banned Christians from their cemeteries. A later decree of the emperor Gallienus let bishops take the cemeteries back.

    Authorities who can close a cemetery and later return it know where it is. Of Rome, the catacomb scholar Anton de Waal wrote in 1908 that the Romans undoubtedly knew where Christians buried their dead.

    The catacombs were burial grounds, not secret refuges. Grade: solid.

    “Wherefore you shall not remain in this city. But you shall be sent into the regions of Libya, to a place called Cephro. For I have chosen this place at the command of our sovereigns, and it shall by no means be permitted you or any others, either to hold assemblies, or to enter into the so called cemeteries.”
    HistoricalChurch History (Historia Ecclesiastica)Church History 7.11.10, with 7.13 on Gallienus (New Advent 250107.htm)The evidence ↓
  2. Eusebius on Helena, and what he leaves out

    c. AD 339

    Eusebius describes the uncovering of Christ's tomb in detail, and Helena's pilgrimage, her gifts to the poor and her two churches. He never mentions a cross being found.

    The nearest thing is a letter of Constantine he copies out, which calls the find 'the monument of his most holy Passion'. Eusebius presents it as the tomb.

    The Catholic reply is that Cyril, about ten years later, preached about the wood to people who could see it.

    “For without delay she dedicated two churches to the God whom she adored, one at the grotto which had been the scene of the Saviour's birth; the other on the mount of his ascension.”
    HistoricalLife of ConstantineLife of Constantine 3.43, with 3.28 on the tomb (New Advent 25023.htm)The evidence ↓
  3. Deacons guard the wood from the faithful

    c. AD 380

    Egeria, a woman pilgrim, watched the Good Friday service in Jerusalem where people honoured the wood. The bishop held its ends while the people filed past to kiss it, and deacons stood guard.

    Someone, she was told, had once bitten off a piece and carried it away. The scene shows how deep the devotion ran, and why rules about relics would be needed. Grade for the object: plausible, unproved.

    “the bishop, as he sits, holds the extremities of the sacred wood firmly in his hands, while the deacons who stand around guard it. ... And because, I know not when, some one is said to have bitten off and stolen a portion of the sacred wood, it is thus guarded by the deacons who stand around, lest any one approaching should venture to do so again.”
    HistoricalThe Pilgrimage of EtheriaThe Pilgrimage of Etheria, Good Friday, 'Veneration of the Cross' (trans. M. L. McClure and C. L. Feltoe, 1919, pp. 74-75)The evidence ↓
  4. Western crusaders strip Constantinople's churches

    1204

    In 1204, as the Orthodox Church in America's history puts it, the knights of the Fourth Crusade sacked Constantinople and stole countless relics. The Crown of Thorns later reached Paris through the Latin empire they set up.

    In 2001 John Paul II said that the attackers being Latin Christians 'fills Catholics with deep regret'.

    In 2004 he returned relics of two patriarchs of Constantinople to the city. That ended what Patriarch Bartholomew called their 'involuntary age-old separation'. Neither side said how they had reached Rome.

    “They pillaged Hagia Sophia and other churches, desecrating the altars and stealing countless relics and other holy objects.”
    HistoricalThe Orthodox Faith, Volume III: Church History — Thirteenth Century — The Fourth CrusadeThe Orthodox Faith, vol. III, Church History, Thirteenth Century, 'The Fourth Crusade'The evidence ↓
  5. A council bans the trade

    1215

    The complaint was old. At the end of the fourth century Augustine, a North African bishop, had denounced wandering 'monks' hawking 'limbs of martyrs, if indeed of martyrs'.

    The Fourth Lateran Council, a great council of bishops in Rome, made rules for the whole Western Church. No sale of relics, no showing old ones outside a reliquary, the case that holds a relic, and no public honouring of new ones without the pope's approval.

    Its rule, or canon, admits that pilgrims had been deceived 'for the sake of gain'.

    “From the fact that some expose for sale and exhibit promiscuously the relics of saints, great injury is sustained by the Christian religion. That this may not occur hereafter, we ordain in the present decree that in the future old relics may not be exhibited outside of a vessel or exposed for sale. And let no one presume to venerate publicly new ones unless they have been approved by the Roman pontiff.”
    HistoricalCanons of the Fourth Lateran Council (1215)Fourth Lateran Council, canon 62 (trans. H. J. Schroeder, 1937, Internet Medieval Sourcebook)The evidence ↓
  6. England's shrines come down

    1538

    The Reformers wrote against relics, and rulers acted. In 1538 Thomas Cromwell, Henry VIII's chief minister, issued orders that called pilgrimages and offerings to relics things 'tending to idolatry and superstition'.

    That year nearly every shrine in England was taken apart. The remains of Thomas Becket, the murdered archbishop, at Canterbury are believed to have been destroyed, though the record is not clear.

    The Catholic reading is that the abuses were real, and that the destruction was a wrong of its own.

    “The martyr's holy remains are believed to have been destroyed in September, 1538, when nearly all the other shrines in England were dismantled; but the matter is by no means clear”
    HistoricalCatholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'St. Thomas Becket'Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'St. Thomas Becket', by Herbert Thurston, closing paragraphThe evidence ↓
  7. A shipload of wood

    1543

    John Calvin's Treatise on Relics went through Europe's collections town by town. His charge was double.

    First, the collections were full of fakes. In Geneva, he says, an arm of St Anthony proved to be a stag's bone, and Peter's brain a piece of pumice. Second, even a genuine relic, he argued, draws people into idolatry.

    Catholic scholars later conceded much of the first charge. The second is the real disagreement.

    “In short, if we were to collect all these pieces of the true cross exhibited in various parts, they would form a whole ship’s cargo. The Gospel testifies that the cross could be borne by one single individual; how glaring, then, is the audacity now to pretend to display more relics of wood than three hundred men could carry!”
    HistoricalA Treatise on RelicsA Treatise on Relics (1543), section on the Cross (trans. Valerian Krasinski, 1854; 2nd edition 1870, Project Gutenberg 32136)The evidence ↓
  8. A Catholic scholar measures the fragments

    1870

    The French Catholic scholar Rohault de Fleury catalogued every known relic of the True Cross. He wanted to answer the charge that they would fill a ship. His total was above 4 million cubic millimetres.

    He assumed a pine cross of about 75 kilograms. That would be about 178 million, roughly forty times as much.

    That answers the ship. It cannot show that any fragment is genuine, and it counts only the relics known in 1870.

    “Supposing the Cross to have been of pine-wood, as is believed by the savants who have made a special study of the subject, and giving it a weight of about seventy-five kilograms, we find that the volume of this cross was 178,000,000 cubic millimetres. Now the total known volume of the True Cross, according to the finding of M. Rohault de Fleury, amounts to above 4,000,000 cubic millimetres”
    HistoricalCatholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'The True Cross'Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'The True Cross', by Fernand Cabrol, section 'Relics of the True Cross', citing Rohault de Fleury, Mémoire sur les instruments de la Passion (1870)The evidence ↓
  9. The catacomb martyr who was not

    1911

    In 1802 a grave in the Catacomb of Priscilla was opened. Tiles naming Filumena were taken as proof of a virgin martyr. A romantic life was written from a nun's alleged revelations, and a feast followed.

    The archaeologist Orazio Marucchi concluded, and the Catholic Encyclopedia agreed in 1911, that the tiles came from an older grave.

    In 1961 the Vatican's office for worship, the Congregation of Rites, ordered her feast struck from every calendar. It gave no reason; the older archaeology is the likely background. Grade: withdrawn.

