Part II · Chapter 5
Did Jesus establish a visible Church?

Did Jesus just leave teachings, or did he set up a Church with leaders?

7 scenes · about 18 min read

The short answer

Both. Jesus taught, but he also chose twelve men, renamed one of them Rock and promised him keys. He gave the group authority to bind and loose: to forbid and to permit.

Why it matters to an ordinary person: if he did, following Jesus isn't only a private belief. It means belonging to a community you can find, with people answerable for its teaching, its and its care of you.

He told them the church, the community of his followers, would settle disputes. And he sent them out to teach everyone.

The keys aren't a throwaway image. They echo the prophet , where a royal steward gets the key of King David's house. He acts as the king's deputy while the king reigns.

This is where the Catholic case really begins, and where other Christians read the same verses differently.

Many Protestants read the rock as 's faith, not Peter himself. The accept Peter's first place among the , but not the authority of the , the of Rome, over every other bishop.

Follow the trail

Seven passages, from the prophet Isaiah to the Gospels, the four early accounts of Jesus's life, that describe leaders with real responsibilities, not just followers.

c. AD 29Revealed2 min read

Jesus chooses twelve, like Israel's tribes

Jesus, as the Gospels tell it

Around AD 29, after a night of prayer on a mountain, Jesus chose twelve of his followers. He named them apostles, people sent out. Israel had been made of twelve tribes, so the number showed God gathering his people again, around Jesus.

IWhat was going on

Jesus was a Jewish teacher from Nazareth in Galilee. By his time, Israel's twelve tribes were a memory.

Ten of them had been scattered when Assyria, the great empire of the day, conquered the northern kingdom of Israel in 722 BC.

The prophets had promised that one day God would gather all the tribes again. Many Jews in Jesus's day were waiting for that.

IIWhat was at stake

Jesus had many followers. There were crowds, women who travelled with him and supported him, and a wider group of disciples, people learning from him.

Was he only a teacher with fans? Or was he forming something, a people with a shape?

IIIWhat happened

Luke says Jesus spent a night on a mountain in prayer. Then he called his disciples and chose twelve of them, whom he named apostles.

He sent them to preach and heal in his name. And he promised them that in the new age they would sit on twelve thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel.

IVWhat came of it

The Twelve stayed with him and were taught apart from the crowds. They were with him at the Last Supper.

After Judas betrayed him, the others made sure the number was made whole again. The Acts of the Apostles, Luke's sequel to his Gospel, tells it in its first chapter.

Their names were remembered as a list, in all three of the first Gospels and in Acts.

Why it matters

The number is a claim. Jesus is gathering a new Israel around himself, with twelve men at its foundation.

Catholics see here the start of a visible Church with leaders, not just a movement of individual believers.

The Book of Revelation, the last book of the , pictures the heavenly city. The names of the twelve apostles are on its foundations.

Source: Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Matthew 19:28; Luke 22:30 (NABRE)

c. AD 29Revealed2 min read

Simon becomes Peter, the Rock

Jesus and Simon Peter, at Caesarea Philippi

Around AD 29, near the city of Caesarea Philippi in the north, Jesus gave his follower Simon a new name: Peter, the Rock. He promised to build his church on this rock, and promised him the keys of the kingdom.

IWhat was going on

Simon was a fisherman from Galilee, from the lakeside town of Bethsaida, who lived in Capernaum. He was one of the first Jesus called, and is named first in every list of the Twelve.

Caesarea Philippi was a mostly non-Jewish city at the foot of Mount Hermon, near the source of the river Jordan. It was built beside a rock cliff with a shrine to the god Pan.

Jesus took his disciples there, far from the crowds.

IIWhat was at stake

Jesus asks them: who do people say I am? They report the rumours: come back, Elijah, a prophet.

Then he asks: but who do you say that I am? Everything depends on the answer.

IIIWhat happened

Simon answers: you are the , the rescuer God had promised, the Son of the living God. Jesus says the Father revealed this to him.

Then Jesus renames him. In Aramaic, the language Jesus spoke, the name is Kepha, rock. In Greek it became Petros, Peter.

On this rock I will build my church, Jesus says, and the gates of the netherworld, the world of the dead, won't prevail against it.

He promises Peter the keys of the kingdom, and the power to bind and loose: to forbid and to permit.

IVWhat came of it

Straight afterwards Peter tries to talk Jesus out of going to his death. Jesus tells him off sharply: get behind me, Satan.

The rock is still a man who gets things wrong. The promise rests on God, not on Peter's strength.

