Where it all went wrong
This is what the garden was meant to be, what broke, and why God didn’t just forgive and move on.
So how did we all end up on that road, the one that ends in death? It goes back to the very beginning, to in the garden.
If you don’t know the story, here it is in a few lines.
The says God made the first two people, Adam and Eve, and put them in a garden where they had everything they needed.
They could eat from any tree there, except one. God told them: don’t eat from that one, or you will die.
Then a serpent came along and told them God was lying.
Eat it, it said, and you’ll be like God, deciding good and evil for yourselves. So they ate. And everything changed.
People hear that story and laugh: all this over a piece of fruit?
But whether you read it literally or not, the point was never the fruit. The point is trust.
Think of a parent and a small child.
The parent says: trust me on this, okay? If you bang your head on the wall, you’re going to hurt yourself.
Then someone else walks in and whispers to the kid: nah, your parents are just messing with you. It doesn’t hurt. They just don’t want you to have fun.
So the kid tries it, and gets hurt.
To see why trust matters so much, you have to see what the garden was meant to be. God made everything good.
People lived close to him and close to each other, in harmony with the animals and with the whole of creation.
There was no anxiety, no loneliness, no fear of dying. Creation was never meant to feel any of that.
That’s what was at stake when God said trust me. In other words: I am the source of everything good, so stay close to me.
Then another voice, which the Bible pictures as a serpent, said: he’s lying to you, and you can decide for yourself what’s good and what’s bad.
Adam and Eve chose to go their own way instead of trusting God.
They grabbed an independence that was never theirs to take, and they got hurt, just like God said they would.
People laugh at the garden story: all this over a piece of fruit? What do you think it’s really about?
Pick an answer below.
When Adam and Eve walked away from God, the source of good, the harmony broke. Every one of their relationships cracked at once:
Anxiety, loneliness, the fear of death: the very things I was drowning in after that day on the rooftop, when I thought I was dying, were never part of the design.
And the break didn’t stop with Adam and Eve. The Church’s name for it is original sin, but the idea is simple.
They didn’t just break a rule. They broke a relationship.
We were made to live close to God, and that closeness was lost, not just for them but for everyone after them.
Every one of us is born with a habit: putting ourselves first, and doing things our own way, even when we know better.
Nobody has to teach a toddler to grab a toy and shout mine, or to lie about who broke the vase.
You see it on the news every day: wars, greed, people using each other.
And if I’m honest, I could see it in myself too. I had trusted myself over God my whole life.
You might be wondering: why didn’t God just forgive Adam and Eve and move on?
He can, and he does. Forgiving is his to give. But forgiving isn’t the same as fixing. Picture this.
A dad loves his son, and has always been good to him.
But the son wants to live his own way. One day he walks out, and cuts his dad off completely.
His dad did nothing to deserve it. It breaks his heart, and for years he lives with that hurt.
His dad keeps calling. For years the son won’t pick up the phone.
He’s busy partying instead, drinking night after night with his friends, and slowly it wrecks his liver. One day he ends up in hospital, and the doctors say he’s dying.
His dad hears, and comes straight away. The son can barely look at him, but he whispers I’m sorry.
Right there at the bed, his dad forgives him for every hurtful word and every missed call. He forgives him completely.
But forgiving him doesn’t fix his liver. The son is still dying. No magic wand, bibbidi-bobbidi-boo, makes that go away.
So the dad does the one thing that can save him. He gives his son part of his own liver.
Nobody forced the dad to give part of his liver. He chose to. And notice what he didn’t do.
He didn’t make his son suffer first, or wait to be paid back for all those years, before he’d forgive him. The forgiveness was free.
But saving him cost the dad something real. A big operation, weeks of pain while he recovered, and a small but real chance he wouldn’t survive it himself.
That’s our situation. Sin isn’t a fine we owe. It’s the son’s liver: we walked away from the source of life, and it’s killing us.
God forgives freely. And to heal us, he chose to do what the dad did: give himself. Hold on to that.
Now, back to the habit we’re all born with: putting ourselves first, and doing things our own way, even when we know better.
That’s what the Church calls . So is it unfair, being born with something that wasn’t even our doing?
The Church is clear that it isn’t a personal fault you committed.
It’s a wound we inherited, a bit like a child born into a broken family: they didn’t cause the break, but they grow up living with it.
We’re born with a habit we didn’t choose. Does that seem fair to you?
Pick an answer below.
And it would be unfair if God had left us alone with it. But he didn’t.
That habit of putting ourselves first is real, but it doesn’t control us.
We can still choose. And God has never stopped showing us the way back.
Think of a lighthouse on a dark coast.
It doesn’t grab the wheel and steer your boat for you. But it shows you where the rocks are, and where the harbour is.
You still choose where to steer, but you’re never sailing blind. That’s how God has guided people all through history.
But a light on the coast doesn’t fix what broke. The relationship was still broken, and the wrong still had to be put right.
So did God just leave it there? No. The rest of the Bible is his rescue plan.