    “Consequently, since the disarrangement of the plates can scarcely be explained as arising from an error, Marucchi seems justified in concluding that the inscription and plates originally belonged to an earlier grave, and were later employed (now in the wrong order) to close another.”
    HistoricalCatholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'St. Philomena'Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'St. Philomena', by Johann Peter KirschThe evidence ↓
  10. Two popes on the bones

    1950 and 1968

    In 1950 Pope Pius XII announced that Peter's tomb had been found, with a very clear yes. Human bones found at its edge, he said, could not be proved to be Peter's.

    Margherita Guarducci later traced bones taken from a niche in the wall beside the tomb. In 1968 Paul VI said the relics had been 'identified in a way which we can hold to be convincing'.

    He called it a happy announcement, while granting that research and argument would go on. Grade: plausible, unproved.

    “Nuove indagini pazientissime e accuratissime furono in seguito eseguite con risultato che Noi, confortati dal giudizio di valenti e prudenti persone competenti, crediamo positivo: anche le reliquie di San Pietro sono state identificate in modo che possiamo ritenere convincente ... Non saranno esaurite con ciò le ricerche, le verifiche, le discussioni e le polemiche.”
    HistoricalUdienza generale, 26 giugno 1968Paul VI, general audience of 26 June 1968 (Italian original, vatican.va); Pius XII's 1950 radio message is quoted in the same addressThe evidence ↓
  11. The excavator who never agreed

    1959 to 1995

    Antonio Ferrua, one of the Jesuits who dug the tomb, rejected Guarducci's identification until at least 1995.

    The Latin on Paul VI's reliquary says the bones are 'considered to be' Peter's. In 1995 Ferrua explained it as 'it is an opinion; others believe in it, I do not'.

    By one account, the anatomist Correnti found traces of two men, not one. Guarducci reported his finding as a single man aged 60 to 70. And the bones' path from the niche to a storeroom box rests on one workman's memory.

    “Guarducci reported her discoveries to the press in 1959 in great detail. What she said was immediately curtly denied by the Kaas, Kirschbaum and Ferrua Commission. ... The historical and archaeological litigation continued at least until 1995, with Guarducci insisting on her discovery and Ferrua denying it.”
    HistoricalAll the Mystery Surrounding St Peter's TombBruno Bartoloni, 'All the Mystery Surrounding St Peter's Tomb', L'Osservatore Romano, weekly edition in English, 29 August 2012, p. 6 (reprinted by EWTN)The evidence ↓
  12. Joan of Arc's relics were a mummy

    2007

    A jar of 'relics', labelled as found under the stake where Joan of Arc was burned, turned up in a Paris pharmacy in 1867. The Catholic Church recognised them.

    In 2006 the French Church let the forensic scientist Philippe Charlier test them. The rib and a cat's bone had never been burnt, and their chemistry matched Egyptian mummies.

    Charlier said the Church was ready to accept the result. Grade: false.

    “The relics were discovered in 1867 in a jar in the attic of a Paris pharmacy, with the inscription “Remains found under the stake of Joan of Arc, virgin of Orleans”. They were recognized by the Church, and are now housed in a museum in Chinon that belongs to the Archdiocese of Tours. ... Carbon-14 analysis dated the remains to between the third and sixth centuries BC.”
    HistoricalJoan of Arc's relics exposed as forgeryDeclan Butler, 'Joan of Arc's relics exposed as forgery', Nature 446, 593 (4 April 2007)The evidence ↓
Every claim this chapter leans on11 claims · all checked against the source

Nothing appears on this page without one of these. “Quotes checked” means the quoted words were compared word for word with the linked page. It doesn’t mean the conclusion is right, and outside scholars haven’t reviewed these claims yet.

01HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Christians kept and honoured the bones of their martyrs from the second century. The church at Smyrna gathered Polycarp's bones around AD 155 and planned to meet where they lay on his anniversary. The New Testament already records God healing through cloths that had touched Paul. In Rome, as late as the 590s, the custom was not to divide a saint's body but to send cloths that had lain near the tomb, while in the East bones were already being divided.

Rests on
  • Acts 19:11-12 (New American Bible, vatican.va IntraText edition, __PYD.HTM)
    “So extraordinary were the mighty deeds God accomplished at the hands of Paul that when face cloths or aprons that touched his skin were applied to the sick, their diseases left them and the evil spirits came out of them.”
  • Martyrdom of Polycarp 18 (Roberts and Donaldson, ANF vol. 1)
    “Accordingly, we afterwards took up his bones, as being more precious than the most exquisite jewels, and more purified than gold, and deposited them in a fitting place, whither, being gathered together, as opportunity is allowed us, with joy and rejoicing, the Lord shall grant us to celebrate the anniversary of his martyrdom”
  • Register of Letters IV.30, to Constantina Augusta (NPNF Second Series vol. 12)
    “Moreover, let my most tranquil lady know that it is not the custom of the Romans, when they give relics of saints, to presume to touch any part of the body; but only a cloth (brandeum) is put into a box (pyxide), and placed near the most sacred bodies of the saints”
  • Register of Letters IV.30, opening paragraph
    “has charged me with your commands to send to you the head of Saint Paul, or some other part of his body, for the church which is being built in honour of the same Saint Paul in the palace.”
  • Register of Letters IV.30, on the custom of the Greeks
    “For this reason we greatly wonder at the custom of the Greeks, who say that they take up the bones of saints; and we scarcely believe it.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Relics', by Herbert Thurston, section on the early history
    “while this and other passages suggest that no great repugnance was felt in the East to the division and dismemberment of the bodies of the saints, in the West, on the other hand, particularly at Rome, the greatest respect was shown to the holy dead.”
Other readings
  • The Orthodox reading, in the Orthodox Church in America's adult manual, draws the same line from Acts 19 and 2 Kings 13:20-21 to the veneration of relics, and goes further in saying that encountering a relic means encountering the saint himself.
  • Calvin reads the same history as the start of a slide: relics, he argues, cannot be handled and looked at without being honoured, and the honour soon passes to them from Christ.
Limits
  • Acts 19 describes healing during Paul's lifetime. It does not describe honour paid to a dead Christian's remains, so it shows the principle, not the practice.
  • The Martyrdom of Polycarp is dated to a range, roughly AD 155 to 167, and reached us through later copyists; the chapter on saints sets out its transmission.
  • Gregory's letter mixes an account of Roman custom with stories of divine punishment for disturbing tombs. It is good evidence of what Rome believed and practised, not of those events.
  • The date 590s rests on Gregory's pontificate, 590 to 604, as given by Jungmann; the letter itself is dated only 'June, Indiction 12'.
  • Gregory did not send Constantina a cloth: he explains the Roman custom of cloths (brandea) and offers her instead filings from the chains of Peter.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

02HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Three early inscriptions bear on Christian belief. The epitaph of Abercius, bishop of Hieropolis, written before AD 216, speaks of a journey to Rome, a people bearing a shining mark, and a Fish given as food with wine and bread; two fragments found in 1883 are in the Vatican Museums. The Pectorius inscription, found at Autun in 1839 and perhaps from the early third century, speaks of the honey-sweet food of the Redeemer of the saints. The Alexamenos graffito on the Palatine mocks a Christian for worshipping a crucified figure with an ass's head.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'Inscription of Abercius', by Henri Leclercq, restored text
    “And to Rome he sent me to contemplate majesty, and to see a queen golden-robed and golden-sandalled; there also I saw a people bearing a shining mark. ... Faith everywhere led me forward, and everywhere provided as my food a fish of exceeding great …”
    Read the full passage
    “And to Rome he sent me to contemplate majesty, and to see a queen golden-robed and golden-sandalled; there also I saw a people bearing a shining mark. ... Faith everywhere led me forward, and everywhere provided as my food a fish of exceeding great size, and perfect, which a holy virgin drew with her hands from a fountain and this it [faith] ever gives to its friends to eat, it having wine of great virtue, and giving it mingled with bread.”
  • Same article, on the date
    “The epitaph of Abercius is generally, and with good reason, regarded as older than that of Alexander, the son of Anthony, i.e. prior to the year of Our Lord 216.”
  • Same article, on the discovery
    “Mr. Ramsay, on a second visit to the site of Hieropolis, in 1883, discovered two new fragments covered with inscriptions, built into the masonry of the public baths. These fragments, which are now in the Vatican Christian Museum, filled out the middle part of the stele inscribed with the epitaph of Abercius.”
  • Same article, on the pagan readings
    “In 1894 G. Ficker, supported by O. Hirschfeld, strove to prove that Abercius was a priest of Cybele. In 1895 A. Harnack offered an explanation which was sufficiently obscure, making Abercius the representative of an ill-defined religious syncretism …”
    Read the full passage
    “In 1894 G. Ficker, supported by O. Hirschfeld, strove to prove that Abercius was a priest of Cybele. In 1895 A. Harnack offered an explanation which was sufficiently obscure, making Abercius the representative of an ill-defined religious syncretism arbitrarily combined in such a fashion as to explain all portions of the inscription which were otherwise inexplicable. In 1896, Dieterich made Abercius a priest of Attis.”
  • Orazio Marucchi, Christian Epigraphy (trans. J. Armine Willis, Cambridge 1912), p. 125
    “The inscription of Pectorius was found at Autun in 1839, and was published and annotated by Pitra. It is a very valuable record, going back perhaps to the beginning of the third century”
  • Same, p. 125, translation of the inscription
    “Comfort thy soul, oh friend, with the ever-flowing waters of wealth-giving wisdom ; and receive the honey-sweet food of the Redeemer of the Saints”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), 'The Ass (in Caricature of Christian Beliefs and Practices)', by Maurice Hassett
    “The caricature of the Crucifixion, discovered on a wall in the Palace of the Cæsars on the Palatine in 1857, which represents a Christian boy worshipping a crucified figure with an ass's head, is a pictured form of this calumny. A Greek inscription, …”
    Read the full passage
    “The caricature of the Crucifixion, discovered on a wall in the Palace of the Cæsars on the Palatine in 1857, which represents a Christian boy worshipping a crucified figure with an ass's head, is a pictured form of this calumny. A Greek inscription, "Alexamenos worshipping his God", is scratched on the caricature. This person is generally held to have been a Christian page of the palace, in the time of the first Antonines, whose companions took this means of insulting his religion.”
Other readings
  • Between 1894 and 1896 G. Ficker, A. Harnack and A. Dieterich read Abercius as a pagan priest of Cybele or Attis, or as a syncretist. The Catholic Encyclopedia reports these readings as refuted by De Rossi, Duchesne and Cumont; the veiled language of the poem is what made them possible.
  • Wünsch suggested the Alexamenos caricature was aimed at a Gnostic sect that identified Christ with the ass-headed Typhon-Seth. Hassett, in the Catholic Encyclopedia, found his reasons not convincing.
Limits
  • The Abercius text is restored: the stone survives in fragments, and gaps are filled from the text preserved in a later Life of Abercius and from the copy on the gravestone of Alexander, son of Anthony, dated 216.
  • The Alexamenos graffito is dated by Hassett only to 'the time of the first Antonines'. It is evidence of what pagans thought Christians did, not of Christian practice as Christians described it.
  • The Pectorius translation is from a 1912 English version of Marucchi, and the inscription's date is his cautious 'perhaps' the beginning of the third century.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

03HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Around AD 200 the Roman Christian Gaius pointed to the 'trophies' of Peter on the Vatican and of Paul on the road to Ostia, which Eusebius took to mean the places where their bodies lay. Excavations under St Peter's, begun under Pius XII in 1939, found a burial ground and, beneath the high altar, a niche against a wall dated to about 150. In 1950 Pius XII announced that the tomb had been found. In 2009 Benedict XVI reported that bone fragments in Paul's unopened sarcophagus came from someone who lived in the first or second century.

Rests on
  • Church History 2.25.6-7 (New Advent 250102.htm)
    “It is confirmed likewise by Caius, a member of the Church, who arose under Zephyrinus, bishop of Rome. He, in a published disputation with Proclus, the leader of the Phrygian heresy, speaks as follows concerning the places where the sacred corpses of the aforesaid apostles are laid”
  • Church History 2.25.7
    “But I can show the trophies of the apostles. For if you will go to the Vatican or to the Ostian way, you will find the trophies of those who laid the foundations of this church.”
  • Letter of Pope Francis to Bartholomew I (30 August 2019), paragraph 2
    “Later, the Emperor Constantine erected the Vatican Basilica dedicated to Saint Peter over the site of the tomb of the Apostle.”
  • Same letter, paragraph 3
    “In June 1939, immediately following his election, my predecessor Pope Pius XII decided to undertake excavations beneath the Vatican Basilica. The works led first to the discovery of the exact burial place of the Apostle and later, in 1952, to the …”
    Read the full passage
    “In June 1939, immediately following his election, my predecessor Pope Pius XII decided to undertake excavations beneath the Vatican Basilica. The works led first to the discovery of the exact burial place of the Apostle and later, in 1952, to the discovery, under the high altar of the Basilica, of a funerary niche attached to a red wall dated to the year 150 and covered with precious graffiti”
  • Pius XII, radio message for Christmas of the Holy Year, 23 December 1950, section 'Ritrovamento della tomba del Principe degli Apostoli' (Italian original)
    “Ma la questione essenziale è la seguente: È stata veramente ritrovata la tomba di San Pietro? A tale domanda la conclusione finale dei lavori e degli studi risponde con un chiarissimo Sì. La tomba del Principe degli Apostoli è stata ritrovata. Una …”
    Read the full passage
    “Ma la questione essenziale è la seguente: È stata veramente ritrovata la tomba di San Pietro? A tale domanda la conclusione finale dei lavori e degli studi risponde con un chiarissimo Sì. La tomba del Principe degli Apostoli è stata ritrovata. Una seconda questione, subordinata alla prima, riguarda le reliquie del Santo. Sono state esse rinvenute? Al margine del sepolcro furono trovati resti di ossa umane, dei quali però non è possibile di provare con certezza che appartenessero alla spoglia mortale dell’Apostolo.”
  • Benedict XVI, homily at First Vespers closing the Pauline Year, 28 June 2009
    “In addition, minute fragments of bone were sent for carbon-14 testing by experts unaware of their provenance. The fragments proved to belong to someone who had lived between the first and second centuries. This would seem to confirm the unanimous and undisputed tradition which claims that these are the mortal remains of the Apostle Paul.”
  • L'Osservatore Romano (English), 28 June 2024, 'A striking discovery', quoting Vincenzo Fiocchi Nicolai of the Pontifical Institute of Christian Archaeology
    “This aedicula already existed at the time and, based on archaeology, we can date it to around 160’s ad. This was definitely the aedicula that marked the tomb”
  • Same article
    “This tomb is located within a burial context and therefore with other tombs that date back to the period between the last decades of the first century a.d. and the beginning of the second century, which, on the basis of this aspect and others like the graffiti, confirms that it is the tomb of the Apostle”
Other readings
  • The Greek word behind 'trophies' means monuments of victory, so on its own it could name memorials rather than graves. Eusebius introduces the passage as being about the places where the apostles' bodies were laid, and Paul VI in 1968 said there was no doubt the word meant the tombs.
Limits
  • Gaius survives only as quoted by Eusebius, writing over a century later.
  • The identification of the grave rests on continuous veneration and the second-century monument, not on any inscription naming Peter as buried there; the graffito read as 'Peter is here' is discussed under the bones.
  • Francis's letter dates the niche and red wall to 1952 and 150, and Vatican News (2019) the wall to about 150; the archaeologist Vincenzo Fiocchi Nicolai, in L'Osservatore Romano (2024), dates the shrine itself to around the 160s 'based on archaeology'. None of the saved pages says how the date was reached. L'Osservatore Romano's 2012 account puts Guarducci's involvement three years after 1950.
  • Benedict XVI's wording is careful: the carbon dating 'would seem to confirm' the tradition. A first- or second-century date fits Paul; it does not identify him.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

04HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Rome's Christian catacombs began as church cemeteries around AD 200, under Bishop Zephyrinus, with the deacon Callixtus in charge of the cemetery on the Appian Way. Their art shows biblical scenes of rescue and resurrection, the Good Shepherd, and the fish as a sign of Christ. They were not secret refuges: under Valerian and Gallienus the authorities banned Christians from entering the cemeteries, and Gallienus later let bishops take them back. Since 1852 the Holy See's Commission for Sacred Archaeology has directed their excavation and care.

Rests on
  • Pontifical Commission for Sacred Archaeology, 'Christian Catacombs', 'Origin of the catacombs'
    “The catacombs originated in Rome between the end of the second and the beginning of the third centuries A.D., under the papacy of Pope Zephyrin (199-217), who entrusted to the deacon Callixtus, who would later become pope (217-222), the task of …”
    Read the full passage
    “The catacombs originated in Rome between the end of the second and the beginning of the third centuries A.D., under the papacy of Pope Zephyrin (199-217), who entrusted to the deacon Callixtus, who would later become pope (217-222), the task of supervising the cemetery of the Appian Way, where the most important pontiffs of the third century would be buried.”
  • Same page, 'Origin of the catacombs'
    “The ancient term to designate these monuments is coemeterium, which derives from the Greek and means “dormitory”, thereby stressing the fact that for Christians, burial is just a temporary moment while they wait for the final resurrection.”
  • Same page, 'Characteristics of the catacombs'
    “The loculi represent the humblest and most egalitarian burial system in order to respect the community sense that animated the early Christians.”
  • Same page, 'The art of the catacombs'
    “To indicate Christ a fish is depicted; to signify the peace of heaven a dove is represented; to express firmness of faith an anchor is drawn.”
  • Church History 7.11.10 (New Advent 250107.htm)
    “Wherefore you shall not remain in this city. But you shall be sent into the regions of Libya, to a place called Cephro. For I have chosen this place at the command of our sovereigns, and it shall by no means be permitted you or any others, either to hold assemblies, or to enter into the so called cemeteries.”
  • Church History 7.13 (New Advent 250107.htm)
    “Another decree of his is extant addressed to other bishops, permitting them to take possession again of the so-called cemeteries.”
  • Pontifical Commission for Sacred Archaeology, 'The Commission'
    “The Commission was created by Pius IX (January 6, 1852) “to take care of the ancient sacred cemeteries, look after their preventive preservation, further explorations, research and study, and also safeguard the oldest mementos of the early Christian centuries”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Roman Catacombs', by Anton de Waal, on construction
    “in other spots the catacombs are connected by a gallery with the arenariae so that entrance could be gained into the Christian city of the dead, in times of persecution, without exciting notice.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Roman Catacombs', by Anton de Waal, on whether Christians built them unmolested
    “Undoubtedly the Romans had knowledge of the spots where the Christians buried their dead; but according to old laws every spot where a body lay was under the protection of Roman law and custom that guaranteed the inviolability of burial places.”
Other readings
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia article on the Roman catacombs (1908) notes that some catacombs were linked to sand-pits so that Christians could enter them unnoticed in times of persecution. That is a claim about discreet access, not about living in hiding, and it sits alongside the state's plain knowledge of where the cemeteries were.
Limits
  • The ban recorded by Eusebius was issued at Alexandria, on imperial orders; it shows that the state knew where Christian cemeteries were in general. For Rome itself the evidence is de Waal's statement in the Catholic Encyclopedia (1908) that the Romans undoubtedly knew where Christians buried their dead.
  • The Commission's page is the Holy See's own summary for visitors, not a scholarly publication; the dates it gives for Zephyrinus and Callixtus agree with Paul VI's 1968 address.
  • The Catholic Encyclopedia says several Roman catacombs grew out of private family vaults (Domitilla, Priscilla, Lucina); the Commission's page dates the catacombs as church cemeteries from Zephyrinus. Both can be true: family burial grounds became community cemeteries.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

05HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

A relic venerated as the wood of Christ's Cross was kept at Jerusalem by about AD 350, when Cyril said pieces had spread across the world, and an inscription of 359 from North Africa lists a fragment. Egeria saw it venerated on Good Friday around 380, under guard. The story that Helena found it appears in Ambrose's sermon of 25 February 395, while Eusebius, describing Helena's journey around 339, mentions no cross. Whether any surviving fragment comes from Christ's Cross cannot be established.