VRead the source
Simon Peter said in reply, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God.” … “And so I say to you, you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church, and the gates of the netherworld shall not prevail against it. I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven.”
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Matthew 16:15–19 (NABRE)

Why it matters

In the Bible, when God changes someone's name, he gives them a new mission. Abram becomes , and Jacob becomes Israel.

Catholics read this passage as Jesus making Peter the foundation of a visible Church. They see him given an office, a lasting role.

Many Protestants read the rock as Peter's confession of faith. The Orthodox give Peter a real first place among the apostles. All three readings are set out below.

8th c. BCInference2 min read

Isaiah: a steward gets the king's key

The prophet Isaiah, in Jerusalem

In the 700s BC the prophet Isaiah announced that Eliakim would replace Shebna as the king's chief steward in Jerusalem. The key of the house of David, the royal family, would be placed on his shoulder. Jesus's words about keys echo this passage.

IWhat was going on

Isaiah was a prophet in Jerusalem in the 700s BC, under the kings descended from David. The Assyrian Empire was crushing its neighbours, and Judah, the southern kingdom, was in danger.

The king's household had a chief steward, the man over the house. It was the highest office under the king, going back to the court of Solomon, David's son.

IIWhat was at stake

The steward at the time, Shebna, was using his office for himself. Isaiah condemns him for carving out a grand tomb for his own glory while the nation was in danger.

The question was who could be trusted to act in the king's name.

IIIWhat happened

God, through Isaiah, says he will remove Shebna and give the office to Eliakim, son of Hilkiah. Eliakim will get Shebna's robe and sash and his authority. He will be a father to the people of Jerusalem.

And God will place the key of the House of David on his shoulder. What he opens, no one will shut; what he shuts, no one will open.

IVWhat came of it

Eliakim appears later in the Second Book of Kings, an history, as master of the palace. He negotiates for King Hezekiah when the Assyrian army stood outside Jerusalem around 701 BC.

The office didn't belong to him. It existed before him and was handed on after him.

VRead the source
I will place the key of the House of David on his shoulder; what he opens, no one will shut, what he shuts, no one will open.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Isaiah 22:20–22 (NABRE)

Why it matters

Jesus's words to Peter echo this passage: keys, opening and shutting, binding and loosing. A Jewish listener would hear a royal office being given.

Catholics argue that this is the shape of Peter's role. He is a steward, not a replacement king. He acts with authority handed to him, in a kingdom whose king is Christ.

Isaiah's passage has a sting at the end, and it belongs in the picture. A few verses on, the peg Eliakim was fixed like gives way, and the weight of his family brings it down (Isaiah 22:25). Even the faithful steward could fail.

Catholics take that as part of the shape too. The office stands, though the man holding it can fall, and Peter's own denial shows the same thing.

And it is an office that outlasts the man who holds it.

c. AD 29Revealed2 min read

Jesus says: tell the church

Jesus's teaching, in Matthew's Gospel

In Matthew's Gospel, Jesus teaches what to do when one believer wrongs another and won't admit it. The last appeal isn't to each person's own judgement. It's to the church, which can decide and expects to be heeded.

IWhat was going on

Matthew's Gospel collects Jesus's teaching into five long speeches. Chapter 18 is about life together in the community of his followers: humility, caring for the little ones, going after the lost sheep, and forgiving.

The word church, in Greek ekklesia, means a gathering of people called together. It appears in the Gospels only here and in Matthew 16.

IIWhat was at stake

Communities fall out. What should happen when one believer wrongs another and won't admit it?

Left alone, a quarrel either splits a group or gets buried. Jesus gives a process.

IIIWhat happened

First go to the person alone. If they won't listen, take one or two others, as the Jewish law required witnesses. If they still won't listen, tell the church.

If they refuse even the church, treat them like a Gentile, a non-Jew, or a tax collector. Both stood outside the community.

Then Jesus gives all the disciples the power to bind and loose.

IVWhat came of it

Binding and loosing were terms Jewish teachers used for forbidding and permitting. They also used them for putting someone under a ban or lifting it.

The aim isn't punishment. Jesus says this right after the story of the shepherd who leaves ninety-nine sheep to find one. Right after, he teaches Peter to forgive seventy-seven times.

Matthew himself had been a tax collector, until Jesus called him to follow.

VRead the source
If he refuses to listen to them, tell the church. If he refuses to listen even to the church, then treat him as you would a Gentile or a tax collector. Amen, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Matthew 18:17–18 (NABRE)

Why it matters

Matthew 18 assumes a community that can judge, decide and be recognised as speaking with authority. Faith isn't left as a private matter.

Here the power to bind and loose is given to all the disciples together. At Caesarea Philippi, in Matthew 16, it's given to Peter alone.

