What kind of book it is
This is about the years before the first copies, what kind of books the Gospels are, and what archaeology has found.
The years before the first copies
The oldest copies we have of the , which are the four accounts of Jesus’s life, go back to about AD 200, with scraps a bit earlier.
So what about the years in between, from Jesus’s life to those first copies?
How do I know the story wasn’t changed then? A few things convinced me.
Take the Temple. Jesus said the great Temple in Jerusalem, the centre of Jewish worship, would be torn down, not one stone left on another.
In AD 70 the Romans did exactly that. They burned it to the ground, and it has never been rebuilt.
Now, if you were writing a Gospel (an account of Jesus’s life) after that, you’d be dying to add: and it happened, just like he said.
None of the Gospel writers do. The Gospels and Acts (the history of the early Church) talk about the Temple as if it’s still standing.
Acts ends with , one of the first Christian leaders, still alive and under house arrest in Rome, around AD 62.
There’s not a word about his death, or the death of his fellow leader , or the Temple falling.
For some scholars that’s a strong hint that Acts, and at least some of the Gospels, were written before AD 70, with the eyewitnesses still around.
Others put the Gospels a little later, between 70 and 100. Either way, they were written within living memory.
Acts ends with Paul still alive, around AD 62, and never mentions the Temple falling. What do you make of that?
Pick an answer below.
Why write it down at all? Most people back then couldn’t read.
The faith spread by voice, with people who had seen it happen telling others. For thirty years, that was enough.
Then in AD 64 Rome burned, and the emperor Nero blamed the Christians. Peter and Paul were killed in the years that followed.
The people who had seen it with their own eyes were dying, and if the story was going to survive, it had to be written down.
That’s when the writing picks up. An early , Papias, says that Mark, whose name is on one of the four Gospels, wrote down what Peter had preached.
What kind of book it is
And look at what kind of book it is. It isn’t a fairy tale with dragons and far-off kingdoms.
The Gospels read like reporting: named governors, named high priests, named towns, named witnesses.
Luke, one of the four Gospel writers, opens his Gospel by saying he checked everything with the people who were there from the beginning.
That one got me personally.
I do user research for a living, and Luke reads like a researcher: curious, careful about his sources, and maybe a bit of a skeptic himself.
Luke wasn’t there, so he went and asked the people who were, and then wrote it down in order. I know that process. I do it every week.
The rest of the is mostly letters.
Real letters to real churches, in Corinth, Rome, Ephesus and elsewhere, most of them from Paul, some from Peter, John, James and others.
They deal with the real problems those churches had.
Take Paul’s first letter to the church in Corinth, a city in Greece, from the mid-50s.
Christians there shared a meal of bread and wine to remember Jesus’s last supper with his friends. Most churches today call it .
But the rich were eating first and getting drunk, while the poor turned up to find nothing left. So Paul scolds them.
Nobody scolds a church that doesn’t exist.
Matthew, Mark, Luke and John: four accounts of Jesus’s life, death and rising.
What the apostles, Jesus’s closest followers, did next, written by Luke. It ends with Paul in Rome, around AD 62.
Thirteen under Paul’s name, plus letters from Peter, John, James, Jude, and one to the Hebrews. Written to churches and people with names and addresses.
A vision given to John, written to seven real churches in what is now Turkey.
And the Old Testament
The , the Jewish Scriptures written before Jesus, held up the same way.
Before 1947, our oldest Hebrew copy of the book of was from around AD 1000.
Then the turned up in caves by the Dead Sea, with a complete scroll of Isaiah about a thousand years older.
Side by side, the two read almost exactly the same.
One thing to be clear about, because it’s easy to mix up.
All of this shows that the message reached us the way it was written. It doesn’t show that the message is true.
That’s a separate question, and it’s what comes next.
Does the ground back it up?
Then there’s archaeology. In 1961, at Caesarea on the coast of Israel, archaeologists found a stone with ’s name and title carved into it: prefect of Judea.
Pilate was the Roman governor who ordered Jesus to be .
In 1990, in Jerusalem, a family bone box turned up inscribed “Joseph son of Caiaphas”, most likely the high priest who handed Jesus over to the Romans.
The Pool of Siloam, where John’s Gospel says Jesus healed a blind man, was dug up in 2004.
The Pool of Bethesda, which the same Gospel describes with its porches, was found too.
In 1968 a heel bone was found in a Jerusalem tomb with an iron nail still through it: a crucified man, given a proper burial in a tomb.
So the Gospels’ account of Jesus being laid in a tomb after crucifixion isn’t far-fetched.
At Delphi in Greece, an inscription naming Gallio as governor lets us date Paul’s time in Corinth, the one Acts describes, to around AD 51.
Even small details check out.
In Acts, Luke calls the city officials in Thessalonica, a city in Greece, “politarchs”, a title rarely found in ancient literature, and inscriptions from the city use exactly that word.
Archaeology can’t prove a miracle. But again and again, the people, places and small details the Gospels and Acts name turn out to be real.
These aren’t stories set once upon a time.
So does archaeology prove the Gospels are true?
Pick an answer below.