Rests on
  • Catechetical Lecture 10.19 (trans. Gifford, NPNF Second Series vol. 7)
    “The holy wood of the Cross bears witness, seen among us to this day, and from this place now almost filling the whole world, by means of those who in faith take portions from it.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'The True Cross', by Fernand Cabrol, on the excavations
    “Under Constantine, after peace had been vouchsafed to the Church, Macarius, Bishop of Jerusalem, caused excavations to be made (about A.D. 327, it is believed) in order to ascertain the location of these holy sites.”
  • Same article, on the Tixter inscription
    “An inscription of A.D. 359, found at Tixter, in the neighbourhood of Sétif in Mauretania, mentions in an enumeration of relics, a fragment of the True Cross”
  • The Pilgrimage of Etheria (trans. McClure and Feltoe, 1919), pp. 74-75
    “the bishop, as he sits, holds the extremities of the sacred wood firmly in his hands, while the deacons who stand around guard it. ... And because, I know not when, some one is said to have bitten off and stolen a portion of the sacred wood, it is …”
    Read the full passage
    “the bishop, as he sits, holds the extremities of the sacred wood firmly in his hands, while the deacons who stand around guard it. ... And because, I know not when, some one is said to have bitten off and stolen a portion of the sacred wood, it is thus guarded by the deacons who stand around, lest any one approaching should venture to do so again.”
  • Same edition, translators' footnote on Ambrose and Rufinus, p. 75
    “According to S. Ambrose (395) Pilate's original superscription (titulus) was found by Helena still attached to the Saviour's cross, which enabled her to distinguish it from the two others ; but other authorities, including Rufinus, state that it was …”
    Read the full passage
    “According to S. Ambrose (395) Pilate's original superscription (titulus) was found by Helena still attached to the Saviour's cross, which enabled her to distinguish it from the two others ; but other authorities, including Rufinus, state that it was found in a separate place from the cross, and that the recognition of the true cross was due to a miracle.”
  • De obitu Theodosii 43 and 46 (trans. Mannix, 1925)
    “Helen, then, came and commenced to look about the sacred places. The Spirit inspired her to search for the wood of the Cross ... She discovered, then, the title; she adored the King; not the wood indeed, because this is an error of the Gentiles and …”
    Read the full passage
    “Helen, then, came and commenced to look about the sacred places. The Spirit inspired her to search for the wood of the Cross ... She discovered, then, the title; she adored the King; not the wood indeed, because this is an error of the Gentiles and a vanity of the wicked; but she adored Him who hung on the wood, who was inscribed in the title”
  • Mannix, Introduction, on the occasion
    “The De Obitu Theodosii Oratio was delivered by St. Ambrose, Bishop of Milan, on February 25, 395 the fortieth day after the death of the emperor”
  • Life of Constantine 3.43 (New Advent 25023.htm)
    “For without delay she dedicated two churches to the God whom she adored, one at the grotto which had been the scene of the Saviour's birth; the other on the mount of his ascension.”
  • Life of Constantine 3.28
    “But as soon as the original surface of the ground, beneath the covering of earth, appeared, immediately, and contrary to all expectation, the venerable and hollowed monument of our Saviour's resurrection was discovered.”
  • A Treatise on Relics (1543), on the Cross (trans. Krasinski, 1854)
    “In short, if we were to collect all these pieces of the true cross exhibited in various parts, they would form a whole ship’s cargo. The Gospel testifies that the cross could be borne by one single individual; how glaring, then, is the audacity now to pretend to display more relics of wood than three hundred men could carry!”
  • Same article, section 'Relics of the True Cross', on Rohault de Fleury (1870)
    “Supposing the Cross to have been of pine-wood, as is believed by the savants who have made a special study of the subject, and giving it a weight of about seventy-five kilograms, we find that the volume of this cross was 178,000,000 cubic …”
    Read the full passage
    “Supposing the Cross to have been of pine-wood, as is believed by the savants who have made a special study of the subject, and giving it a weight of about seventy-five kilograms, we find that the volume of this cross was 178,000,000 cubic millimetres. Now the total known volume of the True Cross, according to the finding of M. Rohault de Fleury, amounts to above 4,000,000 cubic millimetres”
Other readings
  • Catholic reading: the veneration at Jerusalem is well attested within a generation of Constantine's excavation, in the city itself, before people who could see the wood; the Helena story is a later explanation of a relic already there.
  • Skeptical reading: Eusebius's silence about any cross, in a work praising Helena's piety at these very sites, makes the finding a legend, and the relic's identity was never testable.
  • Calvin's reading: the number of fragments shows fraud, and venerating the wood is idolatry that Ambrose himself condemned. Calvin concedes Ambrose's line that Helena did not worship the wood.
Limits
  • Cyril's lectures are dated around 350; the Catholic Encyclopedia puts them from 347. Egeria's visit is placed about 380 by the same article and 'towards the end of the fourth century' by her translators.
  • Constantine's letter quoted by Eusebius (3.30) calls the find 'the monument of his most holy Passion'; Eusebius presents it as the tomb, and it cannot be read with certainty as a reference to the Cross.
  • Rohault de Fleury's count covers only relics known in 1870, assumes a pine cross of about 75 kilograms, and was made to answer Protestant critics. It shows the fragments are not a shipload; it cannot show that any of them is genuine.
  • Cabrol's Catholic Encyclopedia article says a chapel for the relic 'is mentioned by Eusebius'; no such mention appears in the saved Life of Constantine, book 3, which describes Helena's journey and the tomb without any cross being found.
  • No saved source says Ambrose's account is the earliest of Helena finding the Cross, so the chapter says only that he tells it in 395.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

06HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

The Crown of Thorns at Notre-Dame can be traced in documents from 1238, when the Latin emperor Baldwin II offered it to Louis IX, who redeemed it from Venetian lenders, carried it into Paris on 19 August 1239 and built the Sainte-Chapelle for it. Before that its record is thin: few writers of the first six centuries speak of it as a relic; pilgrims report a crown on show at Jerusalem from the sixth century, and its link to the Passion rests on tradition. It is a circlet of rushes without thorns. It was saved from the Notre-Dame fire of 15 April 2019 and returned to the cathedral on 13 December 2024.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crown of Thorns', by Herbert Thurston, third paragraph
    “In 1238 Baldwin II, the Latin Emperor of Constantinople, anxious to obtain support for his tottering empire, offered the Crown of Thorns to St. Louis, King of France. It was then actually in the hands of the Venetians as security for a heavy loan, …”
    Read the full passage
    “In 1238 Baldwin II, the Latin Emperor of Constantinople, anxious to obtain support for his tottering empire, offered the Crown of Thorns to St. Louis, King of France. It was then actually in the hands of the Venetians as security for a heavy loan, but it was redeemed and conveyed to Paris where St. Louis built the Sainte-Chapelle (completed 1248) for its reception.”
  • Same article, third paragraph
    “The Crown thus preserved consists only of a circlet of rushes, without any trace of thorns.”
  • Same article, first paragraph
    “there are comparatively few writers of the first six centuries who speak of it as a relic known to be still in existence and venerated by the faithful.”
  • Same article, first paragraph
    “St. Paulinus of Nola, writing after 409, refers to "the thorns with which Our Saviour was crowned" as relics held in honour along with the Cross to which He was nailed and the pillar at which He was scourged”
  • Emily Guerry, The Conversation, 6 December 2024
    “On August 19 1239, King Louis IX (the future Saint Louis) carried the crown relic into Paris in an extraordinary parade.”
  • Same article
    “Having removed his crown, the king wore only a simple linen tunic. He walked barefoot for miles while carrying the relic in a double-bier”
  • Catholic News Service, 24 April 2019
    “A hero emerging from the Notre Dame Cathedral fire April 15 is Father Jean-Marc Fournier, chaplain of the Paris Fire Brigade, who is credited with saving a reliquary containing the crown of thorns and the Blessed Sacrament from the burning cathedral.”
  • OSV News, 17 December 2024
    “On Dec. 13, the Crown of Thorns was returned to Notre Dame, marking a deeply moving moment for Parisians and pilgrims alike. The relic, which survived the devastating 2019 fire, had been stored at the Louvre since the blaze.”
  • Vatican News, 25 September 2026
    “Before the Vespers, Pope Leo venerated a relic of the crown of thorns, which was placed on Christ’s head during his Passion.”
  • Same article, first paragraph
    “it is certain that what purported to be the Crown of Thorns was venerated at Jerusalem for several hundred years.”
Other readings
  • Devotional reading: the Crown has been venerated as Christ's for many centuries and is honoured as such by popes, most recently Leo XIV on 25 September 2026.
  • Critical reading: nothing ties the circlet to the Passion before the fifth or sixth century, so its authenticity is a matter of tradition.
Limits
  • Accounts differ on when the Crown entered Notre-Dame after the Revolution: the Catholic Encyclopedia and OSV News give 1806, Emily Guerry 1803.
  • Guerry's article was published a week before the December 2024 return and describes it as planned; OSV News reports that it took place on 13 December.
  • Before 1238 the record is thin rather than empty: Thurston reports a crown shown at Jerusalem from the sixth century to at least 870, and de Mély concluded that the whole crown reached Constantinople about 1063. Nothing ties it to the Passion before the fifth or sixth century, and the documented history after 1238 does not bear on whether it was worn by Christ.
  • Accounts differ on where the Crown was kept between 2019 and 2024: OSV News says the Louvre; Emily Guerry says the Hôtel de Ville and then Saint-Germain-l'Auxerrois, while its empty reliquaries were shown at the Louvre.
  • The Vatican News report of Leo XIV's visit is dated 25 September 2026 and describes the veneration as happening that day; it says 'a relic of the crown of thorns' without saying whether it was the circlet itself.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

07InferenceEstablished Catholic teaching Quotes checked

The Catholic Church teaches that the bodies of the saints, once living members of Christ and temples of the Holy Spirit and destined to rise, are to be venerated, and that this honour is not the worship owed to God. The Council of Trent defined this on 3 December 1563 while ordering superstition and profit removed. Current law forbids any sale of relics, requires a certificate of authenticity before relics are shown, and directs bishops to withdraw doubtful ones. Veneration of relics belongs to popular piety, which extends the liturgy but does not replace it.