Catholics read both together: the apostles as a group, with Peter at their head.

c. AD 33Revealed2 min read

Jesus prays for Peter at the Last Supper

Jesus and Peter, in a room in Jerusalem

Around AD 33, at his last supper in Jerusalem, Jesus told his apostles that Satan wanted to sift them all like wheat. But he had prayed for Peter, and Peter was to strengthen the others.

IWhat was going on

It's the night before Jesus died, at time, in a room in Jerusalem. He had just given them the bread and wine as his body and blood.

Then, Luke says, the apostles started arguing about which of them was the greatest. Jesus told them that the greatest must be like a servant.

IIWhat was at stake

Jesus knew what was coming: his arrest, and his friends running away. The group was about to be shaken apart.

Who would hold them together when it happened?

IIIWhat happened

Jesus turns to Peter by his old name: Simon, Simon. Satan, the enemy of God, has asked to sift all of you like wheat. In Greek the you is plural: all of them.

But I have prayed for you, he says, and here the you is singular, that your faith may not fail. And once you have turned back, strengthen your brothers.

IVWhat came of it

Peter insisted he was ready to go to prison and to death. Jesus told him that before the cock crowed he would deny him three times. That night he did, and went out and wept.

But after the resurrection Jesus appeared to Peter on his own. In Acts, Peter is the one who stands up and speaks for the others at , when the apostles first preached in public.

VRead the source
“Simon, Simon, behold Satan has demanded to sift all of you like wheat, but I have prayed that your own faith may not fail; and once you have turned back, you must strengthen your brothers.”
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Luke 22:31–32 (NABRE)

Why it matters

One man is singled out, not because he is strongest, but so that he can steady the rest.

Catholics see this as the heart of the job of the pope, the bishop of Rome: to strengthen the faith of his brothers. It's a role given to a man who failed, and was forgiven.

c. AD 33Revealed2 min read

Feed my sheep: Peter is given a job

The risen Jesus and Peter, by the Sea of Galilee

John's Gospel tells that the risen Jesus met Peter by the Sea of Galilee. Peter had denied him three times. Now Jesus asked him three times if he loved him, and each time gave him a job: feed my sheep.

IWhat was going on

Chapter 21 of John's Gospel reads like an epilogue, added after the book's first ending. It may have been added by John's disciples. The Catholic Church receives it as part of the Gospel.

After the , Peter and six others had gone back to fishing on the Sea of Galilee. They caught nothing all night.

IIWhat was at stake

Peter had sworn he would never deny Jesus. Then he did, three times, beside a charcoal fire in the high priest's courtyard.

Could he still lead, or even be trusted, after that? He had to live with what he'd done.

IIIWhat happened

At dawn a man on the shore told them to cast the net to the right, and it filled. The disciple Jesus loved, traditionally John, recognised the Lord, and Peter jumped into the water. Jesus had breakfast ready, on a charcoal fire.

After they ate, Jesus asked Peter three times: do you love me? The third time Peter was hurt. He said: Lord, you know everything; you know that I love you.

Each time Jesus answered with a job: feed my lambs, tend my sheep, feed my sheep.

IVWhat came of it

Then Jesus told Peter that when he was old, someone else would dress him and lead him where he didn't want to go. John adds that this showed the kind of death by which Peter would glorify God.

Early Christian tradition holds that Peter was in Rome under the emperor Nero, in the 60s AD.

VRead the source
He said to him, “Feed my lambs.” … “Tend my sheep.” … “Feed my sheep.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · John 21:15–17 (NABRE)

Why it matters

Jesus doesn't just forgive Peter. He hands him the care of the whole flock. Each denial is answered with a question and a job.

Catholics read this as Peter being made shepherd of the Church, a role the bishops of Rome have claimed to carry on.

Other Christians read it as one apostle being personally restored, with no successor in view.

c. AD 33Revealed2 min read

Jesus sends the apostles to all nations

The risen Jesus and the eleven, in Galilee

At the end of Matthew's Gospel, the risen Jesus meets the eleven remaining apostles on a mountain in Galilee. He sends them to make disciples of all nations, baptising and teaching them, and promises to be with them always.

IWhat was going on

After the resurrection the eleven remaining apostles went to a mountain in Galilee, where Jesus had told them to go.

Matthew is honest about the scene. When they saw him, they worshipped, but some doubted.

IIWhat was at stake

Jesus was about to leave them. Until then he had sent them only to the people of Israel.

What was his mission to become without him there in person? And who would carry it on?

IIIWhat happened

Jesus says all authority in and on earth has been given to him. Then he sends them: go and make disciples of all nations.

They are to baptise, to wash people in water as the sign of joining him. They are to do it in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the , and teach people to keep everything he commanded.

