For roughly the first thousand years there was no central process for recognising a saint. The local bishop judged whether a martyr had truly died for the faith and allowed the cult, and neighbouring churches could adopt it. Optatus of Milevis records that a Carthaginian woman, Lucilla, was rebuked shortly before a persecution, around AD 300, for kissing the bone of a man not yet acknowledged as a martyr, which shows a local check already at work.
- Against the Donatists, Book I, 16 (O. R. Vassall-Phillips translation, 1917, p. 32)
“It was said that she kissed a bone of some martyr or other—if he was a martyr—before she received the spiritual Food and Drink. Having then been corrected for thus touching—before she touched the Sacred Chalice—the bone of a dead man (if he was a martyr, at least he had not yet been acknowledged as such)”
- Translator's note 141.2 to Book I, 16 (Vassall-Phillips, 1917)
“Catholics in Africa were strictly forbidden to honour with religious worship any martyrs who had not been recognised as such (id est canonised = vindicati).”
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, History
“The decision as to the martyr having died for his faith in Christ, and the consequent permission of worship, lay originally with the bishop of the place in which he had borne his testimony.”
- Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), Beatification and Canonization, History
“St. Optatus of Mileve, writing at the end of the fourth century, tells us (De Schism, Donat., I, xvi, in P.L., XI, 916-917) of a certain noble lady, Lucilla, who was reprehended by Caecilianus, Archdeacon of Carthage, for having kissed before Holy …”
Read the full passage“St. Optatus of Mileve, writing at the end of the fourth century, tells us (De Schism, Donat., I, xvi, in P.L., XI, 916-917) of a certain noble lady, Lucilla, who was reprehended by Caecilianus, Archdeacon of Carthage, for having kissed before Holy Communion the bones of one who was either not a martyr or whose right to the title was unproved.”
- Canonization (Orthodox Church in America, from the 1970 book for the canonisation of St Herman of Alaska)
“For the first thousand years of the history of the Church saints were recognized without any formal rite of canonization.”
- Orthodox writers read the same early evidence as showing that recognition by the faithful was itself the canonisation, and regard the later Roman procedure as a legal overlay that the East never needed.
- A skeptical reader can take the Lucilla story as a quarrel about church politics, since Optatus tells it to blame her for starting the Donatist schism.
- Optatus was writing against the Donatists and presents Lucilla as the villain of their schism, so the story is told by a hostile witness.
- The date is approximate: Optatus places the rebuke before the persecution that followed, not in a given year.
- One anecdote shows that a check existed in Carthage; it does not show how every church handled its martyrs.
Every quote was compared word for word with the source (2026-09-27).