Rests on
  • Session XXV (begun 3 December 1563), decree on the invocation, veneration and relics of saints (Waterworth 1848, pp. 234-236)
    “the holy bodies of holy martyrs, and of others now living with Christ,-which bodies were the living members of Christ, and the temple of the Holy Ghost, and which are by Him to be raised unto eternal life, and to be glorified,--are to be venerated …”
    Read the full passage
    “the holy bodies of holy martyrs, and of others now living with Christ,-which bodies were the living members of Christ, and the temple of the Holy Ghost, and which are by Him to be raised unto eternal life, and to be glorified,--are to be venerated by the faithful ... Moreover, in the invocation of saints, the veneration of relics, and the sacred use of images, every superstition shall be removed, all filthy lucre be abolished”
  • Session XXV, same decree, on new relics
    “that no new miracles are to be acknowledged, or new relics recognised, unless the said bishop has taken cognizance and approved thereof”
  • CCC 1674
    “the religious sense of the Christian people has always found expression in various forms of piety surrounding the Church's sacramental life, such as the veneration of relics, visits to sanctuaries, pilgrimages, processions, the stations of the cross, religious dances, the rosary, medals, etc.”
  • CCC 1675
    “These expressions of piety extend the liturgical life of the Church, but do not replace it.”
  • Code of Canon Law (1983), canon 1190 §1
    “It is absolutely forbidden to sell sacred relics.”
  • Congregation for the Causes of Saints, Relics in the Church: Authenticity and Preservation (8 December 2017), Introduction
    “Relics in the Church have always received particular veneration and attention because the body of the Blesseds and of the Saints, destined for the resurrection, has been on earth the living temple of the Holy Spirit and the instrument of their holiness”
  • Same instruction, Introduction
    “The relics of the Blesseds and of the Saints may not be displayed for the veneration of the faithful without a proper certificate of the ecclesiastical authority who guarantees their authenticity.”
  • Same instruction, Part II, Title II, chapter III
    “The commerce (that is, the exchange of a relic for something else or for money) and the sale of relics (that is, the cessation of ownership of a relic for a corresponding price), as well as their display in profane or unauthorized places, are absolutely prohibited.”
  • Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy (2001), 237
    “ensuring the authenticity of the relics exposed for the veneration of the faithful; where doubtful relics have been exposed for the veneration of the faithful, they should be discreetly withdrawn with due pastoral prudence”
  • Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy (2001), 237
    “preventing undue dispersal of relics into small pieces, since such practice is not consonant with due respect for the human body”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'The True Cross', by Fernand Cabrol, citing Petavius
    “this cult must be considered as not belonging to the substance of religion, but as being one of the adiaphora, or things not absolutely necessary to salvation.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Relics', by Herbert Thurston, on what the Church has defined
    “Neither has the Church ever pronounced that any particular relic, not even that commonly venerated as the wood of the Cross, as authentic; but she approves of honour being paid to those relics which with reasonable probability are believed to be genuine and which are invested with due ecclesiastical sanctions.”
Other readings
  • Lutheran: the Smalcald Articles of 1537 say relics are neither commanded nor counselled by God and have been treated as a way to earn indulgence and forgiveness.
  • Reformed: Calvin's Treatise on Relics of 1543 holds that the desire for relics is never without superstition and is usually the parent of idolatry.
  • Anglican: Article XXII of the Thirty-Nine Articles calls the Roman teaching on the worshipping and adoration of relics a fond thing vainly invented.
  • Eastern Orthodox: the veneration is shared in full, and relics are placed in every antimension.
Limits
  • Trent condemns those who deny that relics should be honoured. It does not declare any particular relic genuine, and no Catholic document requires belief that one is.
  • The phrase 'no Catholic is obliged' rests on Herbert Thurston's 1911 statements that the Church has never pronounced any particular relic authentic and that no one is constrained to pay homage to a relic, and on Petavius as reported by Cabrol, who counted such cults among things not absolutely necessary to salvation. These are theologians, not magisterial texts; Trent, the Code and the 2017 instruction require no belief in any particular relic.
  • Waterworth's 1848 English is archaic; 'filthy lucre' renders the Latin for shameful profit.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

08HistoricalDisputed Quotes checked

Bones said to come from a niche beside Peter's monument were identified by the epigrapher Margherita Guarducci as Peter's. Pius XII had said in 1950 that it could not be proved with certainty that bones found at the edge of the tomb were Peter's. In 1968 Paul VI said the relics had been identified in a way he could hold convincing, and in 2019 Francis wrote that they can quite reasonably be considered Peter's; no pope has declared them authentic. Antonio Ferrua, one of the excavators, disputed the identification until 1995, and the anatomist Dino Correnti found traces of two individuals.