And he promises: I am with you always, until the end of the age.

IVWhat came of it

The apostles carried the message out from Jerusalem across the Roman world and beyond, as the Book of Acts and early tradition describe.

The Didache, a church handbook from around AD 100, already uses the same words for . It names the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.

VRead the source
Go, therefore, and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you.
Sacred Scripture (New American Bible, Revised Edition) · Matthew 28:18–20 (NABRE)

Why it matters

This sending out presumes people with the authority to do it. And it doesn't end with the eleven. They were going to die, but the promise runs until the end of the age.

Catholics read that as a promise to a Church that goes on through the people the apostles appointed after them.

That leads to the next chapter, on : the apostles' authority handed on to the bishops after them.

Reading the evidence

Why Catholics read it this way

Catholics read these texts as the founding of a visible community with leaders, not just the gathering of an audience.

The keys, binding and loosing, the church settling disputes in Matthew 18, and the sending out in Matthew 28 all point the same way. They need people who can act in 's name, and whom others recognise as doing so.

The passage from Isaiah is the hinge of the argument about Peter. A steward with the key of David's house isn't a replacement king. He's a deputy, with authority handed to him.

He uses it on the king's behalf, and the office passes to another, as it passed from Shebna to Eliakim. Catholics argue that Peter's office has exactly this shape.

The Catholic Church doesn't claim this passage by itself proves the papacy as it is today. Its institutions took centuries to develop.

It claims that a particular office, given to a particular man in a text this early, is the seed of what came later. The next chapters set out to show the seed growing.

It began with a fisherman who had denied Jesus three times, and was forgiven on a beach and sent to feed his flock.

Reading the evidence

How others read the same evidence

Other Christians and historians look at the same documents and see something different. Here is each reading in its own terms.

Most Protestant readers

Many hold that the rock is Peter's confession of faith, not Peter himself. Or that Peter is the rock only as the first to confess it, with no successor in view.

They note that Matthew 18 gives binding and loosing, the power to forbid and permit, to all the , not to Peter alone. And the never describes Peter's particular role being handed on.

Eastern Orthodox readers

The Orthodox generally accept that Peter held a real first place among the apostles. They accept that the bishop of Rome inherited a first place of honour.

But they deny that this gives him power to govern bishops everywhere. They read the same texts as spoken to the apostles as a group, with Peter as their spokesman.

Critical scholars

Some argue that Matthew 16:18 reflects the situation of Matthew's own community, not the words of Jesus. One reason they give: church is an unusual word in the .

Others reply that the wordplay on Kepha, Aramaic for rock, is evidence of an early tradition, not a late one.

The deeper critical case is about Jesus himself. Albert Schweitzer, in 1906, argued that Jesus expected God to end the world soon. A man who expected that, on this view, wouldn't found an institution.

Alfred Loisy, a French Catholic priest and scholar later excommunicated, put it in one line in 1902: Jesus foretold the kingdom, and what came was the Church.

Catholics answer that the founding acts happen in Jesus's own lifetime and assume time after him. He chose the Twelve, gave Simon a new name, told them to repeat the supper in his memory, and said no one knows the day or the hour. , writing about twenty-five years later, already speaks of the Twelve as a known group.

Don’t take our word for it

Check it yourself

Everything above rests on documents you can open and read. They’re all here.

Read the sources yourself3
Offices, not just followers5 steps

Look at what Jesus does in these scenes. He appoints, names, gives keys, prays for Peter, tells him to feed the flock, and sends the apostles out.

They describe a structure, with people responsible for other people.

  1. A defined group of twelve

    Chosen on purpose, numbered on purpose, and later treated as a body that can be added to.

    “Then they gave lots to them, and the lot fell upon Matthias, and he was counted with the eleven apostles.”
  2. An office that outlives its holder

    When Judas is gone, the group doesn't shrink. Peter quotes a psalm about the empty place, using the word for an office.

    “For it is written in the Book of Psalms: ‘Let his encampment become desolate, and may no one dwell in it.’ And: ‘May another take his office.’”
  3. Authority to decide, with consequences

    Binding and loosing is what Jewish teachers called making firm decisions about what is allowed.

    “whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.”
  4. A named individual with a particular role

    The keys, the new name, the prayer that his faith won't fail, and the charge, three times over, to feed the flock.

    “you are Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church … I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven.”
  5. And a foundation described as the apostles themselves

    Paul, writing to the Christians of Ephesus, uses building words for the apostles themselves, not for a book.

    “you are fellow citizens with the holy ones and members of the household of God, built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus himself as the capstone.”
Questions people ask next