Rests on
  • Paul VI, general audience, 26 June 1968 (Italian original)
    “Nuove indagini pazientissime e accuratissime furono in seguito eseguite con risultato che Noi, confortati dal giudizio di valenti e prudenti persone competenti, crediamo positivo: anche le reliquie di San Pietro sono state identificate in modo che …”
    Read the full passage
    “Nuove indagini pazientissime e accuratissime furono in seguito eseguite con risultato che Noi, confortati dal giudizio di valenti e prudenti persone competenti, crediamo positivo: anche le reliquie di San Pietro sono state identificate in modo che possiamo ritenere convincente ... Non saranno esaurite con ciò le ricerche, le verifiche, le discussioni e le polemiche.”
  • Pius XII, radio message, 23 December 1950 (Italian original)
    “Ma la questione essenziale è la seguente: È stata veramente ritrovata la tomba di San Pietro? A tale domanda la conclusione finale dei lavori e degli studi risponde con un chiarissimo Sì. La tomba del Principe degli Apostoli è stata ritrovata. Una …”
    Read the full passage
    “Ma la questione essenziale è la seguente: È stata veramente ritrovata la tomba di San Pietro? A tale domanda la conclusione finale dei lavori e degli studi risponde con un chiarissimo Sì. La tomba del Principe degli Apostoli è stata ritrovata. Una seconda questione, subordinata alla prima, riguarda le reliquie del Santo. Sono state esse rinvenute? Al margine del sepolcro furono trovati resti di ossa umane, dei quali però non è possibile di provare con certezza che appartenessero alla spoglia mortale dell’Apostolo.”
  • Catholic News Service report in America, 3 July 2019
    “While no pope has ever declared the bones to be authentic, St. Paul VI announced in 1968 that the “relics” of St. Peter had been “identified in a way which we can hold to be convincing.””
  • Same report
    “The only time the bronze reliquary has been displayed publicly was in November 2013, when Pope Francis had it present for public veneration as he celebrated the closing Mass for the Year of Faith, opened by Pope Benedict XVI.”
  • Bruno Bartoloni, L'Osservatore Romano weekly edition in English, 29 August 2012, p. 6 (EWTN reprint)
    “Guarducci reported her discoveries to the press in 1959 in great detail. What she said was immediately curtly denied by the Kaas, Kirschbaum and Ferrua Commission. ... The historical and archaeological litigation continued at least until 1995, with Guarducci insisting on her discovery and Ferrua denying it.”
  • Same article, on Ferrua's 1995 article in La Civiltà Cattolica
    “this means: "it is an opinion; others believe in it, I do not"”
  • Same article, on Correnti
    “He maintained that they were the remains of two men because he found traces of a double set of limbs.”
  • Same article, on the workman Segoni
    “After much insistence, Giovanni Segoni remembered that Mons. Kaas had given him the remains in the casket and that he had put them in a shoe box left in a broom cupboard in a corner of the Fabric of St Peter.”
  • Same article, on the graffito
    “And among the graffiti she succeeded in deciphering on the Red Wall was one which said in Greek Petros eni, "Peter is here".”
  • Vatican News (Italian), 'Quei nove frammenti ossei che Papa Montini volle accanto a sé', June 2019
    “Va detto che un altro studioso, il gesuita padre Antonio Ferrua, che aveva scavato la tomba, non concorderà con le conclusioni della Guarducci.”
  • Letter of Pope Francis to Bartholomew I (30 August 2019), paragraphs 3 and 5
    “This contained bones that can quite reasonably be considered those of the Apostle Peter. ... I sensed that it would be highly significant were some fragments of the relics of the Apostle Peter to be placed beside the relics of the Apostle Andrew, who is venerated as the heavenly patron of the Church of Constantinople.”
  • Same letter, paragraph 4
    “The nine fragments were placed in a bronze case bearing the inscription, Ex ossibus quae in Archibasilicae Vaticanae hypogeo inventa Beati Petri apostoli esse putantur: “Bones found in the earth beneath the Vatican Basilica considered to be those of Blessed Peter the Apostle”.”
  • Eric J. Lyman, Religion News Service, 5 December 2013 (Wayback copy)
    ““It’s very difficult for me to believe the bones are authentic,” said Antonio Lombatti, a church historian. “It’s one thing to say the bones are 2,000 years old and that they have the characteristics we believe to be those of St. Peter. But recall …”
    Read the full passage
    ““It’s very difficult for me to believe the bones are authentic,” said Antonio Lombatti, a church historian. “It’s one thing to say the bones are 2,000 years old and that they have the characteristics we believe to be those of St. Peter. But recall that in the time of St. Peter, Christianity was illegal. Things were hidden and moved around hastily.”
  • Same article
    “There are many ways to verify and I suppose there is no way to be 100 percent sure, but from circumstances and records we can say some specific things about these bones: that they were buried there some time (before the period) between 114 and 120 …”
    Read the full passage
    “There are many ways to verify and I suppose there is no way to be 100 percent sure, but from circumstances and records we can say some specific things about these bones: that they were buried there some time (before the period) between 114 and 120 A.D., that Constantine believed them to be authentic, that other records seem to support that.”
  • L'Osservatore Romano (English), 28 June 2024, translating Paul VI's audience of 26 June 1968
    “and he made a “happy announcement”: “We have to be all the more solicitous, all the more exultant, seeing that now we have every reason to believe that there have been discovered the mortal remains, few it is true, but sacrosanct, of the Prince of the Apostles”
  • Same article, on the niche beside the aedicula
    “A niche was discovered in the wall next to the aedicula that was identified as the famous Trophy of Gaius. It held a marble casket without a lid, hence was deemed of little importance.”
Other readings
  • Guarducci, as quoted by Vatican News in 2019, held that the identification was certain. Lorenzo Bianchi, an archaeologist quoted by Religion News Service in 2013, thought the bones were buried there by about 120 and that 'we can be as certain as we can reasonably expect to be'.
  • Antonio Ferrua, one of the excavators, rejected the identification; Dino Correnti found traces of two men; Antonio Lombatti judged that nothing that old can be shown to be real.
Limits
  • Paul VI's and Pius XII's words are quoted in the Italian original. The English phrase 'identified in a way which we can hold to be convincing' is the Catholic News Service translation; the English summary of Pius XII's words is a plain paraphrase of the Italian, not a published translation.
  • The chain of custody rests on the memory of one workman as reported by Guarducci, and on an account written by a journalist whose father covered the excavations.
  • L'Osservatore Romano's article gives the first analysis as at least one male of 60 to 70 of robust build; Correnti's contrary finding is reported, not published here in his own words.
  • The bones Pius XII spoke of in 1950 were found at the edge of the grave; those Guarducci identified came, by Bartoloni's account, from a casket in a niche in the wall beside the shrine. They are not the same find.
  • Paul VI went further than 'convincing': he called it a 'happy announcement' and said there was reason to hold that Peter's few but sacred remains had been found. 'No pope has declared them authentic' is Catholic News Service's summary, meaning no formal declaration.
  • Vatican News (2019) reports the analysis as showing the bones of one robust man who died old; Correnti's finding of two men is known only as Bartoloni reports it.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

09HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Relics were bought, sold, faked and stolen, and the Catholic Church legislated against it repeatedly. Augustine denounced fake monks hawking martyrs' limbs at the end of the fourth century; the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215 banned the sale of relics and the public veneration of new ones without papal approval; Trent in 1563 ordered superstition and profit removed. Western crusaders stole relics from Constantinople in 1204. At the Reformation Luther and Calvin attacked relics, and in England nearly all shrines were dismantled in 1538.

Rests on
  • Of the Work of Monks 36 (NPNF First Series vol. 3)
    “Some hawking about limbs of martyrs, if indeed of martyrs”
  • Fourth Lateran Council, canon 62 (trans. Schroeder)
    “From the fact that some expose for sale and exhibit promiscuously the relics of saints, great injury is sustained by the Christian religion. That this may not occur hereafter, we ordain in the present decree that in the future old relics may not be …”
    Read the full passage
    “From the fact that some expose for sale and exhibit promiscuously the relics of saints, great injury is sustained by the Christian religion. That this may not occur hereafter, we ordain in the present decree that in the future old relics may not be exhibited outside of a vessel or exposed for sale. And let no one presume to venerate publicly new ones unless they have been approved by the Roman pontiff.”
  • Same canon
    “by worthless fabrications or false documents as has been done in many places for the sake of gain.”
  • Session XXV, decree on relics
    “the holy bodies of holy martyrs, and of others now living with Christ,-which bodies were the living members of Christ, and the temple of the Holy Ghost, and which are by Him to be raised unto eternal life, and to be glorified,--are to be venerated …”
    Read the full passage
    “the holy bodies of holy martyrs, and of others now living with Christ,-which bodies were the living members of Christ, and the temple of the Holy Ghost, and which are by Him to be raised unto eternal life, and to be glorified,--are to be venerated by the faithful ... Moreover, in the invocation of saints, the veneration of relics, and the sacred use of images, every superstition shall be removed, all filthy lucre be abolished”
  • The Orthodox Faith, vol. III, 'The Fourth Crusade'
    “They pillaged Hagia Sophia and other churches, desecrating the altars and stealing countless relics and other holy objects.”
  • John Paul II, address to Archbishop Christodoulos, 4 May 2001
    “The fact that they were Latin Christians fills Catholics with deep regret.”
  • Smalcald Articles (1537), Part II, Article II, 22-23
    “The relics, in which there are found so many falsehoods and tomfooleries concerning the bones of dogs and horses, that even the devil has laughed at such rascalities, ought long ago to have been condemned, even though there were some good in them; …”
    Read the full passage
    “The relics, in which there are found so many falsehoods and tomfooleries concerning the bones of dogs and horses, that even the devil has laughed at such rascalities, ought long ago to have been condemned, even though there were some good in them; and so much the more because they are without the Word of God; being neither commanded nor counseled, they are an entirely unnecessary and useless thing.”
  • Same, 23
    “But the worst is that [they have imagined that] these relics had to work indulgence and the forgiveness of sins [and have revered them] as a good work and service of God, like the Mass, etc.”
  • A Treatise on Relics (1543), opening
    “In short, the desire for relics is never without superstition, and what is worse, it is usually the parent of idolatry.”
  • Same, opening
    “they cannot be handled and looked upon without being honoured, and in doing this men will very soon render them the honour which is due to Jesus Christ.”
  • Same, opening
    “Every one admits that the reason why our Lord concealed the body of Moses, was that the people of Israel should not be guilty of worshipping it.”
  • Same, on Geneva
    “In this town (Geneva) there was formerly, it is said, an arm of St Anthony; it was kissed and worshipped as long as it remained in its shrine; but when it was turned out and examined, it was found to be the bone of a stag. There was on the high …”
    Read the full passage
    “In this town (Geneva) there was formerly, it is said, an arm of St Anthony; it was kissed and worshipped as long as it remained in its shrine; but when it was turned out and examined, it was found to be the bone of a stag. There was on the high altar the brain of St Peter; so long as it rested in its shrine, nobody ever doubted its genuineness, for it would have been blasphemy to do so; but when it was subjected to a close inspection, it proved to be a piece of pumice-stone.”
  • Article XXII, as quoted in the Orthodox Church in America's manual (research/texts/relic_oca_essential_relics.txt)
    “Worshipping and Adoration, as well of Images as of Reliques, and also invocation of Saints, is a fond thing vainly invented, and grounded upon no warranty of Scripture, but rather repugnant to the Word of God.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1912), 'St. Thomas Becket', closing paragraph
    “The martyr's holy remains are believed to have been destroyed in September, 1538, when nearly all the other shrines in England were dismantled; but the matter is by no means clear”
  • Second Royal Injunctions of Henry VIII (1538), art. 6
    “great threats and maledictions of God, as things tending to idolatry and superstition, which of all other offences God Almighty does most detest and abhor”
Other readings
  • Protestant reading: the abuses were not accidents but the natural fruit of the practice, so reform required abolition.
  • Catholic reading: the abuses were real and condemned by the Church's own councils, but abuse does not remove right use; the destruction of shrines was itself a wrong.
Limits
  • The Becket entry in the Catholic Encyclopedia says his remains are believed to have been destroyed in 1538 but that the matter is by no means clear, and calls the story of a posthumous trial and burning probably apocryphal.
  • Calvin's Geneva examples are his own report, not independently documented.
  • Augustine is dated here by Thurston's 'end of the fourth century'; Of the Work of Monks is usually placed around 400.
  • John Paul II's 2001 words concern the sack of Constantinople by Latin Christians as a whole, not the relic thefts in particular.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

10HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Catholic scholars and authorities have themselves judged many relics false or doubtful. Herbert Thurston wrote in the Catholic Encyclopedia in 1911 of medieval treasuries crowded with unquestionably spurious relics, and in 1908 of more than 700 'holy thorns' that cannot all be authentic. The 1802 identification of a catacomb martyr named Philomena rested on tiles reused from an older grave, and on 14 February 1961 the Congregation of Rites ordered her feast struck from every calendar. In 2007 relics of Joan of Arc, recognised by the Church, were shown to come from an Egyptian mummy.

Rests on
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'Relics', by Herbert Thurston, on medieval abuses
    “all these are causes adequate to account for the multitude of unquestionably spurious relics with which the treasuries of great medieval churches were crowded.”
  • Same article, on the Crib of Santa Maria Maggiore
    “Mgr. Cozza Luzi frankly avows that all positive evidence for the authenticity of the relics of the Crib etc., is wanting before the eleventh century.”
  • Same article, on tolerating ancient doubtful relics
    “On the one hand no one is constrained to pay homage to the relic, and supposing it to be in fact spurious, no dishonour is done to God by the continuance of an error which has been handed down in perfect good faith for many centuries.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1908), 'Crown of Thorns', final paragraph
    “That all the reputed holy thorns of which notice has survived cannot by any possibility be authentic will be disputed by no one. M. de Mély has been able to enumerate more than 700 such relics.”
  • Catholic Encyclopedia (1911), 'St. Philomena', by J. P. Kirsch
    “On 25 May, 1802, during the quest for the graves of Roman martyrs in the Catacomb of Priscilla, a tomb was discovered and opened; as it contained a glass vessel it was assumed to be the grave of a martyr.”
  • Same article
    “composed a purely fictitious and romantic account of the supposed martyrdom of St. Philomena, who is not mentioned in any of the ancient sources.”
  • Same article
    “Consequently, since the disarrangement of the plates can scarcely be explained as arising from an error, Marucchi seems justified in concluding that the inscription and plates originally belonged to an earlier grave, and were later employed (now in the wrong order) to close another.”
  • Sacred Congregation of Rites, Instructio de calendariis particularibus, n. 33, Acta Apostolicae Sedis 53 (1961), p. 174; the OCR splits 'calen-dario' across a line, hence the elision
    “Festum autem S. Philumenae V. et M. (11 augusti) e quolibet ... expungatur”
  • Same instruction, dating clause, AAS 53 (1961), p. 180
    “Datum Romae, ex aedibus S. Rituum Congregationis, die 14 ... 1961”
  • Declan Butler, Nature 446, 593 (4 April 2007)
    “The relics were discovered in 1867 in a jar in the attic of a Paris pharmacy, with the inscription “Remains found under the stake of Joan of Arc, virgin of Orleans”. They were recognized by the Church, and are now housed in a museum in Chinon that …”
    Read the full passage
    “The relics were discovered in 1867 in a jar in the attic of a Paris pharmacy, with the inscription “Remains found under the stake of Joan of Arc, virgin of Orleans”. They were recognized by the Church, and are now housed in a museum in Chinon that belongs to the Archdiocese of Tours. ... Carbon-14 analysis dated the remains to between the third and sixth centuries BC.”
  • Same article
    “Philippe Charlier, a forensic scientist at Raymond Poincaré Hospital in Garches, near Paris, obtained permission to study the relics from the French church last year.”
  • Same article
    “The Church is ready to accept the results, according to Charlier.”
  • Directory on Popular Piety and the Liturgy (2001), 237
    “ensuring the authenticity of the relics exposed for the veneration of the faithful; where doubtful relics have been exposed for the veneration of the faithful, they should be discreetly withdrawn with due pastoral prudence”
Other readings
  • Calvin would say these cases prove his point about the whole practice. The Catholic reply is that they are cases of false objects, detected and withdrawn largely by Catholic scholarship, and that a forgery of a thing presupposes that the genuine thing was valued.
Limits
  • The 1961 instruction gives no reason for striking Philomena's feast. The archaeological doubts had been published by Marucchi and by Kirsch half a century earlier; the link between the two is an inference.
  • Thurston also argues that the Holy See was justified in tolerating some doubtful ancient relics, to avoid scandal where proof of spuriousness falls short of certainty.
  • The Nature report says the Church was ready to accept the result, on Charlier's word; no statement of the Archdiocese of Tours is quoted.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

11HistoricalStrong historical evidence Quotes checked

Catholics and Orthodox share the veneration of relics. The Second Council of Nicaea in 787 ordered that relics be placed in churches consecrated without them and that a bishop who consecrated a church without relics be deposed. Orthodox churches place a relic in the antimension, so every Divine Liturgy is celebrated over relics. In 2004 John Paul II returned relics of Gregory Nazianzen and John Chrysostom to Constantinople, and in 2019 Francis gave Patriarch Bartholomew fragments of the bones found under St Peter's.

Rests on
Other readings
  • The Orthodox manual states the union of saint and relic more strongly than most Catholic documents do, saying that encountering a relic means encountering the saint himself.
Limits
  • The 2004 texts do not say how or when the relics of Gregory and John Chrysostom came to Rome. Bartholomew speaks only of an involuntary separation imposed by unfortunate circumstances.
  • The OCA manual is a teaching text for adults in one Orthodox jurisdiction, not a conciliar statement.
Checked

Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).

Questions people ask next